Population of India: Women’s Empowerment is the Best Contraceptive

Declining Rate of Population Growth in India
Declining Rate of Population Growth in India

Will the World be Different and Better, if Run by Women?

See results without voting

Is Population a Problem?

Yes; if your thinking is shaped by the enlightened philosophy of English cleric Mr Thomas Robert Malthus prophesied 2 centuries ago. If you see people merely as food eating morons their increasing number is clearly a burden. In his 1798 piece Essay on the Principle of Population Malthus observed, “…in nature plants and animals produce far more offspring than can survive, and that Man too is capable of overproducing if left unchecked. Malthus concluded that unless family size was regulated, man's misery of famine would become globally epidemic and eventually consume Man.

Whenever philosophers and scientists extrapolate observations from "plants or animals" to the human world deficiencies are in-built into the logic. Because humans are far too superior compared with plants or animals in every aspect -- whether we like it or not!

If Malthus' ideas survived and found prominence, a large part of the credit goes to the elite class of Western societies which found a rationale for their supposed supremacy over ordinary and poor people. Most of the class and race bias in the Western world most definitely originated from his philosophical ideas.

Malthus was concerned about the decline of living conditions in the 19th century England and argued that growing population is a burden on nature’s resources. He also noted that the lower classes were bearing more children; therefore, he suggested that poor families should only produce as many children as they can support. Why he did not think of helping poor become rich is not known; probably he had no interest in uplifting the poor despite being a cleric.

Given his observations and the socioeconomic conditions at that time, his conclusions were certainly logical. What is wrong is to apply them in today’s world by ignoring the premises on which he said what he said. In fact, Malthus's ill founded ideas shaped much of the aid politics during the mid 20th century.

China’s One Child Policy

Yet the most faithful disciple of Malthus and his philosophy turned out to be the Communist China, whose One Child Policy is often touted as a brilliant example of Malthus’ ideology in action and how any country should check its burgeoning population quickly. In fact, Chinese turned out to be more enthusiastic than Malthus – they implemented their One Child policy across board to all families, not just in the poor class as Malthus initially suggested!

However, what is left unsaid is the havoc the One Child policy caused in the basic structure of the Chinese society and the long term social problems it created for China and its neighbors. Rather than a discourse here, a link to The Dark Side of China’s One Child Policy should suffice. In direct contrast to the State control of people’s reproductive behavior there is a bright example of Kerala here in India. In fact, Kerala has demonstrated how people development can give more humane and more sustainable population control without denying basic reproductive rights to the people. Kerala’s model has been highly applauded and both India and China have a lot to learn from Kerala.

"Women do two-thirds of all the work in the world. They produce over 50 % of the food, but earn less than 1 % of the income and own less than 10 % of the property. It will be an enormous challenge to overcome this depth of inequality."

- Joanna Maycock, President, CONCORD, An European NGO

Need to Learn from the ICPD, Cairo 1994

In the current world order, not Mr Malthus, but the International Conference on Population and Development (ICPD) of 1994 held in Cairo and its Program of Action (PoA) should guide the policies of population dynamics. The Conference marked a watershed in the understanding of population and development issues. What appears to be “population problem” is nothing but an indication and a symptom of lack of “people development.” It is in direct opposition to the scare mongering of “population explosion” type rhetoric and endorses the idea of rights based approaches in health through the adoption of the concept of “reproductive rights.” The ICPD Program of Action also highlighted the need for male responsibility along with the empowerment of women and mentioned sexual health.

As the Conference highlighted and further corroborated by many studies, women empowerment has a direct bearing on their reproductive behavior and a controlling effect on fertility. A woman’s ability to control her reproductive activities and fertility are very much affected by her status, self-image, and the sense of empowerment. The more empowered she feels, the greater is the freedom and options available to her in terms of education, time of marriage, contraceptives she would like to use, when to bear children, and how to participate in social and work related activities.

I am not sure why Mr Malthus could not think of empowering women at that time. Probably gender equality and its positive consequences were unknown to the primitive English society he lived in.

