Blogger vs Wordpress: Which is best for SEO and How Does Self-Hosting Fit Into the Equation?

94
rate or flag this page

By iBuildâ„¢ Branding


The Great Blogging Debate: Blogger or Wordpress?
The Great Blogging Debate: Blogger or Wordpress?

Introduction to the Big Blogging Debate

This is becoming an age-old question in the world of blogging and SEO. Many will argue that Blogger is a better platform among the free blogs, being that it's owned by Google. Others will argue that Wordpress offers more to the average blogger. In reality, each blogging platform has its own features & benefits which make it a viable choice for the average, amateur blogger. However, when it comes to blogging for your business and becoming an authority blogger, only one platform makes the cut. I'll explain why and which platform will work best for specific functions.


The differences in the Blogger & Wordpress platforms can be seen in the design and interface of their sites.
The differences in the Blogger & Wordpress platforms can be seen in the design and interface of their sites.

Blogger Highlights & Features

  • user-friendly interface
  • drag & drop module functionality
  • easily allows HTML & JavaScript
  • easily add custom header images
  • Open ID sign-in functionality
  • automatic inclusion in Google Blog Search

Wordpress Highlights & Features

  • great for SEO
  • addtional exposure from Wordpress directory
  • popular tags show up separately in organic search results
  • allows importing of content from other platforms
  • easily add custom header images

  • progressive & detailed traffic stats

Blogger vs. Wordpress: The Breakdown

In order to compare Wordpress and Blogger, it's important to know their features and how they affect your experience. We'll start with Blogger. Blogger is a quite user-friendsly and doesn't require any knowledge of HTML, CSS or experience with web hosting. It allows bloggers of all experience levels to get up and running in just a few minutes. Blogger also allows added functionality, including the ability to incorporate widgets, videos, polls etc. in the sidebar of your blog. What's more, Blogger's interface allows you to easily drag & drop different sections into place any time you want to change the look & feel of your blog. In terms of policies, Blogger pretty much allows you to blog about anything and everything, making it a good platform for affiliate marketers. However, in terms of SEO Blogger is not your best bet for showing up in search engines, despite now being owned by Google. When it comes to Google as a search engine, you're more likely to see relevant tags and searches from Wordpress than from Blogger. I have experienced creating a blog on Wordpress and over the course of 4 months easily reaching 150+ hits per day and a Google PageRank of 3, while moving the same blog to Blogger (after some issues with Wordpress' Terms of Use) and only achieving a PR of 2 and about 30 to 40 hits per day in the same amount of time.

The first thing to understand about Wordpress is that there are 2 different versions. The first version would be the free, shared-hosting version at wordpress.com. This is usually the easiest option to get up & running in just a few minutes. The second version is self-hosted and available as a download from wordpress.org. For this version you'd need to purchase your own hosting. Wordpress' free, shared-hosting version is much better in terms of SEO than Blogger. Not only do blogs show up in Wordpress' high-traffic directory, popular tags are often listed in organic search results of Google & Yahoo! linking to the most recent/popular blogs using that tag. Wordpress blog posts also tend to show up separately in organic search results more readily than Blogger or any other blogging platform. Wordpress' interface is a little more advanced than Blogger, though still with some drag & drop functionality. Unlike Blogger, Wordpress limits what kinds of widgets you can add to your blog's sidebar. Certain forms of HTML and JavaScript are not allowed, limiting your ability to embed flash slideshows etc. Furthermore, Wordpress specifically states in their Terms that blogs about certain topics such as home business & affiliate marketing are not allowed. So even though the free version of Wordpress is better for SEO, it's not the best option for bloggers who are involved in home business or affiliate marketing.

So Which is Best?

Well, that really depends on what the main goal or function of your blog is. In a nutshell, if you're reasons for blogging have anything to do with business or monetization through programs such as Google adsense, I'd suggest purchasing your own hosting and installing the Wordpress.org platform. If your blog is purely recreational in nature, but you'd like added functionality such as incorporating flickr photos, YouTube videos or other widgets, I suggest going with Blogger. While the free version of Wordpress is great for SEO, there are limits to what you're allowed to blog about and even more limits as to what functionality you can add.


