Gandhi and the Threat to his Leadership by Bhagat Singh

Bhagat Singh
Bhagat Singh

Bhagat Singh and Gandhi

Bhagat Singh and Gandhi are two leaders who fought for the independence of India. Gandhi is better known outside India, but Bhagat Singh has an equal following in India. Gandhi is accused of being lukewarm to the hanging of Bhagat Singh. He made no appeal to the Viceroy and was content to let Bhagat Singh hang. Bhagat was hanged by the British on 23 March 1931. He was only 24 years old. Gandhi himself was assassinated by Hindu zealots on 30 January 1948, fed up with his policy of appeasement to the Muslims.

Why Bhagat Singh was hanged.

Bhagat Singh had realized that the only way India could win freedom was by a violent revolution. In this task he was assisted by some more young men. But his was a small group and he did not realize that a revolution is a mass movement, not a sporadic act by a few people. He and his companion hurled a bomb in the Punjab assembly at Lahore. The bomb was thrown in an empty space and after the bombing; Bhagat did not flee, but surrendered. He later said his aim was not to kill anyone, but to highlight the eveil effects of British rule.

Earlier the British Superintendent of Police who had rained lathe blows on Lala Lajpat Rai during a peaceful march had been shot dead. The murder was traced to Bhagat and his group and he was also put on trial for this murder. Lala Lajpat Rai was a great freedom fighter from Punjab and Bhagat had vowed to avenge his death. The Lala’s last words are significant. He had said” Every blow struck at me is a nail in the coffin of the British empire”

The Empire could not let Bhagat Singh live and accordingly he was hanged in the dead of the night secretly.

Gandhi and the Myth of Non-Violence

Gandhi is universally recognized as an apostle of non violence. Much of this myth is propagated by Richard Attenborough in his film Gandhi as well as the works of pro-Gandhi elements. In addition Gandhi himself carefully cultivated an image for the west. Bhagat Singh by comparison has had a number of films made about him, but none by a foreigner. In contrast to Gandhi, Bhagat Singh believed in violence as a means to an end. He had read Marx and Lenin and was greatly influenced by them. He was thus the anti thesis of Gandhi.

Bhagat Singh Challenged Leadership of Gandhi

Bhagat Singh was a serious challenger to Gandhi’s leadership. It is worth quoting Pattabhi Sitaramayya, a top Congress leader and Gandhi loyalist, who stated 'It is no exaggeration to say that at the moment Bhagat Singh’s name is as widely known all over India and is as popular as Gandhi”.

In the twenties of the last century Bhagat Singh had emerged as a serious contented as the leader of the Indian masses. Many saw him as a messiah and were fired by his revolutionary zeal. Gandhi felt threatened. His carefully cultivated image and leadership was under threat and the older man was loathe to hand over the mantle of his leadership to Bhagat Singh. He thus took a stand against Bhagat Singh to a point, where he decided not to exert to save Bhagat Singh from the gallows.

Gandhi Failed to Act

Many representations were made to Gandhi to appeal to the Viceroy, but Gandhi refused and wrote that he did not favor any violence. This was just a ploy to retain the leadership of the political movement. He felt Bhagat Singh was a threat and hence took this stand. Gandhi was greeted by black flags everywhere he went after the hanging of Bhagat Singh, but he remained unfazed.

The British also showed they were poor sticklers of the law as they hanged Bhagat Singh against the Jail manual which specified hangings to be done at first light in the morning, by hanging Bhagat Singh at midnight. It was a nefarious act and showed the British were scared of a massive movement by the people to free Bhagat Singh

Last Word

Bhagat Singh was too young to understand the intricacies of a revolution. He failed to properly organize a revolution, despite tremendous support. Gandhi on the other hand was a sly old man who knew that an alive Bhagat Singh was a threat to him, hence his course of action to let Bhagat hang despite popular clamor for his release.

More by this Author


Comments 4 comments

pramodgokhale profile image

pramodgokhale 3 years ago from Pune( India)

Sir,

your article is a contrasts of both Bhagat Singh and Gandhi and to some extent creates controversy. Bhagat Singh is a martyr and Gandhi was assassinated and his followers made him martyr.

Appeasement of Muslims and riots after partition and massacre of Hindus en mass was the reason of Gandhi' murder.

30% Indian population fought for freedom, remaining were happy under British regime.

Bhagat Singh sacrificed for Mother India , route was different , Gandhi did not request for his release and appeal to cancel his hanging.

Many congress leaders enjoyed privileges in jail, courtesy British regime.

Churchill long back predicted that Congress thugs will loot and plunder India, unfortunately he proved right.

These controversies has no end.He would have been competitor of Gandhi

pramodgokhale


MG Singh profile image

MG Singh 3 years ago from Singapore Author

Thank you Promod for commenting.


Proud Indian 3 years ago

Thank you Mr Singh for tearing Gandhi's mask and shining the light on the late blessed Mr Bhagat Singh who fought for independence through the methods he felt were most practical for him. It is without doubt that Westerners would take offence against his means (violence), but remember it was violence to achieve a highly desirable end. The unfortunate aspects of Gandhi are:

1)He's remembered as the father of India's independence (a lie)

2)Foreigners, particularly Westerners believe that Indians are generally peaceful, like Gandhi and so can be exploited

3)Many Indians have lost their sense of pride in the nation and their culture, preferring instead to desperately seek a Green Card or equivalent; they are offspring of Gandhi's Western-placating (to the point of idolizing) views

It is time Indians awoke and destroyed this myth of Gandhi before it destroys India


MG Singh profile image

MG Singh 3 years ago from Singapore Author

Thank you Proud Indian. India could have done without Gandhi

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working