The Cuckoo's Calling: A Cormoran Strike Mystery

JK Rowling ( Robert Galbraith)
JK Rowling ( Robert Galbraith)

The Leak

JK Rowling wanted to avoid the hype and hyperbole that surrounds her and published the book under the pseudonym Robert Galbraith. When the newspaper 'outed' Rowling as the author, many claimed that it was a marketing stunt. It was soon known that the truth was revealed by a tweet sent by one Judith Callegari, leaving Rowling wondering how a woman she never knew could leak the story.

We now know that a partner at Rowling's the law firm Russells solicitors had told the truth to Judith Callegari, his wife's friend, in a private conversation. She had promptly tweeted the story which was picked up by Sunday Times. They verified their suspicions using linguistics software developed by academic Patrick Juoma at Pittsburgh Duquesne University. This confirmed the strong likelihood of Rowling's authorship.

Rowling admitted her authorship when the paper approached her, no doubt annoyed that her plan to leave the secret a bit longer was thwarted by social media.

Crime and Adoration

I love a good book. Trouble with good books are that they are needles in the proverbial haystack. You have to wade through so many of them to find one that is memorable, meaningful, well written and utterly gripping. Sometimes, you find an author through reviews or through a good word of mouth.

Sometimes you find a good book through your trust in your favorite author.

'The Cuckoo's Calling' is the debut crime novel of one Robert Galbraith released in April 2013. The author was supposed to be a retired ex army veteran. The book received warm praise from fellow crime writers, some good reviews from reviewers who were astonished by the assured writing and intricate plotting from a debut writer. The book sold a reasonable 1500 copies from April to July. Hardly surprising, as in the overcrowded market of crime novels, it takes a while for the first time writer to make his or her mark, if they were ever destined to stardom.

The book has now shot straight into the number one slot and is selling by thousands. This was soon after the UK newspaper 'Sunday Times' revealed that Robert Galbraith, was indeed a pseudonym of JK Rowling. The story broke into a media frenzy. I, like many others, ordered the book the same day the story broke. I received the copy today and read it in one sitting. Not because I was forced to, not because I was curious, but simply because, it is one the best written crime novels I've read in a long time.

I've always admired Rowling for her masterful plotting and the meticulous characterisation of the Harry Potter series. Could lightning strike twice? Could she create another enduring series character that millions would love?

Cormoran Strike

Name: Cormoran Strike

Age: 35 years

Career: Military Police, injured in action.

Brief Bio: Born out of an illicit liaison between a famous rock star and a 'super groupie'. Cormoran's personal life is complicated, having recently broken up with his girlfriend and living out of his office. His only link to his family is his sister Lucy and her family. He has no contact with his father, but he is listed in his dad's Wikipedia page as his illegitimate son. He is kind and sensitive and has an uncanny ability to put people ease and open up.

Address: Denmark Street, London

Favorite Beer: Doom Bar

Secretary/Sidekick: Robin Ellacott

Doom Bar, Cormoran's favourite pint
Doom Bar, Cormoran's favourite pint

The Hero

Cormoran Strike, the hero of 'The Cuckoo's Calling' follows genre conventions. He is an ex Military Policeman with a colourful backstory - he lost a leg in the line of duty. He has troubled personal life and is on the verge of destitution and abject despair. He is a Private Detective in London living out of his office. The arrival of a temporary secretary Robin coincides with the arrival of a fresh case.

Investigating the apparent suicide of a supermodel Lulu Landry, who falls to her death from her apartment balcony on a cold winter day, Cormoran's personal struggles are interwoven so well with the slow burn mystery of the dead supermodel. The interplay between his new secretary and him, the array of colourful characters that he encounters in the course of the investigation, the astonishingly realised London which he inhabits, the sparkling dialogue and the satisfying denouement. What more could one want from a crime novel?

Cormoran Strike comes across as a highly likeable, fully fleshed out, character. Rowling's love of unusual names has populated her entire Harry Potter series with memorable monikers. Cormoran Strike, will be joining the canon of peculiar detective names such as Hercule Poirot and Harry Bosch.

