Book Review and Analysis of The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro

The Remains of the Day is a book by Kazuo Ishiguro, published in 1989, and set during the in-between times of post-War England. Ishiguro's third novel is highly respected, having won the Man Booker Prize for Fiction. In 1993, The Remains of the Day was adapted as an Oscar-nominated movie by Merchant-Ivory.

Although it wasn't quite what I was expecting, The Remains of the Day surprised me, thrilled me, and sits on the mountain of magical memory along with many other well-loved books. At first, I was mildly bored, but being the sort that believes that not finishing a book is a practically unthinkable crime, I continued on. As I continued, I thought, "What a solid novel" - "solid" being the only suitable adjective I could think of. Still I read, and, although I was occasionally annoyed at the rambling narrative style and the jumping between past and present, I came to realize that this is a novel of great depth, complex characters, subtle humor, and lasting themes. By the end of my 245 pages, I was in love with it.

The Remains of the Day is an armchair book, ideal for my fellow Anglophiles. It's the sort of read to be enjoyed by a quieted mind in the sole company of a warm fire (imaginary or otherwise) and a pot of tea (preferably unimaginary). With a storyteller like Kazuo Ishiguro, you won't be disappointed.

Mr. Stevens

The narrator of the story is Mr. Stevens, who is also the main character. But as one reads, one must realize that this character has flaws (as all good characters do) and can't quite be trusted for an unbiased version of the story. Indeed, our hero changes his mind about certain topics several times throughout the book, and we must learn to read between the lines. This is a display of Ishiguro's brilliant storytelling talent. He gives us a man, not entirely likeable or exciting, but a man we struggle to understand, first because we think there is nothing important to comprehend about him, but then later because we realize he has a hidden character with a complex emotional and intellectual past.

Stevens is a butler, serving an English lord before and during World War II and an American gentleman during the days afterward. The fact that he is a butler shows Ishiguro's interest in exposing the heart of a man working in a profession which is dying out and which is not often described in detail or depth in literature.

Mr. Stevens, as played by Anthony Hopkins
Mr. Stevens, as played by Anthony Hopkins

As an old-fashioned English butler, Mr. Stevens is efficient, meticulous, and strictly professional. His world is very structured and depends on perfection of detail for it to run smoothly. Despite the flux and waning of life around him, Stevens is determined to confront every situation with the same calm dignity he believes is suitable to his position as a butler.

Stevens is narrating the story in the present, describing a journey he is undertaking as one of the few vacations he has ever enjoyed. While he drives his master's car out west, he contemplates the past (his days working under an influential man during the war) while also thinking about the person he is about to see at the end of his journey - Miss Kenton.

Miss Kenton

Miss Kenton, the heroine of the story, pops in and out of the boook, as she pops in and out of Stevens's mind, which is quite frequently. All we know of Miss Kenton are the perceptions of Stevens, and I rather wish I could hear her side of the story. Stevens colors the character of Miss Kenton through various events that occurred during the years they spent working together. His feelings for this faithful housekeeper are revealed gradually through the book, but only if we can reach into his mind and read the thoughts he won't speak aloud.

When Miss Kenton first came to Darlington Hall, Stevens tells us that he and she clashed somewhat over various household issues and jurisdiction. As the two leaders of the numerous staff at the hall, both Mr. Stevens and Miss Kenton must learn to work together in order for the household to run smoothly. As the years went by, they grew in their respect for one another. We read of the evening chats they would have over hot cocoa after the day's work was over. Stevens describes these talks as being of a professional nature, but we can safely gather that they also bear the weight of friendship and perhaps the possibility of something more.

Miss Stevens, as played by Emma Thompson
Miss Stevens, as played by Emma Thompson

As the present narrative rolls on, we know that Miss Kenton is now a Mrs. Benn who resides a few days' journey away from the Hall, and that Mr. Stevens is going to see her in the hopes of hiring her back on the staff of Darlington Hall after receiving a letter from her which told of the separation between her and her husband. At least, that is the motivation of which Stevens tells us. But we soon realize that there are perhaps other reasons he wishes to see her.

Lord Darlington

Lord Darlington, though an aristocrat, is always in the background of the story. He is the employer of Stevens, and he trusts his butler more than almost anyone. The thirties and forties were tumultuous times for England, and Lord Darlington found himself in the middle. We know that Stevens has the utmost respect for his employer and never doubted his good intentions and upright behavior. We read of Darlington's influence on politics: how he is able to gather together influential men in his home for meetings, how he is interested in promoting peace. Though he sometimes makes mistakes, he has good intentions, or else Stevens defends his employer's reputation. But in the end, we find that Lord Darlington, while trying to do good, in reality aided Hitler and his propaganda in England, ending his days in dishonor. Darlington represents the fading of the aristocracy, giving way before a new way of life and a new kind of people.

