Are You Smart Enough For This Article?: Flesch-Kincaid Readability Scoring

It All Began With a Mark Cuban Tweet

Recently while browsing Twitter I came across a “tweet” from Mark Cuban (yes, that Mark Cuban) that referred to a website entitled The Harvard College Sports Analysis Collective and specifically an articled called The Reading Level of Sports Writing by Ben Blatt. To make a long story short, Blatt performed an analysis using the Flesch-Kincaid readability test to compare the level of reading ability it took to fully understand a sports column as opposed to other sections of a news paper including opinion, business, science, politics, and arts. The Flesch-Kincaid scoring system basically assigns a “grade level” required to understand a written article with an equation that factors in word count, number of sentences, and number of syllables weighted with different factors likely figured out by really smart people whose articles most of us could not comprehend. To no surprise, sports columns generally ranked last out of the studied groups with an average Flesch-Kincaid grade level of 8.3 when using the New York Times as a point of reference. For comparison, opinion, business, and science all came in at over grade 10 followed by politics, arts and sports in that order. Does that mean that sports writers are dummies or are these genre or articles written to appeal to as many people as possible regardless of their education level?

Mark Cuban

Source

Thanks to Mr. Cuban, I have officially become obsessed with this as an evaluation tool for my own articles, hubs, and scholastic papers I have written and decided to search for an easy way to do this online so I didn’t have to count how many sentences and syllables I used in an entire 1000 plus word article. Also, I thought it would be fun to use some of my hubs on this website to use for scoring my writing and also to see if there was any correlation to each articles “hub score”. In short, does a higher readability (lower grade level) create a less read article or does the higher grade level actually harm a hub’s wide ranged popularity due to higher reading difficulty?

The Experiment

To be able to conduct this unscientific experiment on my own Hub Page articles, I first had to find a website that I could easily upload an article from MS word or at very least copy and paste the text directly to the site. Thankfully, this was quite easy to find and began analyzing some articles I have written for Hub Pages since I joined in October 2011. To be as fair as possible I decided on 4 articles; the first two are my highest scoring (hubscore) non-recipe Hub Page articles Money Saving Mom + Money Saving Dad = Money Saving Kids: Managing Money and Saving Extra Doing Small Every Day Things, and Should Americans Be Learning Foreign Languages Starting in Kindergarten? ¿Español que aprende en jardín de la infancia? And two more scholastic articles that I have published that I also handed in for grades while pursuing my MBA; Demand for Diesel, and U.S. Payment Systems and the Federal Reserve, both of which I believe I got A grades. In the table below, I got my Flesch-Kincaid scores calculated at readability-score.com.

The Results

Article
Readers / Days Since Published (popularity)
Hub Score (Article Quality)
Flesch Kincaid Readability Grade Level (years of education)
Money Saving Mom + Money Saving Dad = Money Saving Kids: Managing Money and Saving Extra Doing Small Every Day Things
.387
84
11.2
Should Americans Be Learning Foreign Languages Starting in Kindergarten? ¿Español que aprende en jardín de la infancia?
.301
82
8.8
Demand For Diesel
.591
71
11.9
U.S. Payment Systems and the Federal Reserve,
6.688
76
13
Statistics as of 5-23-12
 
 
 

The Analysis

Well, the factors that my analysis obviously leave out and are difficult to know for certain are factors such as, general interest in the topic matter, attractiveness of title, popularity of website it is published on, search engine optimization, and proper promotion of the articles. Regardless of how well written or easy to understand an article is, it doesn't matter if no one knows it exists or even worse care if it exists. The Flesch-Kincaid grade level analysis also cannot determine how well written an article is, only how difficult the words may be to read or how complex the sentences used are. The only way the quality of the article can be determined is by reading it which doesn't factor into the analysis I performed. This says a lot for the importance of an attention grabbing article title, a topical and long lasting subject, as well as talent for SEO and promotion of said article.

If you are curious, this article rated at a pretty decent 11.3 Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level readability. As for what this means for the potential success of this article is a little foggy. I guess I will just have to promote the hell out of it and see what happens.

Source

More by this Author


Comments 4 comments

Michele Travis profile image

Michele Travis 4 years ago from U.S.A. Ohio

Is it a hub or an article? The title will be important. The next thing you need to do is make sure this hub is yours. It need a copyright. Other people who write hubs are stealing other hubs. Wording in your writing does not always mean intelligence. My father was a professor and taught at a university. He gave an IQ test to me, but it was based on language used by inner city African Americans. My IQ was about 68. Then he gave it to his class. The highest IQ in his class was about 86. The university would not let him publish it.

That was not a big deal, but I have a few questions for you. Mostly because of the Federal Reserve bank. After all, if it wasn't for them we would not be in a financial crisis. Or would we?


Peter Leeper profile image

Peter Leeper 4 years ago from Londonderry, New Hampshire Author

Hi Michell, thanks for the comment! The title of this hub/ article was an attempt at humor related to the topic I was writing about. I don't consider myself particularly bright and most of what I write scores a decent grade level reading requirement. Lots of multiple slaw words in long sentences doesn't mean they are well crafted to produce an intellectual article in my opinion.

As for the feed reserve and their impact on the economy; I think it is a mixed bag. On one side they are responsible for ensuring money continues to flow into our economy by lowering prime rates that they provide loans ( printing money) to banks this enabling the banks to loan to businesses and consumers at a lower rate... However this practice also weakens the dollar as compared to foreign currency which increases absolute oil prices as well as many other pitfalls.. I believe in the end of the day the world economy is cyclical and we can only hope that decisions the fed makes can tighten the ebbs and flows...


Michele Travis profile image

Michele Travis 4 years ago from U.S.A. Ohio

I know Peter, if you were truly writing an article, it would not be here. As for the Federal Reserve, yes it is a mixed bag, but also has an interesting history. But, the Federal Reserve does not control the world's economy, that is a good thing. You are correct about the world's economy as being cyclical. It will go up and down, we just think each time is the worst.


carozy profile image

carozy 4 years ago from San Francisco

Interesting article. Simple writing is often better anyway. Look at Mark Cuban. He's a billionaire.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working