jump to last post 1-12 of 12 discussions (32 posts)

Should the paper $1 bill be replaced with a coin in the US?

  1. profile image0
    Deb Welchposted 4 years ago

    http://s3.hubimg.com/u/6665522_f248.jpg
    Con:   A coin would be a little heavier to carry around.
    Pro:    It would save a small fortune in not having to
               replace damaged bills.

    What are your reasons?

    1. Sherry Hewins profile image95
      Sherry Hewinsposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      No! Absolutely not, As you pointed out the coins are heavy, and I always end up with a lot of ones. My local post office was giving those Susan B Anthony dollars as change from their stamp machine, and I can tell you they were a real pain, really hard to distinguish from a quarter. If there was a dollar coin it would have to look and feel far different from any existing coin.

      Actually I think it would be a better plan to get rid of pennies.

      1. profile image0
        Deb Welchposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        I believe Canada has or is getting rid of the penny.  I do see a few $1 dollar coins around, they are much larger than a quarter - they should make them lighter - if they get rid of the folding bill.

    2. kschang profile image90
      kschangposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      I have dollar coins. The gold ones. They are NOT widely accepted at vending machines.

      And the US paper money, being made of cotton/linen, not paper, is much more durable than similar "paper bills" in other countries.

      So the savings are much less than you think. Indeed, this was discussed on NPR not long ago.

    3. Ramsa1 profile image70
      Ramsa1posted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Keep the paper bill. The cost of producing it is nothing compared to the inconvenience of carrying around coins. In Canada they have dollar and two dollar coins. Most transaction are paperless anyway. And the argument about the cost is extremely weak. How many TRILLIONS have been wasted, and continue to be wasted, on all kinds of stupid wars - drugs, on non-existent WMDs, the war to crush al-Quieda (America and NATO are now quietly talking peace with them). Keep the dollar bill.

      1. Marisa Wright profile image93
        Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        So if we're wasting money in one area, that gives us permission to waste money everywhere else as well?  That's not a logical argument. 

        I don't know the relative costs, but it's so common for countries to convert their low-value bills to coins, I'd say the savings must be significant.  As bankscottage says, it's not about the cost to produce - it's about the lifespan.  If it costs $1 to produce a dollar coin which will last 20 years, then a dollar bill would have to cost less than 5c to compete.

  2. bankscottage profile image92
    bankscottageposted 4 years ago

    Absolutely, replace the paper bill.  The coin would last a lot longer than a paper bill.  The loonie and toonie seem to have worked well for Canada.  The US wouldn't have to mint more dollar coins.  They already have them.  They minted too many presidential dollars and they never ended up in circulation.  After collectors, almost no one else uses them.
    I guess the biggest issue preventing the conversion is vending machines.  Almost all will take a paper bill, but few take a dollar coin.  It could be expensive to convert all of these machines.
    While we are at it, lets get rid of the penny.  It costs more than a penny to make one

    1. TheMagician profile image95
      TheMagicianposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Amen!

    2. internpete profile image91
      internpeteposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Yep, totally with you here!

    3. profile image0
      Deb Welchposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      bank - You are right about vending machines or public transportation.  Abraham Lincoln is on the penny - and - maybe that is why we hang on to it.

    4. bankscottage profile image92
      bankscottageposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Just read an article in the WSJ from 5/18 about an "underground" paper currency in Canada.  Seems Canadian Tire stores give "paper money" as little refunds on your purchases the next time you shop.  They range in value from 5 cents to $2 I believe.  They are made so that they can't make counterfit copies.  In addition to using them, people like to collect them, particularly the older ones.  Guess paper money may never really go away.

      1. Ramsa1 profile image70
        Ramsa1posted 4 years ago in reply to this

        The Canadian Tire money can be used at Canadian Tire stores just like cash.

  3. FatFreddysCat profile image95
    FatFreddysCatposted 4 years ago

    The U.S. has tried to get a "dollar coin" to catch on several times over the years but has never had much luck. Any children of the '80s here remember all the whoop-de-doo over those shiny new Susan B. Anthony dollars? Where have you seen any of them lately? big_smile

    1. bankscottage profile image92
      bankscottageposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      All the US has to do is what Canada did.  Quit printing dollar bills and collect all of those still out.  They could make it happen if they wanted to.
      I think my Susan B. Anthonys are next to my Sacaguwea dollars.  My Peace and Morgans are in the safe.

  4. internpete profile image91
    internpeteposted 4 years ago

    Yes! After living in Japan for 10 years, where the smallest paper bill is 1000 yen, or about 10$, I find the US 1$ bill annoying. Plus the government wastes a lot of money replacing the paper bills every 2 years or so I believe. It would be a tough thing for Americans to get used to, but it could work. Japan also has a 5$ equivalent coin. Imagine getting rid of the 5$ bill as well?