Best Investment – Girls’ Education

In a recent study of 65 countries including India, the World Bank also concluded that for development there is no investment more effective than educating girls. This one action alone solves several problems in one go; for instance,

  • Reduction in Women’s Fertility Rate: Educated women are more likely to use family planning methods, delay marriage and child-bearing compared with women with no or little education. There are studies to suggest that one year of female schooling, particularly secondary school, reduce fertility by 10 percent.
  • Reduction in Infant and Child Mortality Rates: Educated women are more aware of healthcare, children’s immunization and their nutritional requirement, and adopt improved sanitation practices. Hence, their kids have higher survival rates and tend to be better nourished and healthier.
  • Reduced Maternal Mortality Rate: Due to their better knowledge, educated women are better equipped to avoid unwanted pregnancies and have better planned and well spaced pregnancies and take care of pre- and post-natal issues. It has been estimated that an additional year in school for 1000 women prevents two maternal deaths.
  • Protection against HIV/AIDS Infections: Girls’ education is a powerful tool for reducing their vulnerability. Education provides access to information that enables them to stay protected.
  • Education Enables Women to earn More: Education opens the door for jobs, income, and opportunities. They become a contributing part of the society.
  • Educated Mother Means Educated Kids: Education of mothers is a significant variable affecting children’s educational opportunities. Thus, an educated mother pulls her children from the quagmire of ignorance and poverty.

The problem with the rigid patriarchal society like India is that women have been traditionally confined to home and their role has been limited to mere breeding and shouldering responsibility of all domestic work. Even now in many pockets of rural society the world beyond home boundary is an alien land for them. Male dominance is the sole reason for domestic violence in Indian society. Women get least priority in everything in the families, including education. So, they remain trapped in the self sustaining cycle of exploitation and misery. Therefore, it is also vital to work with men and bring change in their patriarchal mindset.

MASVAW Activists in Action
MASVAW Activists in Action | Source
Activists exchanging Ideas
Activists exchanging Ideas

Involving Men for Women Empowerment

Involving men in the process of gender equality and women empowerment is equally important because that will automatically serve the purpose of population stabilization. When men change, the societal perception and definition of female gender will also change – that in turn will be good for women’s own sense of self worth.

Fortunately such an effort has emerged during last ten years, in the form of a network called Men’s Action for Stopping Violence Against Women (MASVAW). While typically groups working on women empowerment focus on women – that is quite logical – but MASVAW approaches it from the other side, men. Yes, it puts men in the center to change their gender definition and redefines masculinity to include the concept of “share and care.” The changed men then become role models for other men to emulate. Being focused on “men” MASVAW also provides a supportive platform where men can discuss their intimate issues freely and help each other to concretize the change in them.

“MASVAW initiative was first of its kind in Asia which helped propagate such movements in many other countries. It also played an important role when the “Men Engage Global Alliance” was set up in 2004 at the international level.” – Satish Kumar Singh, MASVAW Convener

If all subtle or gross forms of violence against women (VAW) are eliminated, an important mile stone is already achieved on the way to women empowerment. A violence-free environment offers them “normal” atmosphere to grow, discover self-worth, and participate in all types of decision making in the family including reproductive activities and fertility.

Perhaps the happiest individuals from MASVAW's work are the wives of MASVAW activists!! For instance, sample this:

“Now (after joining MASVAW) my husband does not beat me. In fact, now he even counsels me why I should not beat kids. He also encourages me to go out and work. I like the fact that he trusts and respects me.” – Wife of a MASVAW activist

Men are certainly part of the problem; they must share their responsibility in solving it too!

Consequences of Population Growth

Population Growth and Women Empowerment

It is amply clear to population experts at least, that the current population growth is momentum driven – too many young people in the reproductive age group – and not because family sizes are increasing. The remedies to check the population momentum are societal – Not clinical. It can be checked by two simple steps: delay the woman’s age at first birth (by discouraging early or child marriages and delaying first pregnancy) and then spacing further births. Child marriages – and hence early pregnancies – are the biggest source of population rise in India. According to UNICEF, 15 percent of girls in rural areas across the country are married before they are even 13; and 52 percent of girls have their first pregnancy between 15 and 19. So, the most effective way to solve the population problem is to kill the population momentum by preventing early pregnancies.

Women empowerment is the ideal way to kill the momentum of population growth. When women have control on their bodies and reproductive health and have the freedom to make decisions and choices a lot of imposed or unwanted pregnancies will be automatically eliminated.

