Camlo, I've been admiring your participation in this thread. You've touched on many important points about being a responsible and thus effective writer.
Some so-called writers tend to think that sloppy craftsmanship in writing is acceptable...But I wonder, do they want a carpenter who forgets a few nails that need to be there to hold up their kitchen cabinets? When those cabinets fall down, the owner pays the price, going through the effort of tracking the carpenter down, endless phone calls to fix a problem....why? The owner already paid in good faith for a job to be done well.
It's as if you are a carpenter when you are a writer. When you write, you make a promise to your reader that you will deliver the goods. Granted, it's a silent contract, but a contract nonetheless.
This concept of commitment to a promise is too often missed in this Internet environment where anyone can write whatever they want, with whatever poor skills they choose not to improve, and no one calls them on it.
There are exceptions. For example, second-language writers struggle. Especially here at HP, where English is the only language. I admire them for putting themselves out here. For me, it would be a cold day in hell that I'd attempt to write for a Spanish or Polish language site, although I can converse in each. Most second-language writers are seeking to better their skills. It's the so-called writers who don't give a damn about how they present their words, and also justify their poor skills by saying that it doesn't matter, that are the ones I take exception to.
Hi Sherri! You know, I speak absolute fluent German, but have never attempted to do on a German site what I do on HubPages. I don't think it's the sort of place to 'practice' the language. Nevertheless, if people do, I take it into consideration whilst reading. As for those professional writers on HubPages; either they are liars or the world of writing is very unjust. You, and the Hubber Elena, for example, make no such claims yet write more or less perfectly. Well, not everyone has that kind of talent. But there's still no excuse for sloppiness or laziness. I think most of us can tell if somebody has done the best they can, and if not, we don't tend to read the Hub.
Why not? I mean it is a thread about spelling and grammar, I personally don't care as long as it isn't terrible. I can let a few errors go. The ones where every sentence is broken English and the spelling is obviously more than just a few small typos are the ones that tend to make me move on to other reading.
Both Chambers Dictionary and the Oxford Dictionary for Writers and Editors cite "spelt" as an alternative to "spelled" for the past participle of "to spell", so LaVieja is correct in her usage of this form.
Yes, absolutely. In these days of spellcheckers there is absolutely no excuse.
In my pre-freelance days of employment, when I had to go through CVs of people applying for jobs with us in order to draw up a shortlist for interview, I automatically binned any CV that contained a spelling error.
If people cannot be bothered to take the trouble to write properly, why should I take the trouble to give them any attention?
Whether right or wrong grammar imprints upon the mind of the reader the level of intelligence the author has. I'm not saying anyone is stupid, it's just the preconceived notion on the part of the reader. A mind that is tuned to correct spelling wants to receive information based on the title and content of the story. When such a mind comes across a grammar error it sticks in there, stays and detracts the mind from the intent of the story. Yes, grammar is very important and keep spellcheck on.
I hate bad spelling too but what you say about poor spellers lacking in intelligence is incorrect. They may not be native English speakers and ignorant of spelling, that doesn't make them stupid. It is our job to correct them so they can improve. But yes, it is annoying.
no spell check on forums is there........ if a person was new, i would not give them hassle about poor spelling, let them gain a bit of confidence writing first, then they can sort out spelling errors. i do not like to see spelling errors in my own work, though it does happen. Very tolerant of others spelling and grammar errors though. Why not?????
Why not????? Because it is to everybody's advantage on HubPages that the quality of hubs are as high as possible. Like so many other hubbers I often email writers with their spelling or grammar errors. If someone would send me an email correcting errors I made, I would be grateful too but it hasn't happened yet.
I ignore the occasional error on a forum message. It's easy enough to do when typing rapidly. Anything that counts as a published piece of work is a completely different matter.
Nevertheless, if someone consistently uses text-speak or their forum messages are absolutely riddled with poor grammar and spelling errors, I really do not have the inclination to wade through all the garbage in order to try to work out what they are trying to say.
If we're talking about article writing, definitely. It's pretty obvious where rare mistakes and accidents occur versus incompetence; the former only harms credibility a little, the latter warrants total dismissal.
Incorrect spelling can bother me, and can sometimes be an indicator of a more amateur writer (I speak of MYSELF) but if you can read the following then studies once again prove that we do not read every letter of each word. Enjoy and good luck!
"Can olny srmat poelpe do?
I Cdnuolt blveiee taht I cluod aulaclty uesdnatnrd waht I was rdanieg.
The phaonmneal pweor of the hmuan mnid, aoccdrnig to a rscheearch at Cmabrigde Uinervtisy, it deosn't mttaer in waht oredr the ltteers in a wrod are, the olny iprmoatnt tihng is taht the frist and lsat ltteer be in the rghit pclae.
The rset can be a taotl mses and you can sitll raed it wouthit a porbelm. Tihs is bcuseae the huamn mnid deos not raed ervey lteter by istlef, but the wrod as a wlohe.
Yaeh, and I awlyas tghuhot slpeling was ipmorant!"
To be able to use spellcheck properly, you have got to have the ability to spell in the first place. Right, Write. Their, There, They're... Some people cannot distinguish, for various reasons, and for them the constant criticism must be hard.
I find it hard to read small print, but on a computer screen it is possible to enlarge this to a comfortable level.
Otherwise, I have visual-spatial problems, so I have difficulty understanding diagrams that supposedly tell me how to fit pieces together to produce something. Therefore, I would never consider offering my services to assemble flat-pack furniture. Likewise, I do not have the capacity to be a car mechanic, computer expert, plumber, dressmaker and many other things, because I lack the basic skills and manual dexterity in such matters and therefore all the book knowledge in the world will not help me master them.
By analogy, some people lack the basic skills and/or capacity to be writers. There are many other activities in which they can become expert instead.