Mr. Farraday

Mr. Farraday is the employer of Stevens in the present day. An American, Mr. Farraday replaces Lord Darlington in Darlington Hall. His way of life is different from his predecessor, and much of the great house is closed down to accommodate his simpler life and smaller staff. Whereas Lord Darlington was a stately English gentleman, Mr. Farraday, also a gentleman, comes from a different perspective. His manner toward Stevens is very revealing. He talks to Stevens in a bantering fashion, making Stevens feel as if he must return the conversation with some witty comment. Unused to this, Stevens is rather bad at bantering, at this new way of life. The old world is passing away, and Stevens finds himself passing with it.

Dignity

Dignity is a key theme in The Remains of the Day. Stevens often talks about it as though it is the ultimate virtue of a butler. The holding of this trait means the attainment of greatness in his world. He seeks this dignity with such fervor that he comes across as a rather hardened and emotionless man. Stevens has a serious nature, and he recalls many incidents in which we see hiim acting truly dignified, even when caught in extremely emotional situations. When his father dies in th midst of an important political dinner, Stevens goes about his work with an exterior that is so calm and emotionless, it is almost shocking.

This dignified demeanor appears to be an ugly look at a man without a heart, without any feelings. But we learn as we read that his calm composure is not indeed the absence of emotion, but rather the masking of it. Behind the mask is a man with complicated emotions, suppressed feelings, and a self-imposed duty to put work before all else. This man has grown old and he rambles as he considers whether he has lived up to his own standards. But the dignity is always there.

Emma Thompson and Anthony Hopkins playing Miss Kenton and Mr. Stevens
Emma Thompson and Anthony Hopkins playing Miss Kenton and Mr. Stevens

The End of the Journey

The last chapter of the book is by far the most emotional and most revealing. As Stevens reaches the end of the journey, he finds himself in the company of Miss Kenton, now Mrs. Benn, enjoying a private conversation with her on a rainy afternoon. They find each other much the same as always, only older. Stevens learns that in the days since Miss Kenton's letter detailing her separation, she has returned to her husband's house. They have a married daughter who is expecting a child. Stevens and Miss Kenton talk mostly of the happy memories they share, from the glory days of twenty years ago. Much has changed since then, but still they remember the good days.

As their time together is ending, Stevens asks what has been on his heart the entire journey - not about Miss Kenton returning to the staff of Darlington Hall, but about her unhappiness which seemed to be apparent in her letter. Miss Kenton replies that although she has regrets - regrets about what could have been with Mr. Stevens - she is not entirely unhappy. She has moments when life seems dismal, but the days go on and one can't turn back the clock. They agree that yes, they can't turn back the clock, and they must continue on as they have always done. Mr. Stevens encourages Miss Kenton to enjoy herself and her husband, to make the most of the life she is given. And then she leaves on the bus in the rain, and Stevens is left with his own regrets, and a heart that is broken now that he truly realizes the possibilities that he gave up. But through it all, he covers himself with the dignity that he has always prized.

Remains of the Day

As we reach the end of the book, Stevens is at the beginning of the dusk of his life, and he contemplates his past, weighing his actions on the scales of dignity and purpose. Were his many years spent at Darlington Hall all for nothing? He sacrificed every hour of every day working in the house of another man. He gave up his only chance at happiness with Miss Kenton. He spent the prime of his life serving a man who in the end was labeled a failure. What was it all for?

Stevens talks of how he thinks that butler's duty is to serve a good gentleman faithfully, without questioning the actions of said gentleman. But later, as the world changes, he doubts whether this was the best course after all. He questions whether there is any dignity in not making his own mistakes, in leaving the living up to Lord Darlington while merely working behind the scenes of importance.

As the remains of the day sink beneath the horizon, Stevens sits on a bench waiting for the light to fade. "I gave my best to Lord Darlington. I gave him the very best I had to give, and now - well - I find I do not have a great deal more left to give."

There is an elderly man sitting beside him on the bench. The man says, "You've got to enjoy yourself. The evening's the best part of the day. You've done your day's work. Now you can put your feet up and enjoy it."

We leave Stevens in the dying light of an age, as he determines to practice his bantering technique and get back to work at Darlington Hall.