Summary

Indian government will do well to heed the experts and don’t just allocate funds for clinical sterilization of women that have been traditionally target driven. The whole focus is loaded against women as if they are solely responsible for pregnancies and child births – and men have no responsibilities. Sensitizing men through a network such as MASVAW for the ultimate goal of women empowerment will automatically put the population issue in perspective.

So, the bottom line is: There is no other contraceptive as effective as women empowerment in the long run; and population is just one of the symptoms of lack of women empowerment, along with poverty. That’s all!

More by this Author


Comments 11 comments

Vegas Elias profile image

Vegas Elias 16 months ago from Mumbai

Womens' empowerment can only come with womens' education. The mindset of the Indian male has to change because he controls lot of decisions with regard to the education and freedom of female children. Girls should be allowed to remain unmarried and pursue their careers as long as they wish. Also the stigma behind girls remaining celibates for life has to go. Having an unmarried and mature daughter or sister at home is still not seen well by Indian society.

I have read three hubs of yours at a stretch and found all of them very informative and interesting. I am definitely rating this up as useful.


Goodpal profile image

Goodpal 20 months ago Author

Thanks Shary. For reading and sharing. Do share the results of your survey here.


shary 20 months ago

Women empowerment Survey : Career orientation of women

I am doing a survey on career orientation of employed women. If you are an employed woman, pls take the survey. Also pls forward this survey to your female friends who are working.

https://qtrial2015az1.az1.qualtrics.com/SE/

This survey is being done only for academic purpose and does not require your name or organization details. Kindly provide accurate information in the survey.

Thanks a lot,

Regards,

Santhi


Au fait profile image

Au fait 2 years ago from North Texas

What you say here is so true. I learned about this in my environmental science class several years ago, and it all makes sense.

Uneducated women see no way to be successful other than to marry and produce babies. Educated women not only contribute to a smaller population, but to a more successful less poverty stricken population because they have many more options and can rely more on themselves.

Education and skills are some of the best ways to fight poverty.


AbhijeetMohapatra profile image

AbhijeetMohapatra 2 years ago from Bhubaneswar, India

Bhaiya i love each piece of article u write. U write the articles so deep with facts and figures ppl would definitely love that.


Goodpal profile image

Goodpal 2 years ago Author

Thanks Abhijeet, for stopping by.

Gone is the stone age which lasted till the 20th century when women used to be seen merely in the role of child bearing and family care-taker and population phobic people failed to think beyond limiting their fertilities.

Landmark international conferences of the early 1990s including the ICPD have brought a paradigm change in the way the issues of population and poverty are viewed today. What came about was not some theoretical ideas but results based on decades of research and field experience of numerous organizations across the world.

Poor people are no longer seen as patients afflicted with the virus called "poverty." It is also not an income issue alone. It is now correctly viewed as symptoms associated with lack of proper development of societies. Likewise, population growth is basically a result of women's lack of control on their own bodies and wishes. Therefore, the correct remedy is "woman development" which means creating an environment where her basic rights as a human-being are respected and treated as par with men in all aspects.

It helps to quote what someone once said: "Women are just Men with a Womb." In fact, men can't sustain the human race on their own. Thus, it is plain stupidity on their part if they can't treat women as their equal.


AbhijeetMohapatra profile image

AbhijeetMohapatra 2 years ago from Bhubaneswar, India

Thanks for writing. Your articles always feels great.


visionandfocus profile image

visionandfocus 3 years ago from North York, Canada

Awesome hub! You've tackled an important topic brilliantly. It's startling to see how different methods adopted can have such strikingly different results. As you say, the world should look upon Kerala and take heed of their good sense and remarkable results. Education is the only way we can solve this issue, and while it is obvious that educating girls is a huge part of the equation, it is enlightening that men can be re-educated, as it were, to be more humane and take their part of the responsibility.

Thank you for a wonderful hub. Voted up and awesome and sharing.


maria thankachan 4 years ago

it is good but i dont got the information that i want


pramodgokhale profile image

pramodgokhale 4 years ago from Pune( India)

Wonderful hub, really inspiring.Empowerment a contraceptive

perfect answer,it is usually said that woman qualified or literate then next generation automatically becomes competent.High quality material you provided, strengthen our knowledge.

thank you


Chatkath profile image

Chatkath 4 years ago from California

Great Hub goodpal! What a well researched summary and informative read! Rated up, useful and interesting.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working