Is Voluntary Intoxication A Valid Defense In A Criminal Case?
Responsibility For One's Actions
Can voluntary intoxication be a valid defense in a criminal case? The answer may seem obvious that voluntary intoxication is not a valid defense in a criminal case but you may wonder why. When a person voluntarily takes drugs or drinks alcohol, they are doing so of their own free will.
A Willful Act
For this reason, that person is responsible for their own actions even if they cannot remember the crime they have committed while being voluntarily intoxicated. Such as, someone cannot voluntarily ingest alcohol and then assault an officer.
That person cannot claim that their actions should be excused because they were intoxicated. Their intoxication is an act they committed willingly and, therefore, they will have to answer for their crime.
The Influence of Involuntary Intoxication
However, it is a different case when someone is under the influence of involuntary intoxication. Involuntary intoxication occurs when a person has been given a drug unknowingly.
If this person commits a crime then their actions may not be held against them. Normally the person would not have committed the crime if they were not intoxicated against their will.
Of course, there are many factors to consider in such a situation, like the drug that was used and the type of crime that was committed.
More by this Author
A classic fairy tale takes on a whole new perspective in Anne Sexton’s poem Cinderella. Sexton’s perspective on the acclaimed childhood story is fairly different than what popular culture and the media wishes to...
Today the topic of globalization is discussed within levels of government, politics, and the world’s working class. While there are some benefits to globalization, the negative effects of the process has many around...
Twelve Angry Men (1957) showed several example of conflicts within the film. I will examine how each conflict was managed, which conflicts were resolved and how, along with the kinds of effects each of these conflicts...