It's really sad when people start to only post on your writings so they can gain more traffic to their site with no general interest in your writing and no actual true criticism to give to help you improve as a writer. Just wanting you to take look at their site and you to take an interest in their work. Why can't people just respect the sanctuary of work and at least try to give some kind of criticism whether good or bad. Actually read the work and respond to it. Not just be interested in their own benefits. Like how I am almost certain someone will use this forum to do the same thing as I just mentioned above. It's upsetting that people can take something as great as Hubpages where you are free to post your work and have it read, admired or critiqued and than change it into another media and money driven place that destroys what I can believe is a thoughtful comment or just another shameless desperate person trying to find someone to look at their work. Please let me know how you feel on this topic and maybe ideas on how we can try to change this and make it a place free for writers to write and communicate to other writers about their writings truthfully and help each other grow as writers.
I agree with rebekahELLE: set your comments to require your approval and just deny any obvious plugs. That's the high road that takes slightly more effort because you have to manually manage all your comments.
The low road would be to simply take advantage of their plug to advertise yourself on their site, but most of us wouldn't do that as we prefer to promote ourselves when it's contextual. Time and place for everything, and all that cliched jazz.
Speaking of constructive criticism: I may be alone in thinking this but seems to me that your post could benefit from at least one paragraph break. Few people like a massive block of text. I know this is just the forums, but with online writing I find it best to practice proper writing format every single time you write so you don't accidentally develop bad habits.
I deny comments with a shameless plug. The hubber will get the message if those comments are denied. I'm sure I've let some slip through, but I've noticed they're happening more often now.
I had one yesterday from someone who had just joined. I'm sure they didn't read the hub or the learning center.
I agree. We are free to deny comments whenever we wish. I have only had to do this once....thank goodness.
I didn't read the learning centre, in fact still haven't, but it's obvious that just plugging away is bad form. And pretty obvious that the comments section is for comments about the hub. Same as the blatant follow me, follow you nonsense. It all means that it just becomes meaningless, pointless. Which is a shame.
As I say, I did not get this from the learning centre because it should be obvious to anyone.
Squidoo has 'strip-out HTML from comments' feature so i guess HP should implement similar here.
by Catherine Mostly2 years ago
First, apologies to Tori since it will SEEM like I'm picking on her HotD - I'm not. These featured hubs need to be touched by an editor if Hubpages is ever going to be taken seriously as a 'real' writing site.1. The...
by FelineFrance5 years ago
Okay, here is my problem I try to learn every freakin' detail about my main character before I start writing. I am very afraid of criticism and allowing others to read my work. I wish there was a way to make myself...
by Haunty7 years ago
I find that most of the comments on hp are either thanking or reassuring the writer. I think hubbers believe it's worth more petting the writer on the back than telling him or her if something feels wrong. This way we...
by Simon Cook4 years ago
It would be interesting to be able to see the Hub Hop ratings on my hubs - this will help me understand what areas I need to work on and which areas I am doing well on....
by Jenny Pugh4 years ago
I still consider myself new here and per observation, there is an existing bias by writers here in terms of giving comments and responses to the write ups.
by Gavin Wichmann3 years ago
Hey, I'm a new hubber, and I have a big question concerning my hubs.I'm a creative writer, and I'm trying to use hubpages to get feedback on my work.Is there a place here where I would get in touch with other authors...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.