Best Bagel Toaster for That Perfect Crunch

There's nothing like a perfectly toasted bagel.
There's nothing like a perfectly toasted bagel. | Source

Toasting the Perfect Bagel

If you are like many people, you love a perfectly toasted bagel in the morning, but not all toasters work well on bagels. Some toast evenly on both sides, leaving the top and bottom of the bagel crunchy and hard - not the desired result. A good bagel toaster will only toast the cut side of the bagel and must be big enough to handle a typical half, which is often larger than a standard slice of bread.

For this job, a typical toaster oven or appliance made for just bread will not do the same quality job as a machine made for the bagels we love. Let's take a look at some of the top small appliances out there that will do a superb job.

Most Wanted Bagel Toaster Features

Here is what you really want in a toaster if the ultimate goal is a bagel with a crispy cut side and warm but not crusty top or bottom. At a bare minimum, the toaster must include these features.

  • wide slots for the bagel
  • ability to toast only the cut side of the bagel
  • easy cancel operation to eject the bagel


That's really it! The good news is that yo can find these features in a number of small appliance toasters these days, so it's easier than ever to find a machine that will work well. The bad news is that there are a lot of toasters with these features these days, making the final choice mind-numbing. To help you out, here are the top rated toasters available today, specifically noted for being loved by their owners for the ability of each to produce a perfectly toasted bagel.

Match Your Small Appliance to Your Big Ones

BLACK+DECKER TR1400SB 4-Slice Toaster, Bagel Toaster, Black/Stainless Steel
BLACK+DECKER TR1400SB 4-Slice Toaster, Bagel Toaster, Black/Stainless Steel

The modern look and flexibility of the Black & Decker TR1400SB make it a great buy. If you leave your toaster out for all to see, why not match the other stainless steel appliances already in your kitchen. This sharp toaster will serve a crowd and look good at the same time.

This model has an attractive brushed stainless steel exterior and the slots raise the bagel high so you can get them out. The cord is fully retractable into the toaster and it also has self-centering slots, so toasting is even.

 

Should You Toast Bagels?

This is a question that can be debated. The answer, of course, depends on your personal preference, but here is some advice. If you have bagels purchased fresh from the bakery this morning, it's probably in the perfect eating state right now. A great, fresh bagel is soft on the inside and has a pleasant crisp outer shell, especially on the top. Putting this in the toaster is strange to many people, but still, others just like the extra crispiness that only a bagel toaster can offer.

Bagels that are purchased from the grocery store or those that are past their prime, however, can be considerably better when toasted. These bagels tend to be void of that crispy shell, and are much more bread-like. The added crunch from a medium toasting adds welcome texture.

Inexpensive Red Toaster Adds Spice to the Kitchen

Proctor Silex 2 Slice Bagel Toaster, Red
Proctor Silex 2 Slice Bagel Toaster, Red

Great style matches great price with the Silex by Proctor. It's fun to splash some color around the kitchen, and small appliances like a mixer, coffee maker, or toaster are a great way to do it. This little toaster makes a statement with a bright, happy color. More importantly, it does a great job.

Owners of this machine like how evenly it toasts, and the built-in cord wrap for easy storage. They also appreciate the wide slots for bagels and the cancel button to get them out when they are just perfect.

 

Improve Store Bagels

Plain bagels from the bread aisle or freezer of the grocery store are great, but toasted bagels have that crispy texture that makes them awesome. This is because these bagels found at the store tend to be different than those made daily at the local bagel bakery. The nice thing about having a toaster that can really handle the extra width of a bagel is that it opens up the possibility of using frozen or day-old bagels, since they will toast nicely just like their fresh counterparts. This will expand your options and save you money if you choose.

If you're looking for a new toaster, and one that has the wide slots needed, these toasters are all quality choices and the highest rated by those that use them.

Brushed Metal Hides Fingerprints

Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Toaster - Brushed Metal
Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Toaster - Brushed Metal

If you want metal accents in your kitchen, this brushed steel model from Hamilton Beach looks awesome, and the brushed steel finish does a pretty good job of hiding fingerprints, unlike a shiny stainless steel finish would.

One of the best features that owners talk about is the defrost feature which works very well, This allows you to keep bagels in the freezer right up to the point you are ready to toast them, excellent for the occasional bagel eater.

 

How Do You Like Your Bagel?

What topping is best on a bagel?

See results without voting

Make Your Own Bagels!

If you want the freshest bagel possible but don't feel like driving to the store, or you can't find exactly the kind you want, make your own! Be advised, that making your own from scratch is not foolproof, and it takes some getting used to, but there are plenty of simple-to-follow recipes out there to get you started. Here are some very highly rates ones that you should check out.

Classic Recipe - For a classic bagel that can be amended with your favorite toppings or fillings,this recipe is a great place to start.

Bread Machine Recipe - If you already have a bread machine, use it to make your own bagels too! This recipe will show you how.

More by this Author


Got any bagel toasting advice?

No comments yet.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working