Factors for selecting and evaluating children's books
83
QUESTIONS TO BE ASKING
There are many factors to take into consideration when selecting and evaluating books for children.
A predetermined set of factors ought to be kept in mind to make your search easier.
First and foremost, it is important to take into consideration the children's physical, cognitive, language, and moral developments, as well as what the interests and preferences are of the age group or groups you are recognizing.
Age group, per say, will not necessarily render completely in your choices, as many levels and types of levels in both reading and developmental, will probably be presented in each group of children. Whether the books you are choosing will be read or read to your child or group of children, will also be a factor. Other questions to ask on your search for the right books are,
- Are the books you are choosing going to provide enjoyment, an overall positive experience, and teach them something along the way?
- Will it get them asking appropriate questions?
- Will you be able to draw from it or transition into other activities, if that is a goal?
These are the types of questions to ask yourself while searching and evaluating books.
IMPORTANCE OF VARIETY
Is there a variety in the books you are choosing?
It is important to include as much poetry, historical fiction, biographies, non-fiction, realistic fiction, and fantasy as possible. All are undeniably essential for rounding a child's literary experience.
While some books may offer a single type of purpose, others are multilayered, and can be "multi tasked" and should be used as much as possible, especially when they are for use with a multi level group.
Multicultural and international books give a great understanding and appreciation for other cultures, so make your selections from a variety of cultures, and make sure that the characters depicted are positively portrayed.
As with all books, it is especially important that the details are accurate. If you accidentally find out that they are not (oops, but it happens), this is the perfect opportunity to talk about misinformation or mistakes, solutions, et cetera.
HOW TO FIND REFERENCES
In order to fully evaluate a book, you must, of course read it cover to cover, paying close attention to details. However finding the books to select and evaluate can, but doesn't have to be, tricky.
Get your hands on as many reliable references and lists as possible. If a book has been recognized as distinguished or outstanding, it can often aid in your own evaluation.
Newbery Award and Honors are given annually to distinguished U.S. authors and are for books geared for middle and upper elementary.
Caldecott Award and Honors are also received annually, and are given to U.S. illustrators. Links to these can be found in the related links section below; these links are part of the ALA or American Library Awards site. Here you can also find links to other awards such as the Mildred Batchelder Award.
There are also the Canadian Library Awards, and the Kate Greenaway Award to mention a few others. Links to these can also be found in the related links section below.
From A to Zoo is a great reference book to look at. Magazines on the subject are also plentiful; though possibly harder to get a hold of if you are a parent than if you are a teacher or librarian, as the latter two are prone to more solicitation. Some to take note of are The Horn Book Magazine, School Library Journal, The Reading Teacher, and Book Links.
Don't pass up sites with excellent lists, like PBS and Reading Rainbow.
Word of mouth can be a reliable source as well.
BOOK HOOKS WITH LINDA: LONDON PUBLIC LIBRARY'S REVIEW OF CHILDREN'S BOOKS
OTHER PLACES TO SEARCH FOR BOOKS
Seek and ye shall find on YouTube. Yes, YouTube has quite a few places to search for books to get your hands on. Libraries, kids, parents, schools, and bookstores, all offer favorites you may not otherwise run across. Videos such as those offered here, put "a face and a personality to books in different kind of way. Here is a small example of what you can find...
FIVE CHILDREN'S BOOKS
Arlington Public Library YA Video Blog
BOOK OBSESSED - TEEN READERS
RELATED LINKS BEFORE A FINAL NOTE
- MAKE WAY FOR BOOKS Preschool Program
MAKE WAY FOR BOOKS promotes early literacy in limited resource areas of Tucson, Arizona by providing young children an opportunity to fall in love with books and reading. - Penguin Group (Canada) - Awards - July 2009
The official online book store of Penguin Group (Canada), publishers of literary, fiction, reference, autobiography, academic and classic books. Links to MANY book awards with discriptions and lists found on this page. - The CILIP Carnegie & Kate Greenaway Children\'s Book Awards
CILIP children's book and illustrator awards, links, pages. Easy to navigate. Fun to check out. Great info. - Reading Rainbow | PBS KIDS
READING RAINBOW is designed to encourage a love of books and reading among children ages 4-8. The site features young writers and illustrator - ALA | NEWBERY MEDAL
Information about the current ALSC Newbery Medal winners and links to past winners and award criteria. Administered by the Association for Library Service to Children. - ALA | CALDECOTT MEDAL
Information about the Randolph Caldecott Medal, awarded annually to the artist of the most distinguished American picture book for children. Includes links to past winners and submission instructions. Administered by the Association for Library Servi - Our 15 Favorite Children’s Books
March 2 is the birth date of beloved children’s author Dr. Seuss. While the National Education Association celebrates the occasion with Read Across America, an annual event that promotes the love of reading among children of all ages, we thought we’d
FINAL NOTE
As librarians, parents, and educators, we want our young readers to have a positive reading experience and instill in them the same love and appreciation for books that we have.
For this reason, it is essential that we keep in mind each child's individuality. Our choices should be based on each child's need and the worlds of opportunities that can be given to them; this can mean keeping our own biases and preferences aside. In the end, the choice is theirs.
Related Articles by Frieda Babbley
- Ramona Quimby Age 8 critique for educators and paren...
