Open Holes Flute or Closed Holes Flute - Which One is Right for Me?
63Open Hole or Closed Hole Flute
- Yamaha Open Hole Flutes
Which flute to buy? Open hole flute or closed hole flute? Yamaha or Gemeinhardt? Find out the difference where to buy an open hole or closed hole flute. - Student Flute
Buy a new or used student flute at cheap discount prices. Student flutes, intermediate flutes, and professional models.
If you are wondering as to what type of flute to get for yourself - one with open holes or the one with closed holes, this just might be the hub for you. Let me start by saying that a flute with open holes is a benefit. What you can do if you are not comfortable with them is plug the holes until you are ready to give the holes their vent. And you can also keep the holes plugged all the time if you so prefer it. And don't worry! There are silver topped plugs that blend in perfectly with the flutes and do not give it an odd appearance. Now here is the advantage that, if you get yourself a closed holes flute and later on wish that you should have bought a open holes flute then you will have to buy a new one and that would cost you of course. Or will have to get the keys replaced, which is equally costly.
Then comes the tonal advantage with the open holes flute. As you lift your finger off an open hole the key is vented and the note you are playing is created and this happens sooner than it would in a flute with closed holes. So the key is vented not only from the pad lifting off the hole in the body of the flute but also through the hole in the center of the key, too. And this creates a slightly quicker response and clarity in the sound.
Another advantage to open holes is that you can do glissandos and pitch bends by sliding your finger over the holes. You can play microtones by just depressing the rim of the key, as well. A lot of modern flute music requires all of this, and it is much more difficult to do stuff and tricks like this with closed holes flute. Open holes flutes allow you to use more alternate fingerings which helps in both technique and intonation. Open holes flute also forces you to have good hand position. It gives you the possibility of doing note bends and much much more.
A good idea therefore, is to get a open holes flute and use plugs or corks for the holes until you are ready to gradually take the corks out one by one. At first the sound of the open holes flute will certainly appear to be very weird to you. But having a lot of advantage the open holes flute is certainly a better choice. You will surely get accustomed to the open holes flute soon enough.
Starting off with an open holes flute you will have to learn some basic hand positions from some expert or by reading some books. Then with a little bit of help from a friend or a teacher you will be able to do it comfortably. Or you can practice in front of the mirror to get your hand positions correct if you find no one to assist you.
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
I personnally do not like open hole flutes because they don't play as well as a closed hole flutes. I think a closed hole flute would be right for you!!!!
your welcome ...... anonamous guest
I was taught that a begining flute should be closed, then if you become more advanced upgrade. The open holes are harder to play, but, an advanged student would not have problems with it.
I found the information very useful. I'm gonna need a new flute soon since mine is very..ummm. Anyways, I was wondering which flute I should get, Open-holed, or closed?
This is exactly waht my flute teacher proposes, and she's a professional flute player. Remember that it is harder to un-learn bad hand positioning than it is to learn good hand-positioning right from the start. So go for the open holes.
I'm 50 and will restart but several years ago I started on a closed hole? I'm going to get a new one but can an old dog learn new tricks like this one?
Thank you, very helpful info,
Who said that one has to be young in order to lean music or any other new tricks?
After all, life goes by so quickly! At the age of 46 I realized that I new absolutely nothing about music and was truly "starving" for its knowledge. Got myself an accordion and with a self teaching book two years later (10min - 1h/day practice) I can say I'm playing it. Of course I will never abandon the accordion, yet I came across this site only because recently I have my eyes and ears set on a traversal flute also.
Another flute site which I found very helpful: www.AllAboutFlutes.com
...with all the above, now I know exactly which flute is for me.
Thanks to everyone for sharing your knowledge and experience.
...my favorite band: NIGHTWISH :-o!!!



Jim says:
13 months ago
Very informative Hub. I enjoyed it. If you get a chance please visit my site at www.yamahaflute.com Thanks--