I disagree. Some people who cannot spell may actually be very good writers, except you wouldn't notice because they have editors to clean things up. Others write perfectly but have little to say, who is to judge?
Of course -- that's why I say 'most of us'. And also why I don't make a personal judgement about a writer (who does not claim to be a professional writer) based on spelling and grammar. I'm reading for the information offered.
General grammar and spelling errors bug me. If I read a hub or writing like that I am less likely to finish the entire thing.
But, even worse I think, is when an article doesn't get to the point or topic for eons. Or, it is all over the place with its theme and supporting paragraphs. It's mentally painful for me to read, hehe.
Actually, I'm never that bothered by errors of spelling or grammar unless ... somebody is claiming to be some sort of writing professional. It's incredible how many mistakes I find in Hubs by writers who do claim such a thing.
That's actually what prompted me to ask the question. I was browsing through hubs and found some really interesting ones, but there were so many I either just couldn't finish reading because the spelling was so bad or did read and then left immediately because I was so tempted to rate it down because of the spelling. I didn't, because I am quite new here, am not quite sure what it means to rate someone down, and it wasn't that the hub was bad, just the spelling.
I see it as something to tell the writer about, and I should do so via the contact button. of maybe we could make an ongoing post in forums ... as you dont really want comments that sit there telling you your spelling mistakes.
I do appreciate it though if anyone tells me mine. For some people too, english is their second language and its great to see them write so well when you can see they are still learning.
Yes, I agree on both points. I don't think my grammar and spelling are too bad, but I notice some of my (embarrassing) mistakes weeks after publishing. It can happen to anybody. As somebody here said before, it's important just to do the best we possibly can, even if we're not all world-class writers.
I would welcome emails on my spelling and grammatical errors. I usually find them myself (after the hub has been published) but I'm sure I miss others. I have a bad habit of letting Canadian spelling creep in (thanks to my spell check in Word which changes it without me noticing). I know it's not wrong but sometimes I have a combination of US and Canadian spelling in the one article.
It is important, matter of fact. Like your profile page, where you write "I want the world a better place for our chidren." Double spacing between words, grammatical problems, and one typo, and that is your opening statement.
Sometimes no matter how much we proofread a piece of writing there might be a few misspelled words (typos as they are called) that we might still miss. We are only human, so that is okay in my opinion, though it is best not to have any at all. However, if there is a piece of writing that has typo after typo, that is definitely a no no. It shows that the writer is careless and that actually lowers the quality of the writing. On top of that it does not send a good message to other people reading his/her work.
It is always a good idea to have other people, who have not seen your piece writing before, read through it and let you know if there are any typos present. This might help spot any typos you might have missed yourself.
Maybe we could have some kind of forum here, where we have the opportunity of proof-reading one another's work before publication. I don't have anyone at home who can do that for me, because they only speak German ...
You're right. And it could encourage even more laziness, not to mention all the other complications. But we could indicate on our Hubs whether we'd welcome readers to mention typos etc., if spotted. I, for example, would never dare make an uninvited mention of errors. It would just seem too pretentious to suggest corrections on other people's Hubs, and might not even interest the particular writer anyway.
I understand that many on HubPages are trying to become good writers. For that reason I try to be understanding when I come across spelling errors. As a retired editor, I also know how difficult it can be to produce copy free of errors.
The first requirement for producing error free copy is to care enough to make the effort. Most experienced editors go over their work more than once, and it's not uncommon for good editors to read their work (or that of others) three or more times -- for spelling, grammar, sentence structure, clarity and accuracy.
Even after all this it is not a certainty that the work is errorless.
Personally, I don't use the spell check until I am convinced the work is errorless. I do, however, consult a good dictionary or thesaurus. Now I frequently consult dictionary.com. Nevertheless, I occasionally find typos or, perhaps, I've spelled "to" when I meant to say "too."
The bottom line is that the writer has to make a genuine effort to avoid errors. It's apparent that some writers on HubPages do not double check their work for errors. I would advise all aspiring writers to do so.
When I come across spelling errors, or any of a variety of basic errors, I find it jarring and disruptive. If I'm interested in the subject and otherwise find the work worthwhile I'll continue reading. But, sometimes, I just give up.
I still remember this very successful book: Fail-Safe (1962, a novel by Eugene Burdick and Harvey Wheeler.) After reading the first chapter it was clear to me the writing was so poor that I felt it was not a worthy book to read.
In spite of everything, as you say, there's still no guarentee the work will be error free. I spot more of my own mistakes if I leave the work for at least a week before re-reading and proof-reading (to distance myself from the writing). But with this dreadful compulsion to press the PUBLISH button on HubPages ... need I say more?
"one should always aim at being interesting rather than exact" -VOLTAIREYes, i know that checking your spelling and grammer make for a better hub score, but is anyone else sick of other hubbers who you arent...
Happy Thursday, everyone! In August we pre-announced a new tool that fixes common spelling and grammatical errors across the site. Today, Editbot, the first iteration of the tool, is live on a small percentage of Hubs...
I just emailed a comment to HubPages staff but thought I'd also ask the forum group. I have a lot of errors in the comments posted on my Hubs because I write Hubs read by students and by people who are not native...
The spellcheck has never worked for me on hubpages. I click it and it either tells me a bunch of words are misspelled when they aren't or it shows no misspellings, when I know there are. I end up copying and...
How come I can't see a misspelled word in my own Hubs, but I can spot one a mile away on someone else's Hubs? I read one today that had a word used incorrectly (could have two different meanings, but spelled the...
Sometimes (or let's say, often), when I see a spelling error in an otherwise perfect hub, I feel inclined, with the best of intentions, to write to the author and point out the glitch, but don't do so out of fear of...