Self-Hosted Blogging Tips

  • be sure to read installation instructions before attempting to install Wordpress
  • download an FTP client such as FileZilla for easy installation to connect to
  • your hosting via FTP, you can usually use the following address: ftp.yourdomain.com
  • to install themes, transfer them to the wp-content/themes folder
  • to install plug-ins, transfer them to the wp-content/plug-ins folder
  • if something goes wrong with a theme or plug-in, reinstall over the existing theme or plug-in to fix the problem
  • always back up your content, either using your hosting's automatic backup feature, or by creating a separate directory and copying your current files to it
  • some plug-ins require a Wordpress api key, which is located on your profile within your wordpress.com account
  • if you need a Wordpress api key, you can easily get one by creating an account at wordpress.com & selecting the "just give me a username" option
  • if Wordpress isn't working correctly, you may need to update your version for bug fixes. Log into your administrative panel to see if there are any update messages.

Self-hosted Blogs: The Benefits

Now, if you're blogging for your business and looking for a solution that offers both functionality and great SEO capabilities, it's best to purchase your own hosting and install the Wordpress platform from Wordpress.org. First off, you won't be bound to the same restricting Terms of Use as you would be with the free, shared-hosting version of Wordpress (wordpress.com). This means that you're blog can be completely commecial in nature and include as much or as little self-promotion and advertising as you feel necessary. Furthermore, free plug-ins allow you to add a variety of functions to your blog, from external SEO and traffic stats to external RSS feeds, widgets, geo-tracking (maps which show where your readers are coming from) and even social bookmarking icons and the ability to update your Twitter account each time you make a new blog post. The use of HTML and JavaScript are also allowed so that you can embed flash slideshows, videos and widgets, whereas this functionality is blocked with the free, shared-hosting version of Wordpress. Last, a self-hosted blog can be attached to your business's website, providing fresh content each time you create a post or someone leaves a comment. This improves the SEO and search engine ranking of both your blog and the website it's attached to, meaning that you don't have to update your actual website to as much to increase your rank. Finally, self-hosted blogs come with a much larger variety of templates, allowing you to create a more original look for your blog (as opposed to the set 20 or so templates that are available with the shared-hosting version). And if you know a little HTML and/or CSS, you can take it a step further and customize your blog to match the look & feel of your website for a completely unique look (for an example, click here).

While many stray away from this option because of the perceived costs, hosting can cost as little as $7 a month. Not to mention, if you've already got your own commercial website then you've already got hosting! Many hosting providers such as Yahoo! already have the Wordpress platform installed; you need only to activate it and choose your template to get started!

The only draw-back to creating a self-hosted blog is initial set-up. While you don't have to be completely techy, it does help to know things like CSS. It also helps to know a bit about hosting & FTP clients in order to properly install the Wordpress platform. Fortunately, there are plenty of tutorials out there that can teach you how to install Wordpress into your hosting account, and plug-ins usually come with install instructions as well. If you're willing to sit down for about 2 hours, you can successfully install a blog that's fully equipped with SEO built in and ready for the web! And for those who don't want to bother with the extra hassle of optimizing your blog for the search engines, there are plenty of programs which offer pre-optimized Wordpress install packs with the proper plug-ins already incorporated. It may take more time to get up & running than the free, shared-hosting version, but the benefits are far greater!

Print   —   Rate it:  up  down  flag this hub

Comments

RSS for comments on this Hub

belief713 profile image

belief713  says:
14 months ago

Thanks for answering my request. Great response. I tried setting up a blog on Wordpress a while back with the free version but didn't like how limited I was. I did see good results with the search engines as it was listed #1 many times for the different key phrases.

I then tried purchasing my own hosting and ran into some problems with installing themes and widgets. I couldn't help but laugh when you said 2 hours! I spent HOURS! A lot - and I consider myself fairly techy. I'm no novice but no amateur either. Well, I finally worked out the kinks and things went pretty smooth after that - until I did something and lost ALL of my content. That kind of scared me away from self-hosting and that's actually when I met HubPages :) 

A few months ago I started a blog on Blogger but I'm not impressed at all with the results. I haven't done much with it content wise. And I do love how easy it is to lay things out and how easy it is to monetize the site and more, but I don't like that I don't have readers :) And I like many of Wordpress themes and templates I see much better.

I'm fine tuning my skills at writting and using key phrases and all and it's definitely working. And not to mention I really do enjoy it. If I wasn't so busy with life and working, being a mom, wife, etc I would spend much more time committed to publishing online.

I've been thinking about switching back over to WordPress and I think this Hub really helped me make my decision. Thanks again for sharing...

iBuildâ„¢ Branding profile image

iBuildâ„¢ Branding  says:
14 months ago

No problem, glad it helped. There are a few more notes that I'd like to share that may help make things a bit easier for you.

First off, if you do have a blog currently on any other platform such as Blogger or TypePad, there is a feature (in both the shared-hosting version of Wordpress and the self-hosted version) which will allow you to import your posts, pages and comments into your new Wordpress blog. So there's no need to copy & paste or write everything all over again!

