Homelessness and Death Caused by the Social Security Disability Backlog
78The Agonizing Wait for SSDI Benefits
Woe to You if You Become Disabled
Reaching unprecented levels, the backlog for new Social Security Disability and Supplemental Security Income cases is worsening instead of getting better. Since 2000, the backlog at the Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) hearing level has more than doubled from 310,000 cases to 765,000 cases. Although the waiting time varies between states, currently, the average waiting time is amost 500 days. Consequently, many applicants lose everything they have or even die before their ALJ hearing.
Appeal Process
How the Social Security System Works
According to the SSA, the definition of a disability is "You cannot do work that you did before. We decide that you cannot adjust to other work because of your disability; and your disability has lasted or is expected to last for at least one year or result in death."
If you file for disability, approximately 60% of initial applications are denied. If you file an appeal, the next level is the Reconsideration level. It is a paper review by a different disability examiner. The denial rate is even greater at this level. Approximately, 80% of the cases are denied. If you appeal again, the long wait for an Administrative Law Judge hearing begins. Although over half of the denials are reversed at this level, by this time many people have suffered from irreversible damage. If you appeal the ALJ's decision, you case goes to the Appeal's Council. At this stage, there is a one year minimum at least. Like the Reconsideration Level, it is basically a paper review of the legality of ALJ's decision and any new evidence submitted. Like the Reconsideration level again, the denial rate is approximately 80%. The last appeal is the Federal District Court. At this level, the case is either awarded or sent back to the ALJ with instructions.
Dying Before SSDI Benefits are Awarded
Even before the latest increase in cases, it is no exageration that people die before they recieve ther rightful benefits. Below are a few examples.
- Mark Wild discovered he was diabetic at 19. Throughout the years, his severe diabetes required frequent hospitalizations. Although he tried working and going to school, his illness and fequent hospitalizations interfered. Massive medical bills, no life outside his parent's home and hospitalizations, and fear of yet another SSDI rejection weighed heavily on his mind. A few days before his hearing Mark was missing, but his watch, ring, and a bullet lay on his nightstand. Two days later, Mark's attorney called and told his mother he won his case without a hearning. Two hours after this call, Mark's parents were visted by a deputy sherriff and chaplain. Hunters found Mark's body dead in the woods from a self-inflicted gunshot wound.
- A Key West Florida woman was shot five times in the liver and abdomen by her husband. As a result of the gunshot wounds, she had related disabilities and chonic obstructive pulmonary disease. Her claim was denied in April 2006. In March 2008, she had her ALJ hearing. She died within the same the month. SSA approved the case after her death.
- A Charlotte, North Carolina man was a pipe insulator for fifteen years. At 52, he had congestive heart failure, chronic atrial fibrillation, pneumonia, obesity, and peripheral artery disease. He applied for SSDI in March 2006 and was denied. In November of 2006, he requested an ALJ hearing. He died in August 2007. Four months later, SSA approved his disability without a hearing.
For every publicized case of the devastation caused by this situation, how many more unpublicized cases are there?
Don't apply for Social Security Disability Benefits without being informed!
Reasons for the High Denial Rates on SSDI Applications
Many people wonder why there is such a high level of disparity between the rates of approval on the initial applications and Reconsideration levels compared to the high reversals at the Administrative Law Judge hearing levels, Although no one has an exact answer, these are several theories.
- Denials based on pain - Many disabiity cases are based on pain. Since pain is subjective, it is hard to determine whether the quality and intensity of the pain are disabling.
- The effect of malingering - Some people think Congress believes if people are given the opportunity, they will choose disability over working. In my opinion, this is absolutely ridiculous! No one is their right mind would rather go through the anxiety, depression, and economic hardship of trying to win a disability case compared to working.
- At the initial application, not as many people have attorneys in comparison to the Administration Law Judge hearing level. Furthermore, the extra length of time between the initial application and the ALJ hearing provides an opportunity to develop a stronger case.
- Compared to the initial application and Reconsideration, at the ALJ hearing, you have an opportunity to present your case in person. Since the ALJ can see you and listen to you, it may give your case more credibility. However, if you do not have legal representation, your odds of winning your case are markedly less. Furthermore, the legal fees cost either 25% of the back money owed by SSA or $6300, whichever is less. Tell me, do you think it is right a person who is so sick they can't work anymore should have to hire an attorney to collect what should be rightfully theirs?
