Liberals Eating Their Own

Welfare Recipient and $1 million lottery winner Amanda Clayton.
Welfare Recipient and $1 million lottery winner Amanda Clayton. | Source

Poor Alexandra Pelosi, all she wanted to do was be fair to both sides. Instead she sent social Liberals looking for the censor button over her New York welfare office video. Both “The Atlantic and Newsmax” picked up on the story. Most noteworthy is how Ta-Nehisi Coates writes about Miss Pelosi. Instead of tackling the subject of Pelosi’s video, he deflects the entire argument as another high and mighty white person degrading poor black people.

“Pelosi thinks she's surprising by her willingness to unleash her quick wit against poor black people. But there is nothing noteworthy about offending "both sides," a feat that can be managed simply by relieving yourself on a crowded street. Moreover, very few black people who've spent time in the white world will be shocked to learn that liberals are just as capable as conservatives as regarding them as objects to be invoked at their leisure.” (Coates)


Really? So I suppose the man in the video who claims to not have worked in the past half-decade is off limits of criticism because he is black? However, I find it interesting how quickly and appropriately American citizens cried foul when they learned of 24 year old lottery winner Amanda Clayton from Michigan was still collecting government assistance. She was derided in a most deserved fashion for her unacceptable excuses and blind fiscal irresponsibility. Is there a double standard here?

There is a proverbial lowering of the bar that mystifies conservatives. The true racism is Liberal on poor; ergo if you are poor then you are incapable of providing for yourself or a family, nor can you ever rise up from your socioeconomic condition by your own will. But do not fear, poor people, Liberal’s want you to know that they will take care of you, give you just enough money to live a miserable, below poverty line existence, up until the day you die. Add addendum: you never have to go get a job.

It is tediously necessary to point out what one cannot point out if you are a liberal; first, never tackle the subject of welfare addiction. Second, never admit welfare is keeping down the masses, especially those whom it was designed to help. Above all else, make sure the narrative always remains “the white conservatives hate poor people.”

Now, to be extremely fair to Alexandra Pelosi, I congratulate her and applaud her “ownership” of her party. Please view the video of her with Bill Maher. Maher first showed Alexandra’s video depicting poor southern rednecks who rather vote for freedom, God and the Republican ticket, but not for handouts. Bill Maher had no (obviously) compunction of taking easy cheap shots. However, when Alexandra turned the tables to bring up her video of poor blacks in the welfare line in New York, Maher appeared physically uncomfortable and moved quickly past the subject.

You need to watch the video twice, mostly to hear Bill Maher make excuses for why the toothless poor Republicans in Mississippi are funny, but for the New Yorkers waiting in line for welfare, it is a sad legacy. Honestly, there are too many double standards to deconstruct during this interview. Another interesting thing Maher said was about Joe the door man, “the doorman says why won’t they get a job, well because most doormen are white. They don’t usually hire black door men.” I cannot even imagine the backlash had a Republican pundit said that on television. Furthermore Maher continues the double standard stating the poor white people in Mississippi have a chip on their shoulder as a reason for staying in poverty. So what exactly does he insinuate then about the Black welfare recipient who wants a career and not a job? Taking his diatribe a step further, how does he know there are no black doormen in New York?

In the video, one young man lets Alexandra know he is in line to get “some Obama bucks.” When she asked this same young man if he really wants to work or get a free check…you guessed it, he opted for the free check. Oh yeah, I didn’t want to forget about the other young man who has five children with four different mothers. Do the math, one young black man with five kids by four different mothers, and he is collecting welfare money. Which one of his four families is he supporting, if any? These poor black Americans are off limits, do not criticize them and do not attempt to stand between them and or help them with true financial freedom because if you do, you are a selfish racist. Again, I must acknowledge gratitude to Alexandra for saying the entitlement culture her side has promulgated is out of control and it is causing them to lose part of their base. Honesty of that magnitude on a show like Bill Maher’s is genuine and rare.

I need to make something very clear to those of you siding with the state of perpetual entitlement programs; I bring this episode up as a prime example of issue dodging, excuse making, back biting and intellectual dishonesty. It is too bad Alexandra didn’t take her street interview a step further and ask what is it going to take to incentivize young men in welfare lines to WANT a job? Most average American’s start out with a handful of jobs with lousy pay, terrible benefits and are not very rewarding. Nevertheless every job held can be treated as a stepping stone to a better one. Who in this entire world is handed a career without having to put in some kind of hard work? Even Kings have to study hard and apply trade specific knowledge.