Next, if you have your own hosting, there is usually a feature which allows you to back up the content of your site (including your blog). You may have to search a bit or possibly even contact your hosting provider for support, but it's usually fairly easy to back your content up so that you don't lose all of that hard work.

If there is no ready-made feature for backing up content, you can easily do it yourself by creating a new directory in your hosting, naming it something like "content backup" and copying your content files from your live Wordpress blog into that backup directory.

I'll freshen this hub up with some tips on self-hosting as time goes on. In the meantime, good luck staring your new blog!

modo  says:
14 months ago

my question is Blogger and Wordpress, which do you think google will rank better?

Volunteer NC  says:
12 months ago

Excellent article, I'm curious as well. Have you noticed blogger ranking higher in serp because its owned by google?

iBuildâ„¢ Branding profile image

iBuildâ„¢ Branding  says:
12 months ago

To modo & Volunteer NC: It seems to me that Wordpress still ranks more highly than Blogger, despite the fact that Blogger is owned by Google. Wordpress seems to have some built-in SEO tools that Blogger just doesn't have. I've been keeping an eye on this for a few years now, and the position doesn't seem to have changed. Hope that helps! <!-- @page { size: 8.5in 11in; margin: 0.79in } TD P { margin-bottom: 0in } P { margin-bottom: 0.08in } <!-- @page { size: 8.5in 11in; margin: 0.79in } TD P { margin-bottom: 0in } P { margin-bottom: 0.08in } -

Razib Ahmed  says:
12 months ago

Thanks for writing this entry. I wished you have discussed some more about having a domain and then using Blogger hosting.

SEO Resources profile image

SEO Resources  says:
10 months ago

I have always used self hosted wordpress blog, and love it.

english-blinds-uk profile image

english-blinds-uk  says:
10 months ago

I prefer to have wordpress installed on my own server. Once you have it set up the flexibility and functionality available gives you much more SEO possibilities.

Gareth  says:
10 months ago

I kind of new this was the best option for blogging, but this has confirmed it. Will get started. After studying SEO full time for the past year, I am not sure about your SEO built in comment. It may have some free open source seo tools, but this will not ensure your blog is fully optimized. That needs a lot of time and effort...

SEO Pune  says:
10 months ago

Blogger is very user friedly and fast while wordpress is slow and need some training for setup blog - Hemang

http://econceptinfotech.com/online-public-relation

Search Engine Optimization Company  says:
9 months ago

We are india based SEO Company. We use Blogger.com as it is easy to use and Google gives more traffice to blogspot site.

http://seoservicecompany.net/seo-australia-sydney-

Alison  says:
9 months ago

We currently have a corporate blog www.betterbraces.com/blog that our web platform provided us with. The functionality is minimal and we recognice the need to switch to Word Press's hosted version. My concern about making the switch is related to SEO. Will switching to a Word Press blog hurt my SEO current efforts? If we host the Word Press version of the blog on our server, will we still reap the SEO benefits?

http://www.cashcratepays.com  says:
8 months ago

Excellent post, I think I am going to try to use Wordpress for now, much more customization and more professional looking. Also no dates in the url link. Thanks and cheers!

nms profile image

nms  says:
7 months ago

you can make any pahe search engine friendly.......just apply right SEO

http://hubpages.com/hub/Search-Engine-optimization

sulumits retsambew  says:
7 months ago

Wordpress is best

righteous  says:
6 months ago

Is there a technical reason why wordpress tops blogger when it comes to SEO?

seodude16  says:
6 months ago

enjoyed reading this. I personally prefer wordpress, but I do know of many people that feel that blogger is better for seo especially out of the box.

Find Online Schools  says:
6 months ago

Thank you for this blog post, I have been debating on which blog platform to use for a new SEO site and now you have answered my questions!

blogcology  says:
6 months ago

It's great that Wordpress is so SEO friendly, less work to do.

blogcology  says:
6 months ago

It's great that Wordpress is so SEO friendly, less work to do.

cjjohn profile image

cjjohn  says:
5 months ago

Excellent Article!

Oxford  says:
5 months ago

WP gives me a head ache from installing up to changing the header. WP is the WORST of all! Not user friendly! It's difficult to handle.

Oxford  says:
5 months ago

WP gives me a head ache from installing up to changing the header. WP is the WORST of all! Not user friendly! It's difficult to handle.

belajar SEO  says:
5 months ago

Nice article. I prefer WP than Blogger if you want high traffic and SEO MOdification WP is the king. Blogger only for fun

seothomas profile image

seothomas  says:
4 months ago

Sweet Graphics man! The only bummer about using wordpress.com as an SEO tool sis that you may get banned. I got banned for using wordpress blog for seo and all my blogs (12 of them) were taken down!