Denmark Street, London
Denmark Street, London
A markerDenmark Street, London -
Denmark Street, London Borough of Camden, London WC2H, UK
[get directions]

Cormoran's PI Office

'Sometimes it jus' takes you over. It's un ilness.' she said, although she made the words sound like 'it's uh nillness'

Nillness, thought Strike, for a second distracted. He had slept badly. Nillness, that was where Lulu Landry had gone, and where all of them, he and Rochelle included, were headed. Sometimes illness turned slowly to nillness... sometimes nillness rose up to meet you out of nowhere, like a concrete road slamming your skull apart.


The Cuckoo's Calling, Robert Galbraith.


The Writing

The book is written in a well paced narrative. While some may find the progression to the ultimate denouement slow, I loved the richness of the characters, the splendid dialogue and scene setting and brilliantly realised descriptions. The book is so well written and described, my head was running it like a well filmed movie inside. The writing is assured and highly visual. Each character is given their moment, even the minor ones. They are all three dimensional and fully fleshed out.

There are some beautifully descriptive passages in the book. They capture the vagaries of fame and the internal motivations of these array of characters. London itself forms a stunning backdrop to the investigations, from its mix of ancient and modern - the antiquated pubs to ultramodern nightclubs, quiet moneyed neighbourhoods to scruffy alleyways, fashion shoots and deathbeds. The author creates the backdrops to every scene with panache.

The Mystery itself is intricately plotted, with satisfying clues and misdirections and a plausible solution. The ending perhaps could've been a bit more dramatic, for it feels after all the careful investigation and the slow unravelling, there could've been a bit more flair in the reveal. But that is a minor quibble.

The Cuckoo's Calling is much more than a by the numbers murder mystery. It sets up the the new hero and his sidekick very well- an immensely likeable pairing - it also creates a rich tapestry of the world the characters inhabit. I am already looking forward to the continuing adventures of Cormoran Strike. I am sure Galbraith - aka Rowling- will not disappoint.


Christina Rossetti
Christina Rossetti

A Dirge

The title 'The Cuckoo's Calling' is from a Christina Rossetti poem ' A Dirge':


Why were you born when the snow was falling?

You should have come to the cuckoo’s calling,

Or when grapes are green in the cluster,

Or, at least, when lithe swallows muster

For their far off flying From summer dying.


Why did you die when the lambs were cropping?

You should have died at the apples’ dropping,

When the grasshopper comes to trouble,

And the wheat-fields are sodden stubble,

And all winds go sighing For sweet things dying.

Series Detectives

Thankfully, Rowling has revealed a sequel is already in the works after the recent incidents and the media storm. There is always the satisfaction of a returning hero or a heroine - I have loved many series detectives over time and Cormoran has now been firmly added to my all time favourite list.

I wonder what makes a good recurring detective...

Is it their pugnacious persistence? ruthless pursuit of truth? healthy disregard for authority? Troubled personal lives? outsider looking in? A memorable and colourful backstory? Endearing eccentricities? A faithful sidekick?

However, one can't deny that however colourful the character is, unless the mystery is satisfyingly plotted, the book shall remain an empty showcase. There have been occasions where I have faithfully followed a writer and watch them slowly decline from their peak, with lazy plotting and loose writing. In such cases the early novels stand out as accomplished feats and success begets pressure and the need to publish frequently.

One can only hope Rowling, the first billionaire author of the world, has nothing more than purely literary motivations for penning this novel and its sequels. She hardly needs the money, does she?

4 stars for The Cuckoo's Calling

© 2013 Mohan Kumar

More by this Author


Comments 18 comments

johnsonrallen profile image

johnsonrallen 3 years ago from Fort Wayne, IN

What a great review! Looking forward to reading this one as well.


Daisy Mariposa profile image

Daisy Mariposa 3 years ago from Orange County (Southern California)

Mohan (Docmo),

Wow! Your review of Robert Galbraith's / JK Rowling's book is very impressive, as is all your writing. The Cuckoo's Calling sounds like a book I would enjoy reading.


