Happy Holidays? The Separation of Church and State and the Politics of Season's Greetings in the United States

Source

Introduction

In recent years, Americans come to a heated debate every time the holiday season comes around. In one camp, there are those who decry the public utterance of "Merry Christmas" as politically incorrect and insensitive to otherwise religious non-Christians and atheists alike. In lieu of this traditional holiday greeting, "Happy Holidays" has been heavily promoted as a politically sensitive umbrella term alternative. Opponents on the more extreme end of the debate view this movement as a direct attack on Christmas and, by extension, Christian values. Common rhetoric from this side of the debate invokes freedom of speech infringement. However, I would argue that this is a non-issue unworthy of the politically charged scrutiny and backlash it receives.

As Regards the Perceived Attack on Christian Values

Christmas as typically celebrated in the United States is not as Christian as it is ostensibly promoted to be. Iconic symbols of Christmas popular in the Western world such as Christmas trees, wreaths, mistletoe, and yule logs have their origin in pre-Christian pagan celebrations of the Northern European Scandinavian and Germanic peoples. December 25th has commonly been celebrated by ancient peoples as the shortest day of the year in the Northern Hemisphere, marking the gradual approach of the coming spring. Northern European pagans lived tenuously in a climate where winter was a particularly long, cold, and barren season for people who depend so heavily on tillage of the land and animal husbandry for survival.

Source

As such, harboring spruce trees and branches in their homesteads over the winter, as modern Westerners do with Christmas trees and wreaths, was symbolic of the approaching spring that would bring winter reprieve. Modern Westerners associate the 25th of December with the birth of Jesus Christ, but in fact, there is currently no evidence which definitively dates the day or even year of Christ's birth. Scandinavian and other Northern Germanic peoples were the last in Europe to be converted to and adopt Christianity, which meant that their pagan traditions had a unique influence on contemporary Europe. As such, the pagan solstice celebration was gleaned over as a Christian holiday during the Christianization of Northern Europe and the 25th of December was appropriated as the birth date of Jesus Christ. As noted above, other choice pagan traditions have also played a role in the evolution of modern Christmas celebrations. I argue that the astoundingly non-Christian origins of modern Christmas traditions weakens the assertion that promoting "Happy Holidays" over "Merry Christmas" works as an affront to Christian values because modern Christmas traditions themselves, as many Puritans argue, work to undermine Christian values.

There is Arguably Far More than One Christmas Holiday

Despite the pagan origins of modern Christmas traditions, the fact remains that it is still ostensibly a Christian holiday. However, it is illogical for Christians to take offence when the utterance of "Merry Christmas" is decried as politically incorrect because Christmas itself is made up of several distinct days of celebration. In addition to Christmas Day, Christmas Eve is a veritable holiday in its own right, as well as the four days of Advent leading up to Christmas, the Twelve Days of Christmas, the Twelfth Night, and the Feast of Epiphany. Thus, "Happy Holidays" may simply be interpreted to encompass a plethora of Christmas holiday celebrations.

Breakdown of Religious Affiliation in the United States as of 2008

Religion
Percent
 
Protestant
51%
 
Catholic
25%
 
Non-Religious
19.6%
 
Other Religion
6%
 
Unsure
1.4%
 

For the Sake of Inclusivity

Major proponents of "Happy Holidays" argue that there are a considerable number of people in the United States who do not observe Christmas. For them, "Happy Holidays" is not meant only to encompass the various days of Christmas celebration, but also those of other religions which happen during the same holiday season such as Hanukkah and Kwanzaa, as well as secular holidays such as New Year's (Day and Eve) and Thanksgiving. Furthermore, proponents also wish often to take the sensibilities of atheists, agnostics, and humanists into account who are reasonably wary of religious sentiment in public settings. However, as outlined in the chart above, the vast majority of Americans are Christians who presumably celebrate Christmas. The tension, then, clearly stems from friction between the ideal of political correctness toward the minority and the perceived threat to the long-standing traditions of the majority. The question, then, is whether political correctness for the sake of the minority is worth inconveniencing the majority. The answer demands thorough consideration of the justifiable rights of the minority and the extent to which the majority is "inconvenienced" in this matter.

Freedom of Speech and the Separation of Church and State

The separation of church and state as outlined (but interestingly not so named) in the First Amendment to the United States Constitution has consistently resulted in modern controversies regarding the presence of religious (particularly Christian) sentiment, language, and iconography in public and government sectors, such as schools and public government buildings.

Constitution of the United States
Constitution of the United States | Source

The Constitution explicitly demands the government remain neutral as regards the matter of religion and forbids the promotion of any particular religious doctrine: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof." As such, it seems logical that policy discourage the promotion of Christmas, a Christian holiday, to the general public through the medium of political and, increasingly more importantly, corporate rhetoric. However, the censorship of "Merry Christmas" seems to undermine freedom of religious exercise (as noted in the above quotation) and America's constitutional virtue of free speech. Clearly this is a nuanced issue with many layers. It is the right of any given citizen to wish "Merry Christmas" to anyone else in the general public as in accordance with freedom of speech. It is however a stretch to conflate this with freedom of religious expression. As I have outlined above, modern Christmas traditions may be ostensibly Christian, but their historical roots are overwhelmingly pagan. There is still, however, the matter of governmental and corporate expressions of season's greetings. I maintain that government officials and customer service representatives are bound by the tenets of political correctness to the point of catering to the needs of the minority, which incidentally does not logically infringe on the needs of the majority, for whom Christmas is also considered under the diplomatic umbrella of "Happy Holidays". In summary, regular citizens have the right to express season's greetings from a Christian perspective and non-Christians have the right to expect a religion-neutral greeting from government and customer service representatives.

