Walter Dean Myers' Harlem - a children's book critique for parents and educators
75
Myers, Walter Dean. Harlem. Ill. Christopher Myers. New York: Scholastic Press, 1997.
Category: Caldecott Award; African American; picture book
Approximate age group: upper elementary
Analysis:
Walter Dean Myers and Christopher Myers (father and son) have collaborated for a second time (first with Shadow of the Red Moon), this time with the inspired and impassioned Harlem. The text is set in 14 point Gothic no. 2; a bold font elaborating on the powerful story of Harlem brought to life in this over-sized picture book.
While Christopher Myers' illustration styles are diverse from book to book, they are always well suited. Here, the ink, gouache, and cut-paper collage illustrations are bold, vivid, and endowed with the colors of the town, culture, and peoples that are Harlem. They speak, flow, and are alive with movement, stillness, and passion, sometimes stretching across pages, sometimes framed in contrasting white.
The full scope of Harlem is portrayed in Walter Meyers' exquisite free-verse poem. His style is rich with allusion and a strong sense of place. The jazzy improvisational quality resonates with stirring sound, refusing to sit still, and demanding to be read aloud.
Sun yellow shirts on burnt umber -
Bodies -
Demanding to be heard, seen -
Sending out warriors -
From streets that know to be -
Mourning still as a lone radio tells us how Jack -
Johnson/Joe Louis/ Sugar Ray is doing with our -
Hopes
Here Hughes refers to
- the first black heavyweight champion, Jack Johnson;
- Joseph Louis Barrow, "The Brown Bomber", held Heavyweight Champion title longer than any man in history; and
- 1976 Olympic gold medallist, boxer Sugar Ray Leonard.
While Meyers makes representative musical, literary, and historical references, he also describes compelling images of the residents, their hopes, dreams, spirits, and sadness.
Each stanza flows into the next, so that pages must be turned, and connections must be made. Where one page ends,
Listening
For the coming of the blues
the next begins,
A weary blues that Langston knew
and Countee sung.
The author is referring her to writer/poet Langston Hughes 1902-1956, and to writer/poet Countee Cullen 1903-1946.
Myers ends his poem as simple as he began, with the title, "Harlem".
Christopher Myers ends his illustrations with the corner of W 125 St. and Dr. Martin Luther Blvd., the heart of Harlem.
While the poem and the illustrations each tell a tale of their own, they combine their strength, flow, movement, and soulful expression to make what is perhaps one of the most resounding, effective, soulful books for children. With the guidance of a well-prepared teacher, this book can be an asset and a great contribution to young minds. Do not wait for African American month or Poetry week to use this book as a learning tool. It has a lot to offer in so many respects.
some other books by Walter Dean Myers
|
Darnell Rock Reporting
Price: $0.75
List Price: $5.99 |
|
Somewhere In The Darkness
Price: $3.16
List Price: $6.99 |
|
Monster
Price: $4.40
List Price: $8.99 |
|
Jazz
Price: $5.22
List Price: $8.95 |
|
Autobiography of My Dead Brother
for grades 8 up
Price: $3.35
List Price: $7.99 |
ACTIVITY
Talk about the media used by the illustrator and have the students make collages of their own to represent something in their lives or community.
Have them research and present one of the references made by Myers (from Lady Day - singer Billie Holiday, to Marcus Garvey, giant of Black liberation and founder of U.N.I.A. - Universal Negro Improvement Association).
Have children compare the styles and messages of Langston Hughes and Countee Cullen with those of this book.
Read Charlie Parker Played Be-Bop, by Chris Raschka (1992).
|
Charlie Parker Played Be Bop
by Chris Raschka - paperback - the jazziest tale; why, it's music to your ears. And remember, "never leave your cat alone..." Dig it. Yeah.
Price: $2.83
List Price: $6.99 |
Related Articles by Frieda Babbley
- Factors for selecting and evaluating children's book...
There are many factors to take into consideration when selecting and evaluating books for children. First and foremost, it is important to take into consideration the children's physical, cognitive,... - Ramona Quimby Age 8 critique for educators and paren...
Critique and activities for Beverly Cleary's Ramona Quimby, Age 8, for teachers and parents. The formatting of this book is characteristic of most books for this reading level. Well-spaced, medium-sized, bold print, makes for easy reading. The paper - Charlotte's Web by E.B. White Critique for Educators
A critique analysis of Charlotte's Web by E.B. White for the educator, parent, and tutors. Activity included. - Eye on Educators - eyeonlife
A Magazine with an eye on life and things that matter to you, brought to you by the best writers on the web. Articles, people, art, stories, blogs, and more. This section dedicated to Education. - Quests in The Magician's Nephew - Children's Book Cr...