Reasons for the Backlog at the ALJ Level
In addition to the high denial rate on the initial applications and at the Reconsideration levels, the wait for an Administrative Law Judge hearning is unacceptably long. Furthermore, this is not a recent problem; it has been going on for years. Some of the reasons for this are:
- Years of underfunding and a decrease in support staff - Until the Economic Stimulus package, the agency had staffing levels below those seen during the Nixon Administration.
- Worries about malingering has led to tighter scrutiny.
- Litigation and financing shortages prevented hiring new Administrative Law Judges.
- Changing demographics. The baby boom generation has led to an increase in disability claims.
The Economic Stimulus Package Fails to Decrease the Backlog
In addressing the average 500+ day wait for an ALJ hearning, the economic stimulus package gave SSA $500 million to hire more staff and judges. However, even though the backlog decreased for six consecutive months, it is on the rise again.
Since October 2008, the number of people waiting to have a claim processed has risen by 30%. Furthermore, according to Allsup, the average time to process an initial disability claim will increase by 20% this year. Adding to these problems, on the state level, at least 10 states have furloughed hundreds of employees that process these cases because of budget shortfalls. In fact, California has furloughed more than 1400 workers for three days a month through 2010. Even more disheartening, on the federal level, since administrative expenses are running short at the end of their fiscal year, SSA has suspended all hearings for people seeking disability benefits during September 2009. When people were already facing homelessness and dying before they recieved their benefits, these actions compound the problem. Hence, at least for the SSDI program, the economic stimulus program was a bandaid that didn't stick.
Facts to Consider
Before this article becomes another one read and forgotten, consider these facts:
- Three in ten people will become disabled before they retire.
- According to the Census Bureau, 18% of Americans have some form of disability while 12% have a severe disability.
- Sixty-five percent of Americans are living paycheck to paycheck. According to a report by MetLife, 50% have less than one month's savings for emergencies, and 28% have less than two weeks of emergency savings. Even people making $100,000 or more, 28% still had only one month's savings.
- Forty-six percent of all home foreclosures are caused by disability and half of all bankruptcies are caused by medical reasons.
Conclusion
Life can change in a second. Considering the statistics, you, a loved one, or someone you know will more than likely become disabled. Furthermore, will you or they be able to survive this torturous, agonizing wait without financial devastation or even a worse fate.
Think about it. If you have children, you may qualify for AFDC. However, more that likey, a disability applicant's income was far greater than AFDC benefits. Furthermore, if you're single without chldren, you don't even have that option. Can you imagine trying to pay all of your bills and survive month after month on minimal or no income. Furthermore, you've already been denied for disability benefits twice, can you imagine the underlying fear that you will be denied again?
If you are denied again, you would either have to reapply for benefits again or appeal to the Appeal Council. Unfortunately, the Appeals Council is similar to the Reconsideration level since they review the legality of ALJ's decision and any new evidence. Most of these cases are ruled in favor of the judge, and an appeal is then made for a Federal District Court Review. Most of these cases are either sent back to ALJ or approved for benefits. Either way, if you appeal the ALJ's decision or you start over again, you are looking at a long, long time before any decision is made or benefits are awarded.
Unless you have gone through this struggle personally, there is no way to imagine the anxiety, fear, and despair the current system inflicts. It is both inhumane and cruel. This problem has gone on for far too long and destroyed too many lives. Tragically, it will continue even longer unless the public gets more involved. If you care, contact your elected officials today.
Social Security Disability Backlog in the News
- Social Security disability backlog hearing convenedUnion City Messenger22 hours ago
U.S. Rep. John Tanner, chairman of the Ways and Means Subcommittee on Social Security, urged the Social Security Administration to continue its focus on reducing the unprecedented backlog in disability claims.
- Disability claims taking longerMemphis Commercial Appeal5 days ago
WASHINGTON -- The backlog in Memphis to get a hearing for Social Security disability benefits increased by three months last year, to 538 days, and is worsening, a lawyer who practices in Memphis told a House Ways and Means subcommittee Thursday.Beth Striklin Bates, a Jackson, Tenn., lawyer for West Tennessee Legal Services Inc. for the last 22 years, testified before the Ways and Means ...
- Claim denials haunt some to death's doorThe News Journal32 hours ago
Backlog of disability cases, dismissal of doctors' documentation leave some Delawareans without aid when they're unable to work.
- Disabled and still waiting for benefitsKVOA Tucson24 hours ago
Thousands of Tucsonans await benefits but help may be on the way. Yolanda Hinojos hasn't changed her son's room since he died six years ago. She hasn't even thrown out his deodorant because she says it's like "footprints" for her. She says the police told her it was suicide but she calls it murder.