The Happy Housewife  says:
4 months ago

Great post! I plan on sharing it with several bloggers who are debating whether or not to switch from Blogger to WP. I am familiar with the plug-in that allows you to import content from your Blogger blog to a WP blog, but what about images that are hosted on the blogger account. Is there a way to import them?

Thanks!

Toni

Unique Wedding ideas  says:
4 months ago

Thanks for sharing this - like everyone else I have been wondering the same thing - I am on Wordpress and will stick with it. I was wondering however if Blogger (due to its relationships with Google) would rank better in the SERPS though, but this seems to suggest not

Shot  says:
3 months ago

If i use a sub-domain to host my blog will my main domain still reap the rewards of any backlinks my my blog receives?

minthosk  says:
2 months ago

i think wordpress is better in SEO posts get indexed faster in search engine

Sally Dillon profile image

Sally Dillon  says:
2 months ago

I'm so glad that you mentioned that it is important to own your blog by hosting it on your own domain. I agree: WP is definitely the better SEO / SEM choice and there are a number of great SEO plugins for WP, too. If you want a custom WordPress theme, please check out my hub... http://hubpages.com/hub/Custom-WordPress-Theme-DNA

terrymill profile image

terrymill  says:
5 weeks ago

I think I am in the minority. I have used the free wordpress and blogger at the same time and found wordpress to be fairly difficult to navigate while blogger is so easy when it comes to set up, changing colors, background and fonts, and placement of widgets. I tried for days to reduce the font size of my blog headings and couldn't figure it out so I gave up. I went back to blogger.

Julesian profile image

Julesian  says:
4 weeks ago

Why not use both? I myself use actually all three, blogger.com, wordpress.org which is the hosted one, and the free version wordpress.com. I change my articles around as not to have the duplicate content. Sometimes I keep them all different. JR

johntriggerman profile image

johntriggerman  says:
4 weeks ago

I prefer WordPress as my CMS of choice. It's easy to use and well-loved by major SE's.

~ John

http://cpanelhostings.net/

irwanfazri profile image

irwanfazri  says:
4 weeks ago

This is very useful information for me. Thank you

Adam k.  says:
4 weeks ago

Nice hub. I appreciate. Thanks for the info. :) Also i have ben to traffic-bug and registered there. I used their software too. And it's working fantastic. My site has got indexed as well my page Rank has increased.

To register and get 30 days free trial on Traffic-Bug Here is the direct link http://www.traffic-bug.com/113.html It's a software which helps in indexing our websites as well as increasing page ranks. Also, it creates many backlinks. Check this out at http://www.traffic-bug-reviews.com I have tried this and it has worked.

lewgard profile image

lewgard  says:
2 weeks ago

This is by far the best comparison / explanation of Wordpress and Blogger I have read. I tried a self-hosted version of Wordpress a few years ago, but was having trouble uploading themes, plugins, etc. Perhaps it was just me, but I found it too difficult for my impatient mind.

I personally love Blogger. I was able to change my theme to accommodate more gadgets, content, etc. and to make it suit my topic. Blogger is very easy for those like me - want it done now and with ease.

I suppose it's personal preference; I suggest trying one then the other to get a feel for them both (provided you have the time)

ziplockbags profile image

ziplockbags  says:
2 weeks ago

Thanks! Really, it's such a pain trying to figure this stuff out. I would have paid someone to research this. Thank you for a high quality and useful article!

naveenkumarc profile image

naveenkumarc  says:
9 days ago

i have always been using blogger....may b i have to give wordpress a try.... thx for sharing dis article....really very helpful one....

modeca profile image

modeca  says:
7 days ago

I have Wordpress and Blogger sites. I must say that I'm overwhelmingly in favour of Wordpress. Blogger just seems a bit Mickey Mouse to me.

Chandrashekhar  says:
7 days ago

really good article....I am using Blogger from six month.But not satisfied with page rank.

http://freecomputercourses.blogspot.com

woodamarc profile image

woodamarc  says:
5 days ago

I have wordpress on my self hosted site. That was a great article. Wish I would have read this first before learning to work the bugs out. I have both blogger and wordpress noting the difference in capabilities and tracking. WP wins hands down. Thanks again for the extra info and good health to you and your family!

Submit a Comment

Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.


optional


  • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
  • Comments are not for promoting your hubs or other sites

working