Critique and activities for Beverly Cleary's Ramona Quimby, Age 8, for teachers and parents. The formatting of this book is characteristic of most books for this reading level. Well-spaced, medium-sized, bold print, makes for easy reading. The paper - Charlotte's Web by E.B. White Critique for Educators
A critique analysis of Charlotte's Web by E.B. White for the educator, parent, and tutors. Activity included. - Quests in The Magician's Nephew - Children's Book Cr...
The Magician's Nephew, by C.S. Lewis, is an exquisitely interwoven quest story. In its simplest form, a quest is generally a search, often times through adventure. In this book, there are three main... - Eye on Educators - eyeonlife
A Magazine with an eye on life and things that matter to you, brought to you by the best writers on the web. Articles, people, art, stories, blogs, and more. This section dedicated to Education. - Walter Dean Myers' Harlem - a children's book critiq...
While the poem and the illustrations each tell a tale of their own, they combine their strength, flow, movement, and soulful expression to make what is perhaps one of the most resounding, effective, soulful books for children. With the guidance of a
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
Thanks man! I'm back online and so behind! Are those the ones where you get to pick what happens next and then read the story that way, so you could like read them a few times, never the same story twice sort of? If so, those were amazing! Thanks for the read. Did ya tweet? Did ya re-tweet? rofl!
Haha, I did tweet! No I think the Choose Your Own Adventure were different. These ones are like... it's almost like you're a detective and have to solve the problem or decipher a code or something before you can move onto the next stage. These books: http://usborne.co.uk/catalogue/browse.asp?css=1&ca
Oh yeah! No, I never got into those, but my oldest son LOVED them! Thanks for the link. Very useful.
I have always loved to read and now my children are both avid readers also. My favorite days as a child were when the book club books arrived at school! This is very good advice to parents. And it is sooo important to read the book yourself to fully evaluate it! :D
A good friend and I often share the books that have impacted our kids (who are friends), for one reason or another. My kids love to hear stories that are about their interests, but stories that their friends have loved are just as interesting to them. I find this a great way to introduce new topics. Other times, I find something interesting at the library and leave it out a few days, while their curiosity grows... Then they just love listening to something that would have been of no interest two or three days before!
I agree, Frieda. There is something about a good book that can allow you to escape to another world. I found out the value of a good book when I was younger. Wonderful hub and a wonderful reminder to parents with children to teach the importance of a good book. Well done.
Hi k@ri, mine was when the bookmobile came around. It was like a caboose and smelled so good filled with all those books. Ah the pleasures.
Christa, sharing books a fantastic idea. I used to turn mine into library books by using index cards to make a pocket and a pull out card. I had a rubber date stamp for return and checkout dates, and I made stickers that said "Michelle's Library" lol! Good times those were. It was thrilling when friends got excited about it and came to browse my library.
Aidy, any world you want. Surprises were always the best. I used to read by the light of the moon so my mom wouldn't catch me. =D
Ha! Going back to what Marco Fratelli and what you said, I remember those Choose Your Own Adventure Books! As a kid, I always was eaten by like a dinosaur (it was some time-travel one) or got shot by some henchmen! I always tried cheating but it never worked! It was like doing a maze with a pen...After a while you forget where you made your initial wrong turn! Thanks, Frieda.
LOl, tried cheating, rofl. Sounds like something I would have tried. I'm going to have to get into those. You can never be too old for books like that, huh? You're most welcome dohn121 Thanks for sharing your memories with those books.
Frieda, these are great tips to help parents locate appropriate books for their kids. Boy, do I miss reading kiddie books, one of the best things about child rearing. One of my favorite and easiest ways to find a good book, I hate to admit, is just grabbing books off the shelf and looking at the pictures. The tone of the book will be obvious from the pictures!
Oh you're so very right, Dolores. I've done that plenty of times, myself. And I've found that sometimes, you really can judge a book by its cover.
Hey Frieda, I love children's books and find your evaluation questions very intriguing. I do judge books by their covers initially but picture books in particular are fun to open and read aloud! I have been writing reviews of young adult books at examiner.com and discovered that every state has its own book awards. You might google what is offered in Missouri. I know a bit about your state, because my sister is a children's librarian in Fayette. She is on the Mark Twain committee to select children's choice books, I believe. She gave me a list to evaluate but I haven't made it there as I am reading three YAs at once, haha. I do love books and it sounds as if you do, too! Glad you are back, by the way... where were you???
I do love books. All ages, all genres. I'm running out of room over here to fit them all! I used to do children's book reviews. I loved writing for The Gazette in Colorado Springs. I was able to do features and really put a lot and go all out. I was disheartened after writing for the St. Louis Post Dispatch, however. That woman threw out anything worth while one could say about anything. I couldn't take the lack of respect she had for Children's books so I had to stop. That was the end of that. I'd love to review or be involved somehow again, but I'm one of those people that tends to run into things at the right time. I'll check out the book awards for Missouri, great thinking. Way lucky for your sister to get to be on the Mark Twain committee!!! How cool is that?! Let her know that if there's any space for me to do anything at all I'd be more than glad to.
I've been sick and in the mean time opening up Eye On Life magazine. And reading a lot. I've got this stack of books that call me every day. I've become a multiple book reader, lol. I never thought I'd see the day.


















marcofratelli says:
4 months ago
I used to love the Usbourne Puzzle Adventures as a kid. They had mysteries you needed to solve, so cool! :) Probably for kids a bit older though! Cool huberino.