- Diabetes Month Highlights Prevalence, Difficulties With Delays in Receiving Disability BenefitsPRWeb4 days ago
November is American Diabetes Month -- an ideal time to examine how individuals with diabetes fare in the SSDI process. (PRWeb Nov 21, 2009) Read the full story at http://www.prweb.com/releases/Diabetes/Disability_Benefits/prweb3240174.htm
Important Informtion in Applying for Social Security Disability Benefits
Are you disabled? Considering 60% of the initial applications and 80% of the Reconsideration level cases are denied, can you afford to go 500+ days without any income waiting for an Administrative Law Judge hearing? If not, learn how to cut through the red tape and successfully acquire benefits the first time you apply. For more information Click Here!
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
Hi Windtraveller
I totally agree with you! I also believe the biggest problem is the discrepancy between the high denial rates on the initial applications and Reconsiderations compared to the high number of reversals at the ALJ hearings. Although the government will deny it, I think they purposely deny cases in the beginning so they don't have to pay out the benefits. Some people will claim the discrepancy may be because the disability examiners at the beginning stages aren't trained as well. However, if this was the case, SSA would still be saving money if the trained the disability examiners better rather than hiring more Administrative Law Judges. Thank you for adding your input, Windtraveller!
This is the same federal goverment that wants to take control of our healthcare??????????
Yes, it's pitiful, isn't it? Furthermore, it not like this a recent situation, it's been going on for years. It's just that no one finds out about it until they or their loved one become disabled and need help!
I was recently healed from my former disability. My last SSDI payment is in November. Hopefully, that makes room for y'all. God bless you.
That is fantastic that you were healed! I am happy for you.
Thank you. Yes, your'e right, and from what I've heard, your company is a good disability representive. Although, it saddens me that a person who is rightfully disabled has to hire legal representation to win their case in this country. Twenty-five percent or $6300, whichever is less, is an exhorbitant amount of money for someone who has already suffered so much. Thank you for your input and stopping by.
Speaking of DYING before benefits are even given, my husband finally got his SSDI in May of '08. HOWEVER, because he has pushed himself to work despite his being born with a severe case of Spina Bifida, he earns too much monthly for medicaid. SO, the government makes you WAIT
2 YEARS FOR MEDICARE AFTER YOU GET SSDI!!!!!
Needless to say, last month he had to have emergency surgery (actually surgeries #53, #54 and #55 of his life and he's only 48!!!)
So, he almost died before getting health coverage. Think they don't HOPE you die before giving you disability in full? It's obvious!!!!
Hi Regina!
I am so sorry you and your husband had to go through that. The Social Security System for the disabled is totally messed up, and it's pitiful how our country's disabled are treated!
Earlier this year, someone proposed legislation, H.R. 1708, a bill designed to phase out the 24-month waiting period for disability. A few weeks ago, I got to wondering what happend with the bill. I searched the net looking for more information on it, but I couldn't find anything beyond what I initially read. What do you want to bet, it was just dropped without another thought for all the people in this position.
God bless and take care.
Thank you for your input and stopping by!
I was one those that waited six years without an income. I honestly believe that SSA thought that if they kept denying my claim that I would give up and move on, but I was so, obsessed with my ailments that I couldn't focus on anything else. Still, it took prayer and leaning to my US Senator's office to finally get things inorder. Sadly, my SSA credits ran out and I could only qualify for SSI. I think that is the real reason behind why the denial rate is so high, because it saves the department money. I also dicovered that your grief can continue long after approval for disability benefits if you get targeted for SSA third party "Plausible Denial" harassment, in which your property is vandalized, stolen or tampered with by people you do business with or trust. Like bankers, grocerers, mail and delivery people, neighbors, pharmacist, landlords and property mangers, law enforcement, just to name a few all covering and snooping and tampering at SSA request. It's a shame, really, that SSA will stoop to this level to look for reasons to controvert and deny your benefits before and after you have fought so hard to get them. It drove me to acquaint myself with the law. SSA's Program Operation Manuals are available online at their website for all those who would like to review them.











Windtraveller says:
3 months ago
The idea that people would rather be on welfare than have a job is ludicrous. Nothing gives a person more satisfaction than to earn your own keep. Even in a nation like mine, where welfare is well organized there's no malingering. Given half a chance people want to have their lives be meaningful to other people.
Putting more judges on staff is like mopping up while you leave the water running: it's not going to help any unless the denial rates come down. That involves trusting your own people.