The Crux of the M F Hussain Controversy

Painting By M F Hussain

First Published for Delhilive.com on 3 March 1010

The point is not whether the paintings of M F Hussain are good or bad. The point is not even whether they are insulting, or derogatory or a misuse of artistic freedom. The only point that should concern us is, do the citizens of India have a right to live in the county without fear and intimidation? Do Indian citizens have the right to feel safe enough to be in their country of birth at age 95?

The drawings and paintings of Maqbool Fida Hussain are open to interpretation. I do not know enough about art to make any informed comment about his work; perhaps I am a philistine that his brush strokes do not evoke much of a reaction in me; negative or positive, the way that a beautiful landscape painted by an unknown would. As I am ignorant about art; so I suspect are most of the others who have taken up cudgels against his work.

Many of Hussain’s paintings have actually been without names, which have then been then been ascribed by others. So you could say that some if not all of his paintings have been misinterpreted. Again the point is that we are free to interpret them the way we perceive them. We are also free to condemn his work. But is it open to people to persecute a 95 year old man who has arguably put Indian art on the world map?

The right to freedom of expression is not absolute; agreed that it should be within the parameters of acceptable behaviour and that the creator of an art work is not wholly unaccountable to society at large. But, it is the job of art to question, to provoke, to incite debate, to initiate new thought; yes even to shock.

Is one disagrees with someone’s art; even someone’s trash, do they have the right to hound the creator of said art/trash to the point that he cannot live in the country of his birth? Does the rule of law have no place in a civil society? Should a backlash instill such fear that a person feels constrained to take up citizenship of another country?

Besides who will decide upon what is art and what is trash? The mob? And will that same mob decide what punishment is to be meted out for the art/trash? This reflects poorly on our democracy, our maturity as a thinking populace, also our law enforcement agencies. Home Minister P Chidambaram has extended a lukewarm welcome and has said that he will be ‘happy’ if the painter returns to India. But this is evidently not reassuring enough.

If M F Hussain will now spend his last days in a foreign country (albeit one with a completely abysmal record of according personal and other freedoms but that is another matter altogether) we must look within and examine our credentials as a democracy that claims to uphold the law, and claims to accord equal security to all its citizens; even if some of those citizens are decried as criminals by a substantial segment of society.

More by this Author


Comments 2 comments

adarsh 5 years ago

India is my country and hinduism my religion. And am pretty passionate about both. Hussain has no business to portray/ paint any of these in a derogatory way. He had a zillion other subjects to paint including his own religion (islam) in the nude. Why did he choose my country/ religion? A case of sedition would have been apt against him. But the sadly "pseudo secular" government let him off easy.


Reena Daruwalla profile image

Reena Daruwalla 5 years ago from INDIA Author

Please understand that M F Hussain did not choose 'your' country, he chose his own country and his own culture and its ethos. There were actually many who filed suits against this artist who was more steeped in Indian and yes Hindu culture than most self proclaimed upholders of morality who incidentally understood nothing about art. added to that his home and countless of his paintings were vandalized as well. It is a crying shame that he couldn't return to the country of this birth and had to die abroad simply because of intolerance and lack of understanding.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working