Trailer for the movie "The Remains of the Day"

More by this Author


Comments 21 comments

Docmo profile image

Docmo 5 years ago from UK

A brilliant book turned into a good film- Anthony Hopkins' performance is a masterclass in underplaying. thanks for the nostalgia!


ahorseback profile image

ahorseback 5 years ago

I love the movie and have not read the book, Emma and Anthony are perfect for this. thanks for the reminder. I love Emma in this!


dallas93444 profile image

dallas93444 5 years ago from Bakersfield, CA

Great article. Flag up!


Jane Grey profile image

Jane Grey 5 years ago from Oregon

Wow, Miss West! You've produced another masterpiece of a book review and I am thrilled to the core by the story and your own gradual dawning of love for this complex, beautiful book. I have always relied on you for the best literature recommendations, and with good reason, for your excellent choices never fail to interest me! Superb writing, as usual. I look forward to reading more from you!

Jane


Jane Grey profile image

Jane Grey 5 years ago from Oregon

Oh, and congrats on your 100th HubPage! Stellar.


Rose West profile image

Rose West 5 years ago from Michigan Author

Hi Docmo, thanks for reading - I'm glad I could bring back some good memories. Anthony Hopkins was really a bit of brilliant casting.


Rose West profile image

Rose West 5 years ago from Michigan Author

ahorseback, thanks for coming by. You really should get your hands on this book - it's great!


Rose West profile image

Rose West 5 years ago from Michigan Author

dallas93444, thanks so much for the rating - I really appreciate it!


Rose West profile image

Rose West 5 years ago from Michigan Author

Hi Jane, thanks so much! It feels really good to get back to some literature writing. This book was just too interesting to put back on the shelf without writing out my thoughts. So glad you enjoyed this!


marwan asmar profile image

marwan asmar 5 years ago from Amman, Jordan

I liked the book, so very English, others didn't think so, boring, but I thought it was a good read, maybe because I was in England, and it reminded me of things I experienced. The author captured vital moments.


Rose West profile image

Rose West 5 years ago from Michigan Author

Hi marwan asmar, this is definitely a subtle book - its strength isn't an exciting plot, but it has great depth. I liked the English factor too :) but I always do...


Bethany Culpepper 5 years ago

I've only seen the movie - you've made me want to read the book! Books are always better anyway.


Rose West profile image

Rose West 5 years ago from Michigan Author

Hi Bethany, well, if you liked the movie, you'll love the book! It is true - books are usually better. Remains of the Day was one of those books that really stuck with me.


elnavann profile image

elnavann 5 years ago from South Africa

Hi - I read the book, but have not seen the movie. Thanks, your very good review has refreshed my memory. I remember that I also took long to get into the book and then could not put it down.


Rose West profile image

Rose West 5 years ago from Michigan Author

Hi elnavann, thanks for coming by! I'm glad I could jog your memory about such a great book. You should watch the movie sometime :)


Nell Rose profile image

Nell Rose 5 years ago from England

Hi, Rose I remember the film well, it was as you said, a bit slow in places, but by the time it got nearer the end, each little bit of story, and character had come together and I realised, in surprise I must add! lol that I had actually really liked it! thanks for the reminder, cheers nell


Rose West profile image

Rose West 5 years ago from Michigan Author

Hi Nell! The story definitely grows on you. You're right about each detail coming together in the end. I was amazed as I read the book how skilled Ishiguro really is with storytelling.


ruffridyer 5 years ago from Dayton, ohio

I caught the very end of the movie on t.v. Hopkins just met his new employer and was asked to get rid of some pedgions that were in the house. He opened the windows and chased them out. It was an obvious message. The birds were free to fly away, the butler wasn't.


Rose West profile image

Rose West 5 years ago from Michigan Author

ruffridyer, good point - Mr. Stevens' chance at a different life was over. You should definitely check out the rest of the movie sometime!


Anaya M. Baker profile image

Anaya M. Baker 4 years ago from North Carolina

Thanks for the useful review! I recently read (and fell in love with) Never Let Me Go by Ishiguro, which seems like the complete opposite of Remains of the Day. The book is set in a futuristic world where human clones are grown in order to become organ donors. I've been curious about Remains of the Day just because it seems so completely different...but after reading your review, I realized there's some similar themes with the idea of dignity and personal relationships.


Rose West profile image

Rose West 4 years ago from Michigan Author

Hello, Anaya! I loved Never Let Me Go too! You're right, it is a different sort of story than Remains of the Day, but both books definitely portray Ishiguro's style and voice with similar themes. Both novels are so subtle and beautiful - they touch on people's souls more than outward plot.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working