Justice: Is It Wise to Let Stew Leonard Stay in Prison?

Stew Leonard Sr., Entrepeneur: 'Our Mission Is To Create Happy Customers'

Stew Leonard Sr.
Stew Leonard Sr.

Stew Leonard's in Yonkers

Stew Leonard's Yonkers, N.Y., Store located at 1 Stew Leonard Drive
Stew Leonard's Yonkers, N.Y., Store located at 1 Stew Leonard Drive

'The Customer Is Always Right'

Stew Leonard's Rock Policy: Rule 1: The Customer Is Always Right. Rule 2: If the Customer Is Ever Wrong, Reread Rule 1
Stew Leonard's Rock Policy: Rule 1: The Customer Is Always Right. Rule 2: If the Customer Is Ever Wrong, Reread Rule 1

Stew Leonard Sr. shouldn't be in prison!

That is not to say he should not be punished for the grievous offenses he has admitted to -- offenses he's been convicted of and sentenced for -- and for which he is now serving time (allowing for his four-week hiatus for hip surgery.)

Certainly Stew deserves to spend time in prison for violating the laws, and for violating the trust of all who know him. The fact that he does not find prison to be conducive to his well-being falls far short of justification for reduction of his sentence.

Neither does his assertion that he's "a changed man" hold any water. As U.S. District Court Judge Peter Dorsey said, the original sentence was intended to punish Stew for his conduct over a long period of time.

Loss of 'Moral Center' Admitted

Stew admits losing his principles, his business integrity and his "moral center," as he put it. Such admission amounts to justification for the judge's position.

But the reason Stew "deserves" to be in prison is that our judicial system, flawed as it is, prescribes prison for most convicted felons. Others convicted of similar, and even less grievous offenses, are required to spend years in prison. Stew cannot be exempt from such punishment; indeed, there are many who would argue he should be held up as an example and punished more severely than others.

While Stew deserves to be in prison, he shouldn't be in prison -- simply because prison is not a very intelligent way to punish people!

But, insofar as that's the system as it now stands, Stew must stew in prison, along with thousands of others whom we must feed, house and otherwise maintain at great expense with little or nothing to show for it.

As a society, we haven't given much thought to the way we punish criminals; we go along with the same old way it's been done for centuries; throw them in jail and forget about them.

But how effective has it been? Has the imprisonment of criminals put the fear of God into men and brought about significant reduction in crime? Hardly.

No Room in the Prisons

The courts have taken steps on their own -- in my judgment extralegal steps -- to modify sentences imposed by statute primarily because judges know there's no room in prison to hold the growing number of convicted criminals.

Plea bargaining and probation have been employed to try to make room in our prisons for serious, violent offenders. But even that hasn't worked; too often prisoners who do not deserve freedom have had their terms cut short because of overpopulation, deemed to be illegal.

The old cliché, "Let the punishment fit the crime," continues to be looked at more closely.

Why not take a good close look at every category of crime and determine anew what would be an appropriate -- and realistic -- punishment for those convicted.

If the crime involves violence, then, by all means, put the convicted felons in prison -- but, even then, don't give them 20 years and let them out in five (Good behavior is nice, but it's something they should have thought of before they committed the crime.)

For other offenses, prescribe community service -- or whatever -- in the statute itself. Don't leave it up to the courts.

I wrote this is a column as a "My View" for The Hour newspaper of Norwalk, Conn., on Oct. 29,1994. Stew Leonard Sr. made millions in his unique Norwalk dairy but was convicted of tax fraud for diverting $17 million in cash register receipts. He was sentenced to 52 months in prison, three years probation, and ordered to pay $13 million in back taxes, a $650,000 fine and $97,000 to cover the cost of his incarceration. I now write my views on a wide variety of topics on HubPages. To view my HubPages profile Click Here

'Stew Leonard: My Story' by Stew Leonard with Scotty Reiss

ADDENDUM: I finally got around to reading Stew Leonard's book, published by Colle & Co. in 2009, thanks to my local library in Valley Stream, N.Y., and the library of the Fashion Institute of Technology in New York City. I heartily recommend the book. I decided to find and read it after visiting the newest Stew Leonard's store in Farmingdale, L.I., N.Y., with some friends. I was privileged to have dined with Stew Sr. and several Norwalk, Connecticut, officials (including my late friend and former Norwalk mayor and 4th District congressman Donald J. Irwin) at Little Anthony's, a onetime local restaurant up the road from Stew's original ("dairy," as Stew insisted, not "supermarket.") The Norwalk store had only been in business a year at that time and as we drove to Little Anthony's Stew told us, "I can't believe how much money I'm making."

Stew Leonard Jr. at His Dairy Farm in Ellington, Connecticut

My Friends And I Visit Stew Leonard's Farmingdale Location a Couple of Days Before Its Opening

Photo of my friends Tom and Vinny taken before the opening of the newest Stew Leonard's store in Farmingdale, L.I., N.Y. We returned after the opening a few weeks late to explore the new store.
Photo of my friends Tom and Vinny taken before the opening of the newest Stew Leonard's store in Farmingdale, L.I., N.Y. We returned after the opening a few weeks late to explore the new store. | Source

More by this Author


Comments 5 comments

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade 8 years ago from Sydney

We have foolish laws and weak Judges.

Someone hurts a dog and we let them out with a slap on the wrist after three years.

Some one hurts a child and the Dept of of looking after "DOGS" just slaps their wrist.


William F. Torpey profile image

William F. Torpey 8 years ago from South Valley Stream, N.Y. Author

We also have foolish and weak legislators. Thanks for your comment MrMarrmalde.


Kenny Wordsmith profile image

Kenny Wordsmith 8 years ago from Chennai

I like the 'social service' concept of punishment for such crimes.

Instead of being locked up, I mean.


compu-smart profile image

compu-smart 8 years ago from London UK

I agree, Prison does has it's place for violent and persistent offenders. That being said, prison does not rehabilitate the majority of offenders.

I think Community service would have been appropriate for his crime as well as a fine. I also would like to see the jury having a role in sentencing criminals.


William F. Torpey profile image

William F. Torpey 8 years ago from South Valley Stream, N.Y. Author

Thanks for your comments, Kenny and compu-smart. We have some 2,000,000 people in our prisons today. Most prisons are more like pens for cattle, and the inmates contribute little to our society. Smarter sentencing and an offer of help where it can produce results would make much greater sense.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working