Atlas Shrugged
Atlas Shrugged | Source

"It's true that there's no such thing as free will. We can't help what we are or what we do. It's not our fault. Nobody's to blame for anything. It's all in your background ... and your glands. If you're good, that's no achievement of yours -- you were lucky in your glands. If you're rotten, nobody should punish you -- you were unlucky, that's all." - AYN RAND, The Fountainhead

More by this Author


Comments 9 comments

ExLeftist profile image

ExLeftist 4 years ago

Good article, Jason. I checked out HubPages tonight determined to read something of interest and I found your peace. No disagreement. I don't watch Politically Incorrect so I'd not gotten to watch Pelosi either. Thanks for the video.


Jason R. Manning profile image

Jason R. Manning 4 years ago from Sacramento, California Author

Hi ExLeftitst, thank you for taking the time to read and leave me a comment. I have been following the critique of both sides for a few years, I cannot remember a time when a Liberal actually said entitlements are making matters worse, not better. Obviously Alexandra fell much further from the tree than Mama Pelosi would like. Thanks.


SubRon7 profile image

SubRon7 4 years ago from eastern North Dakota

OMG, Jason R Manning, excellent hub, although a couple things in the second video kind of made my jaws grind...anyway, thanks for a huge look at our world, and I'm glad it came out that this is Nancy's daughter, cause I immediately wondered.


KB 4 years ago

Nice article Jason. WOW, what a refreshing contrast Alexandria Pelosi is from her former Speaker of the House Mother. I applaud her for acknowledging her party’s liberal dysfunction. Knowing that this social entitlement mentality has evolved into multi generations, it will certainly contribute to the collapse of our economic system if left unchecked. What I can’t fathom is why haven’t our elected officials, from both parties done something more to change the course of this destructive behavior? I can’t help but believe that the root cause leans more towards political self-preservation then doing what’s right by the people for the people, because it’s common sense. I propose a performance based Welfare/Unemployment system.


Jason R. Manning profile image

Jason R. Manning 4 years ago from Sacramento, California Author

Hi SubRon, it feels good to be back. Of course it is always do to stating the obvious. Yes, I watched the video a handful of times just to make sure I wasn’t missing something or over reacting. Yes, the dude who hasn’t worked in half a decade made me crazy, his attitude, his ability to find work and his lame excuses were beyond what is normal (I hope). Thank you for the comments. Glad you came back.

Hi KB, thank you for the kind compliments. Yes, I must admit I couldn’t believe this is a Pelosi from the same tree of California. She made sense, she wasn’t screaming, she sounded logical, thoughtful and moderate. As for your statement regarding politicians doing what politicians do best…CYA, yep, I agree 100%. I would also push the performance plan for benefits. There needs to be incrementality of one does this in exchange for that, which also negates the effects of dependency. I cannot get over how the guy with 5 children by 4 different moms can sit there and not be ashamed. If you cannot support one family, for Christ sake, don’t go spreading your seed to anyone else. We are upside down; the next generations are locked into Daddy Government for support, but who is going to support Daddy Government with income? This isn’t difficult to figure out…those who can help themselves are robbing the truly needy and incapable. Thanks again, I know this conversation is going to explode as I hope it does.


randslam profile image

randslam 4 years ago from Kelowna, British Columbia

I think you open a very important dialogue that should lead to a more centrist position...Alexandra is showing that both sides are wrong in the end.

Programs for career development...not handouts, or just temporary "jobs", need to be created.

The generational mindset of food stamps and welfare checks should be broached and solved...if one looks at the faces of the New Yorkers there isn't a great deal of pride in accomplishment...only a cultural habit of taking from guv'ment what guv'ment will give.

On the other side, being a poor Republican that will take food stamps, but won't get your teeth fixed...well, definition of red neck?

It is education...and it seems Alexandra has fallen into the mold of a centrist...it's a good place to be, but it's also a position that has been abandoned in the last ten years because of polarizing media and political power players.

Statements like, "you're either with us or against us," don't help--they polarize. Pelosi, the daughter, has opened a can of worms...let's put the worms to work and start growing some areas of agreement where people are only on welfare for so long while acquiring education, a career...or simply start opening some doors for people to feel like they're doing something with their lives instead of chasing "booty" and creating children without a supportive father.


Jason R. Manning profile image

Jason R. Manning 4 years ago from Sacramento, California Author

Randslam, you make some very thoughtful points and ones that require follow up from all parties. I didn’t want to start what would be another hub, yet it is easy to broaden this subject into “why do the top two parties do little about nothing?” The obvious point another made is about keeping power. If Government actually started fixing problems, they realize they would put themselves out of work down the road, and like the mother of all entitlement programs, top Government positions are the cushiest of all.

I am much obliged by your centrist comments, great comment about using the “worms,” I agree. Cheers.


Skarlet profile image

Skarlet 4 years ago from California

Excellent information


Jason R. Manning profile image

Jason R. Manning 4 years ago from Sacramento, California Author

Hi Skarlet, thanks for stopping by to read and leave a comment, hope to see more of you around. Cheers

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working