    1. profile image0
      Deb Welchposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      intern - I agree the US needs an upgrade.

    2. bankscottage profile image92
      bankscottageposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      At one time the US had a $20 gold coin.  If anyone doesn't want theirs, I'll give you a nice crisp $20 bill for each that you want to get rid of wink

  5. Marisa Wright profile image93
    Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago

    Australia has $1 and $2 coins, and our smallest coin is the 5 cent piece. 

    As Bankscottage says, all the government has to do is start minting coins.  Then as the $1 notes are returned to the banks in the normal course of business, don't reissue them.

    If you can't bear to part with the note, why not make your notes out of plastic instead of paper, like us?  You can even put them through the washing machine.

    1. profile image0
      Deb Welchposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      Marisa - Australia is similar to Canada with the $1 & $2 coins.  You don't use the plastic money - do you - is it only for a keepsake?

      1. Marisa Wright profile image93
        Marisa Wrightposted 4 years ago in reply to this

        Yes, our $1 and $2 coins are similar to Canada, and to the pound coins in the UK - although they made the pound coin in the UK really, really thick and heavy for some reason. 

        It's our notes that are made out of a special polymer (plastic).  They cost more to make than paper notes, but they last a LOT longer than paper (like I say, you can even put them through the washing machine and they'll survive).  So in the end, they're saving the country a lot of money in printing costs.

        http://www.questacon.edu.au/indepth/cle … notes.html

        It's a very soft plastic and you can fold it just like paper money.

        1. profile image0
          Deb Welchposted 4 years ago in reply to this

          Marisa - Fabulous idea.

          1. profile image0
            Deb Welchposted 4 years ago in reply to this

            Thanks for the article link.

  6. TheMagician profile image95
    TheMagicianposted 4 years ago

    The number one reason I'm down with dollar coins is because I'll get to feel like a pirate... I'd keep a treasure chest full of them! big_smile

    1. profile image0
      Deb Welchposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      TheMagic - I save my small change and sometimes donate it to  those CoinStar machines.  I would not mind giving up the paper dollar bill.

  7. onegreenparachute profile image85
    onegreenparachuteposted 4 years ago

    As a Canadian I can say our loonies and toonies have been a success.  I'm all for saving our tax money! 
    I was a cashier when the loonies first came out and there was a great deal of moaning and whining - especially by the older set - in the beginning.  People forgot to use them and their pockets and purses became too heavy.  Eventually we all got used to spending them and they became part of our lives.  I think we are getting rid of the penny next.
    We live in Arizona for the winter months.  We try to be good "tourists" when there but we do find American money to be a bit of a pain.  Because each denomination is the same colour it's easy to mix them up.  I understand that the "greenback" is an honoured tradition but sometimes change is good!

    1. profile image0
      Deb Welchposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      I like the Canadian loonies and toonies.  I know they complain about our bills being all green and then we complain that all those foreign colorful bills remind us of play money from a game.

  8. Gloshei profile image61
    Glosheiposted 4 years ago

    I hope not for your sake, they did thid to the pound note in UK when we went decimal and they certainly bulge your purse out.
    They add a lot more weight for you to carry around as well.

  9. Anne Losch profile image79
    Anne Loschposted 4 years ago

    No, making the coin would cost too much.  I think we should reduce our use of paper money and work towards total electronic money.  Many people pay their bills online and buy groceries with their credit or debit card anyway.

  10. ibbarkingmad profile image87
    ibbarkingmadposted 4 years ago

    No it will not. Mint coins costs more than printing dollar bills. If the government is considering not minting any more pennies because it is so expensive (thank you Federal Reserve for debasing our currency!) then why would the US Mint start making coins that cost more than bills? No, the dollar bill is here to stay. There would be no logical reason to replace it with coins.

  11. bankscottage profile image92
    bankscottageposted 4 years ago

    A coin will last far longer than a dollar.  While a coin would cost far more to mint than a paper dollar to print, the cost of every dollar bill printed and replaced over the life of the coin would have to calculated.  I believe a dollar bill last about 2 years.  A coin would easily last 20 if not many more.  So for every coin minted at least 10 dollars would have to be printed.  We would have to know the cost of minting versus printing times 10 to see which is the most cost effective.

    1. profile image0
      Deb Welchposted 4 years ago in reply to this

      I really like Australia's plastic money - that would certainly save on replacement of all money denominations.

  12. psycheskinner profile image82
    psycheskinnerposted 4 years ago

    Yes, because making the coins actually costs a hell of a lot less overall, they last pretty much forever when the paper bills make it barely a year on average.  We still have paper dollars mainly due to lobbying from the paper industry. Also paper bills should move to a longer lasting plastic based model like in other countries.

 
working