As a Christmas celebrating Christian, how offended would you be if you were greeted with "Happy Holidays" rather than "Merry Christmas"?

  • Extremely
  • Very
  • Somewhat
  • Barely
  • Not At All
See results without voting

More by this Author


Comments 11 comments

jlpark profile image

jlpark 2 years ago from New Zealand

Given that Christmas is well timed to fall within the same time periods as Hannukah, Yule, Solstice etc - I think that Happy Holidays is very inclusive, and doesn't 'favour' one faith (or lack thereof) over another.

To be offended by someone wishing you well, who may or may not know your religious beliefs, by saying "Happy Holidays" would be as silly as me getting offended by "Merry Christmas" as a non-believer in the Christian God, or that no, I didn't have a Merry Xmas, or a Happy holiday last year. They are trying to be nice and wish you the happy holiday of whichever version you celebrate, without being nosey as to who you may or may not worship.

And what about those of Jehovahs Witness belief - I don't see them stamping their feet when wished Merry Christmas or Happy Holidays, when they do not celebrate Christmas or Birthdays (Including that of Jesus) as a rule.

A period of time once a year, that has many religious (and non) history and customs around it - Happy Holidays is the better of the lot - it encompasses everyone.

But, I do agree it is a little PC overkill in a way...but nothing to get offended about....In My Humble Opinion (which may or may not count for anything!)


Spongy0llama profile image

Spongy0llama 2 years ago from Canada Author

Thank you for your comment. I completely agree with your opinion. It does not come through in this article though because I purposefully avoid giving my own opinion on either side of a polarizing argument. I opt rather to present the perspectives from both sides of the issue in order to understand the most effective point of reconciliation.

Despite the logic of your comment, the fact remains that many people actively oppose "Happy Holidays" in the context of a broader threat to the sanctity of Christmas. This is why I try to treat the matter from different angles, rather than state the obvious. This is, by the way, a writing style which helps me boost my hub's word count ;)


someonewhoknows profile image

someonewhoknows 2 years ago from south and west of canada,north of ohio

As I recall there was a cease fire during warfare on Christmas day .Don't remember the conflict I believe it did happen and that those doing the fighting did not really want to be fighting each other. That's just the way they felt about and yet the day after they continued with the fighting.


Spongy0llama profile image

Spongy0llama 2 years ago from Canada Author

You are referring to the First World War, when American and German infantrymen gave up fighting and came on friendly terms on the "no man's land" between both opposing trenches. This happened during Christmas in the holiday spirit of good will toward man. However, upper ranks cracked down on these "ceasefires" and nationalist and military propaganda continued to ensure the senseless slaughter and destruction of human lives. War is abominable and unjustified regardless of the circumstances. The war-torn history of the twentieth century sickens me.


lions44 profile image

lions44 2 years ago from Auburn, WA

Growing up in New York City, we used Happy Holidays all the time because there was such a large Jewish population. So I don't see what the big deal is. The spirit of the greeting is what matters.


Spongy0llama profile image

Spongy0llama 2 years ago from Canada Author

I grew up in a very rural, predominantly baptist community in Canada where this has become a very contentious issue. I suspect the same is true throughout the rural United States, particularly around Bible Belt middle America.


reinhardBeck profile image

reinhardBeck 20 months ago from LEEDS

Happy Holidays!

And why am I having a holiday? To celebrate Christmas.

In that case it's: Happy Christmas.

If other people have a problem with that why do they have the right to create a problem for me?


Spongy0llama profile image

Spongy0llama 20 months ago from Canada Author

No one is trying to take away your right to say whatever you want on your own time. However, it is fair for employers to insist that their employees use a neutral holiday greeting when on duty so that the business or company is not seen to prefer one religious observance over another.

If you say "Happy Christmas" to someone who doesn't celebrate Christmas, it's not likely to offend them. It is however a sign of ignorance and undue entitlement to assume Christmas takes priority over other religious celebrations in the public sphere.


someonewhoknows profile image

someonewhoknows 20 months ago from south and west of canada,north of ohio

If,you think about it the word Holiday refers to a "holy day" which tends to have a religious aspect to it. Yet ,we use the word "holiday " in reference to all celebration days.Thus happy holidays seems more appropriate.Even so! It,still refers to a "holy - day" as long as you use that word. Secular holidays as well as other so- called religious days that have nothing to do with religion.


Spongy0llama profile image

Spongy0llama 20 months ago from Canada Author

I'm not sure exactly what you are trying to say. It is true that the word "holiday" is a modern form of the Middle English word for "holy day", but in modern English, it refers to a variety of secular celebrations and observances as well. Deconstruction of the word itself is a matter of linguistics, and not of religion.


someonewhoknows profile image

someonewhoknows 20 months ago from south and west of canada,north of ohio

One of Webster's dictionary definition's of - "Secular" - "indifference" to or "rejection" or "exclusion of religion and religious considerations". That doesn't mean a particular holiday doesn't have a meaning that's just as important to certain individuals as religious holidays are to others. However I agree that the majority likely see most holidays as secular .

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working