Obama Apology Wrong, says Gingrich

Gingrich

Understanding?
Understanding? | Source

Afghanistan

At the biggest United States military base in Afghanistan, US soldiers burned copies of the Koran.

This action enraged the Afghan people, they demonstrated and during these demonstrations two American soldiers were killed.

President Obama sent an apology, on behalf of the American people, to the President of Afghanistan.

Newt Gingrich, a Republican nominee for President, said that President Obama was wrong to apologize.

President

Sets an Example
Sets an Example | Source

Actions

These soldiers who burnt the Korans were in the employ of the United States government at the time of their wrong doing. President Obama, is the chief of the US armed forces, therefore the men were working for him. Of course he was to apologize but he should do more. He should be seen to remove the officer in charge of these men from Afghanistan. Without any action, any apology is only seen as meaningless words.

American soldiers have lost their lives trying to convince Afghans that the United States has their interests at heart. Their interests would mean that they have respect for their religion and their feelings. An act of burning copies of the Koran, which the Afghans consider sacred, is not an action that supports what the majority of the American soldiers are trying to convey. In fact it is an action in direct opposition of what the majority of servicemen are trying to convey and is an actual insult to the Afghan people.

Of course the US president should apologize but he should also be seen to be taking action against the perpetrators. I daresay that the military have already found out what the truth behind the action was and possibly already “slapped the wrist” of the person responsible. However because of pride, would not want to air their dirty washing in public. Usually I would agree with these sentiments but in this instance, when an act has been perpetrated on or against the Afghan public, then a public act of punishment should be seen to have been taken. Even if it is only the removal of the guilty person from the country, after all wouldn’t that also be in the soldiers own security interests?

Gingrich

If this was a bank employee that did a rash act, possibly causing the stock holders to lose money, would you say the CEO need not apologize and that no action should be taken against the bank employee?

What you are saying is that the dollar, to some already rich, is far more important than the lives and beliefs of people.

You would have that the example to young Americans, set by the President of the United States, is one of not having to apologize for a wrong doing. So if a student burnt a US Flag, in front of the White House, there is no need even for an apology.

Mr. Gingrich, you are running for President of the United States of America, a position that answers to all the citizens of the United States, not just those members of your country club that have no members of their families in the armed forces.

The rest of America has family members in the armed forces putting their life on the line against the war on terror. Acts like this burning of the Koran, give groups like Al Qaida huge recruitment boosts, prolonging the war and increasing the numbers of US military lives lost. If an apology is a help in reducing these recruitments, what is the harm?

The pride of you and your country club members is not more important than the lives of brave US soldiers. Until you can learn that: you should not even consider running in a race for which you clearly have no respect for the prize.

It was not Obama’s apology that caused the loss of these two American lives. It was the burning of the Korans that instigated a demonstration by innocent Afghans which terrorist were able to infiltrate and it was them that took the lives of the soldiers.

US soldiers cannot win a war on terror alone. US politicians and diplomats need to have policies that act to curb recruitment of more terrorists, not actions that encourage them.

More by this Author


Comments 9 comments

Credence2 profile image

Credence2 4 years ago from Florida (Space Coast)

Rafken, Somebody needs to newtralize Newt and that big mouth of his. The mark of a leader is one that will make necessary sacrifices to save lives. Our fighting people as you so well pointed out are in harms way. Doing something as insenstive as burning the Koran plays into the propoganda war of our adversary, giving them the higher ground to recruit more angry young men. How does that help our cause? I probably would have fired the commanding officer over that unfortunate action. The mark of great leader is to know when one can afford to humble oneself without caving in to terrorist blackmail, and yes, there is a difference. Great Article, Cred2


Eyeson 4 years ago

I give...Brenda Durham...5 stars and up and awesome.


rafken profile image

rafken 4 years ago from The worlds my oyster Author

ib - There are 2 things that you seem to easily and conveniently forget. First the number of terrorist acts that the US supports. Many rebellions in countries are backed by the US, these rebellions start with terrorists. Secondly, when Christianity was the same age as Islam is today, it was in the midst of the inquisitions. Should all Christians be judged for being responsible for the inquisitors actions?


ib radmasters profile image

ib radmasters 4 years ago from Southern California

Sorry but how can you equate burning the Koran with killing two soldiers. YOur hub rambled through words with no real direction.

The important issue here is that two American soldiers are dead. No Afghans died. Anything else is irrelevant.

Do you think that Christians would kill someone that burned their bibles? I don't think so.

It is time to focus on the deadly actions of terrorists and those that support terrorists. When a book even a religious book is worth more than a human life than that religion is the problem.


maxoxam41 profile image

maxoxam41 4 years ago from USA

They torture, pee, insult...What else? They are real animals! Where are their hierarchic superiors when such behavior occur? Obama did what was for a man of his stature. Gingrich is an amateur hustling for supporters! Is it what the American people identify with?


GoGreenTips profile image

GoGreenTips 4 years ago from Indianapolis

Nice articles, good points, But, Really, all said and done we have no business being in Afghanistan. It has nothing to do with freedom, fighting terrorists, it has to do with securing natural resources, oil and access to land that it strategically located.

All of this could have been avoided if we were spending our tax dollars taking care of Americans....


rafken profile image

rafken 4 years ago from The worlds my oyster Author

Brenda - So you think 2 wrongs make a right. Well that attitude would surely help America's image abroad. Why don't you tell Gingrich, maybe that philosophy will get him elected.


Brenda Durham 4 years ago

Well. I wonder if those soldiers were remembering, perhaps, the time a couple years ago when U.S. soldiers were commanded to burn Bibles? In which case, why would anyone even try to stop them from burning the Koran if they want to? Gingrich is right, Obama shouldn't apologize, at least not for the soldiers' actions! But yes Obama should take the blame for BOTH incidents! Meaning he should apologize personally for himself, PLUS apologize to America's military personnel. He IS the "Commander-in-Chief", and should be ashamed of ALL his "apology tours" and "apologies" where he used American citizens and now American soldiers as scapegoats for his own denunciation of America's foundation and Constitution.

Heck, what am I saying?---Obama should've done America including our soldiers a favor long ago and RESIGNED.


pagesvoice profile image

pagesvoice 4 years ago from New York/Pennsylvania border

I really enjoyed your article and you raise many legitimate points. Somewhere post 1970s we seem to have lost a moral compass in regard to politics. Saying politics is a nasty business is certainly an understatement. I was always taught that if you did something wrong then apologize. Why is it so hard for those like Gingrich to understand such a simple concept?

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working