Mhatter99 profile image

Mhatter99 3 years ago from San Francisco

Well written review, thank you


Jools99 profile image

Jools99 3 years ago from North-East UK

Mohan, I am not a Harry Potter fan but you have convinced me that I should read Rowling's new book with this review.

I do like a good crime novel and am a big Kate Atkinson fan - she also created a fine private detective in her novels, Jackson Brodie. I will download The Cuckoo's Calling to my Kindle (to read out in my hot garden with a bit of luck!).


midget38 profile image

midget38 3 years ago from Singapore

Rowling is a true talent! Watched a biopic of her life and was fascinated. Thanks for sharing, Doc, and will make sure everyone reads this review!


Sunshine625 profile image

Sunshine625 3 years ago from Orlando, FL

When I grow up I want to be JK Rowling. Thanks for the book review, it's on my must-read list :)


PegCole17 profile image

PegCole17 3 years ago from Dallas, Texas

Wonderful review of the newest book by J.K. Rowling aka Robert Galbraith. I've already ordered my copy from Amazon and am hoping there is stock available to fill my request! Another ongoing series by this incredible writer is like a wish fulfilled. Her amazing success with the written word is encouraging and inspirational.


tillsontitan profile image

tillsontitan 3 years ago from New York

What a fantastic and interesting book review. I think I'd have to say it is one of the best I've ever read, but then, I wouldn't expect less from you.

Now of course I want to read the book since you've made it sound so good.

Endearing eccentricities? Hmmm, who knows...once we like them though we'll follow them anywhere.

Thanks for the heads up on this one.

Voted up, useful, awesome, interesting, shared, and pinned.


Jackie Lynnley profile image

Jackie Lynnley 3 years ago from The Beautiful South

Quite an interesting read, thank you.


Docmo profile image

Docmo 3 years ago from UK Author

@johsonrallen- Thanks for reading this.

@Daisy -glad you liked my review. Thanks for sharing/tweeting.

@MHatter- much appreciated. Thanks.


Docmo profile image

Docmo 3 years ago from UK Author

@Jools - you certainly wont be disappointed - I was quite impressed by her mystery debut- but then many of the Harry Potter books always had a mystery at their core - What is more impressive is the immensely likeable lead characters. thank you!

@Michelle- Thank you- she is indeed a true talent.

@Sunshine - can't wait for you to grow up. You are already a superstar- the world wouldn't cope.


Docmo profile image

Docmo 3 years ago from UK Author

@Pegcole- Yes. I do love the promise of a new series, especially in the assured hands of Rowling. Glad you've already ordered it.

@Mary - thank you. You should read the book, it is very good. we do like to follow our favourite characters don't we?

@Jackie- Thank you very much.


drbj profile image

drbj 3 years ago from south Florida

After reading this laudatory book review, Mohan, I'm convinced that Rowling should dedicate her next book in this proposed series to you. With your splendiferous preface to her work, you convinced me to buy and read the book. Thank you. Ever so.


tobusiness profile image

tobusiness 3 years ago from Bedfordshire, U.K

Hi Doc, a great review, I saw what I thought was a hype to sell more books on the news, but of course that lady doesn't need hype. However, I found it really interesting that as an unknown, the book did not rise to the surface like the proverbial cream, which just goes to show how competitive this writing business really is. I agree with drbj, I'm also off to Amazon :).


Eiddwen profile image

Eiddwen 3 years ago from Wales

So very interesting and thanks for sharing.

Eddy.


bravewarrior profile image

bravewarrior 3 years ago from Central Florida

Great review, Doc. I like crime novels, too. I just may have to pick this one up!


Genna East profile image

Genna East 3 years ago from Massachusetts, USA

Thank you for this review, Doc. Crime fiction had been dominated by male authors for decades -- or male crime solvers -- and it’s always nice to see another female author take this growing stage. Especially, when it is JK Rowling. Almost half of the mysteries now being published are written by women. After reading this, I read an excerpt of this book online, and look forward to buying my own copy. Thanks again, Doc, for this superb hub!


BarbaraCasey profile image

BarbaraCasey 2 years ago from St. Petersburg, Florida

We're reading this for our upcoming book club meeting. The second book in the series is good, too.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working