The Magician's Nephew, by C.S. Lewis, is an exquisitely interwoven quest story. In its simplest form, a quest is generally a search, often times through adventure. In this book, there are three main...
Favorite Children's Books on HubPages feed
- The Grouchy Ladybug by Eric Carle Children's Book Review
The Grouchy Ladybug, by Eric Carle, is a classic children's book first published in 1977. It's visual appeal combined with a three-part theme of telling time, bullying, and comparing sizes will entertain and interest your preschool and early elementary age audience for repeat readings. - 2 years ago
- How to Eat Fried Worms
More and more children's books for boys are popping up in the last couple of decades. While it used to be boys would rarely do much reading, overall, unless it contained graphics and superheros and sound... - 2 months ago
- Charlotte's Web by E.B. White Critique for Educators
A critique analysis of Charlotte's Web by E.B. White for the educator, parent, and tutors. Activity included. - 4 months ago
- Ramona Quimby Age 8 critique for educators and parents
Critique and activities for Beverly Cleary's Ramona Quimby, Age 8, for teachers and parents. The formatting of this book is characteristic of most books for this reading level. Well-spaced, medium-sized, bold print, makes for easy reading. The paper is thick and durable, great for a lot of ... - 4 months ago
- No David! by David Shannon â Children's Book Review with Sample Lesson
No David! (ISBN 10: 0590930028) is the first in a series of children's picture books starring author David Shannon's alter ego, a sharp-toothed little child who is delightfully naughty. This vividly-illustrated children's picture book by award-winning author David Shannon will delight even young toddlers. - 2 years ago
- Where the Wild Things Are by Maurice Sendak Children's Book Review and Sample Lesson
Where the Wild Things Are by Maurice Sendak (ISBN-10: 0064431789) is one of the most well-loved children's picture books of all time. Winner of the prestigious Caldecott Medal in 1964, just one year after its publication, this book stars Max, the most wild thing of all. Read on for an in-depth review and sample lesson for your preschool or library story hour. - 2 years ago
- Chrysanthemum by Kevin Henkes Children's Book Review
Chrysanthemum by Kevin Henkes is one of the all-star children's books of the children's literary world. Kevin Henkes' title character is a cute little mouse with a very big name and an even bigger problem: bullying! This should be required reading for every elementary school classroom. Read my review to learn more. - 3 months ago
- Quests in The Magician's Nephew - Children's Book Critique for Parents and Educators
The Magician's Nephew, by C.S. Lewis, is an exquisitely interwoven quest story. In its simplest form, a quest is generally a search, often times through adventure. In this book, there are three main... - 4 months ago
PrintShare it! — Rate it: up down flag this hub
Comments
Wow great review. I have to go get this book!
Thanks UW. Oh, should we? I didn't know. When I read the forum from Ryan he said we didn't need to on this one. But will do I suppose. Thanks. I'll go back and do that for all of mine in this challenge then.
Triplet Mom, yes you do. Thanks. I got it from the library. When I was looking for it on Amazon it didn't show a photo, so you probably have to go through a bookstore I assume.
Thanks for the read guys. Not sure how these critiques would do overall on HP. If they do well, I'll add more, if not, I'll add a section to my mag. I guess.
children's poetry in the news
- Friends share talents to produce third children's bookThe Lewiston Sun Journal2 days ago
WELD — Sharing friendship, similar interests and their talents, a former local postmaster now living in Texas and the treasurer for the town of Weld have just released their third soft-covered children's book. Writer Elizabeth Scott, former Dryden and East Wilton postmaster, and i...
- Traditional children's books -- with a twistMinneapolis-St. Paul Star Tribune2 days ago
The season's best picture books offer fresh takes on some familiar story lines.
- Holiday calendar of eventsRichmond Times-Dispatch16 hours ago
Sunday, Nov. 29 Legendary Santa, 9 a.m.-5 p.m. at Children’s Museum of Richmond, 2626 W. Broad St. Visits to Santa are free; $7-$8 for museum entry. Santa hotline at 474-7009 or 474-2667. Daily (hours vary) through Dec. 24. Genworth Financial Holiday Village, scaled-down Fan District-style houses exploring symbols, traditions and customs of the holidays, at Children’s Museum of Richmond, 2626 W ...












Uninvited Writer says:
4 months ago
This is an excellent review. Well done :)
If you add the tag hubchallenge to your tags so that it will turn up on the articles os those who are running the RSS for the challenge.