Us and Them

Hatfields and McCoys

I had a friend whose first husband was a McCoy. Of the original Hatfields and McCoys, two families who feuded during the latter part of the 1800s in Kentucky and West Virginia. The two families lived along the Tug Fork River in the southern Appalacians. It was a story of jealousy and alienation, with a Romeo and Juliet subplot (a McCoy Juliet and Hatfield Romeo). A dozen deaths resulted from long-held family hatred started between two patriarchs from the time of the Civil War through the end of the 19th Century.

According to information I researched, Asa Harmon McCoy was murdered after being discharged from the Union Army, followed by an incident over a disputed pig that resulted in the killing of Staton Hatfield by two McCoy brothers. Then, Roseanna McCoy had an affair with Johnse Hatfield, who was then arrested, followed by a rescue from his family; after which he abandoned the pregnant Roseanna anyway.

Hatfield clan 1897

After that, scores of bullet-riddled bodies from one side then the other ensued for years, finally resulting in a conflict between the Governors of West Virginia and Kentucky, who called up their State militias to restore order.

Complete pandemonium. Both sides justified; both families wronged and both justifiably angry with the other. On the one hand, it's hard to imagine how something could escalate to such a great extent, based upon stored-up animosities between two families of people.

On the other ...

War and Peace

Divisions have defined us. Wars have shaped countries and determined the shape and nature of our history. It's hard to imagine an analysis of human history without a discussion of wars. In many ways, our history is the telling of wars between one conflict and the next. In between - the periods of peace, unity and humanity - are uneventful, and thus disappear from much of our scholastics.

I remember reading a quote years ago, when I was on a trip through Europe, that in Italy under the Borgias they had warfare, terror, murder and bloodshed, but they produced Michelangelo, Leonardo da Vinci and the Renaissance. In Switzerland, they had brotherly love, 500 years of democracy and peace and produced the cuckoo clock!

Humanity appears to have an addiction to conflict, and an aversion to true peace. By true peace, I mean not just a lack of an active war, or a period where there is no violence, in the midst of tumult. I mean closeness, collaboration, positive regard for others.

Yeah yeah yeah, you say. Commie.

But what's most notable to me is when two camps form sides. "Us" versus "Them". Where "we" are right and "they" are wrong. It still continues to happen today, in our generation. It's not just a story of warring between nations, as in the World Wars, but even in 1994 in Rwanda between two tribes of people, who have lived together as neighbors for hundreds of hears. The Hutus and Tutsis had an undercurrent of distrust for each other, but when a Hutu President was assassinated, Hutus took to the streets with thousands of machetes and for over 90 days slaughtered nearly a million Tutsi men, women and children in the streets, in their homes, in their churches - everywhere. They believed it was their duty to slaughter the "cockroaches."

Immaculee Ilibagiza, a Rwandan Tutsi, was hidden in a tiny bathroom along with seven other women for the entire period, while the slaughter was occurring outside the window. She tells of it in a harrowing, but amazing book, titled Left to Tell, which I highly recommend. One of the most significant pieces of literature I have ever read:

Left to Tell

Political Polka

What drives humans to be so polarized on so many issues? When you step back from conflicts, it almost becomes humorous to watch the catty, childish games that each side plays against the other. In the US, there's the perpetual and seemingly growing conflict between "liberal" vs. "conservative", where neither is truly either. Just a bunch of talking heads looking for an audience to buy into their talk shows, buy their books or catapult more morons into fame.

But why do so many buy into the hype? Have we so lost our individuality so that we can't discriminate between sides? Can't it be how we feel personally, without just parroting dogma we've heard from someone else? Where is our personal ability to independently discern what is real to us? Are we really either over "here" or over "there"? I ask because most people I know and talk with are pretty darned similar in their thinking. It's comical to realize now that political candidates who, during the election season, are portrayed as being polar opposite as Marilyn Manson and John Tesh, and then afterward are really much more alike than different in their approaches. This is one of the beautiful things about our system of governance - we don't have to behead the loser!

The truth is force creates counterforce. I see it in my kids every day. They, like far too many "mature" adults, seem oblivious to the fact that when you insult someone, they insult you back. I can't blame them - they see the same immature behavior modeled for them by their leaders, by their peers, and too often, by families. Working together isn't an idealistic vision. It is the only way forward. Period. Fighting merely reinforces further fighting, and further resistance.

9-1-1

Which brings me to today - eight years following the attack on the Twin Towers in New York City. There are no words to express the dismay, shock and anger at such an audacious act. So misguided and unbelievable we almost didn't know how to respond when it happened. And we're not entirely sure how to respond even today.

We didn't have a country to blame, though we tried. We didn't have a specific ethnic culture to blame, though we tried. We don't have a specific religion to blame, though we also tried.

If we're "us", who is "them"? A radical leader and a radical group that we almost can't fathom; they're like a vapor - you can't find them in any particular or specific place. You can't decimate them because they seem to multiply with more fighting. It's very unsatisfying for all of us - myself included. I want satisfaction. I want retribution. And there's a part of me that wonders whether that's an itch that can never be scratched.

It's a deeper wound from which we - all of humanity - suffer. A wound amplified by ego, divisiveness and anger.

September 11, 2001 will resonate forever with each of us. I only hope we find a way - collectively - to bring us all together.

"Between stimulus and response there is a space. In that space is our power to choose our response. In our response lies our growth and our freedom."

- Viktor E. Frankl, Author of Man's Search for Meaning, Psychiatrist and Holocaust Survivor

More by this Author

  • The Lucky Life of Dick Van Dyke
    12

    In his memoir, "My Lucky Life In and Out of Show Business", talented actor/comedian Dick Van Dyke revisits his life in show business with wit, circumspection and wisdom, After reading his memoir, I feel...

  • "Think" Smarts vs. "Feel" Smarts
    11

    Our culture seems to value thinking intelligence far above feeling intelligence - what is referred to as emotional intelligence. They are clearly not the same, as a person can develop one without the other. This...

  • Push Me Pull You
    13

    Using public transportation as an example, a look at how people tend to get stuck in the problem - like the Push Me Pull You from Dr. Dolittle - instead of being focused on collaborative outcomes. Once we let go of...


Comments 11 comments

Jackwms profile image

Jackwms 7 years ago

Greg, this is absolutely brilliant.It is questioning, while being being open to questioning; insightful, while being open to views of others; and critical, while welcoming critical comment.

Wonderful hub


Gerg profile image

Gerg 7 years ago from California Author

Thank you, Dad. It is a challenging subject to tackle!


pgrundy 7 years ago

This is perfectly said. We seem to be a people obsessed with and deeply fearful of 'the other'. I think it's the dark side of the obsession with self and individuality--if the self and the ego is where it's at, then the other has to be bad, right? And something, somebody HAS to be the other.

I also think so many people are starting to feel kind of emotionally hung over, especially here in the U.S. So much hate, acrimony, and polarity and it's unrelenting.

I know I can't take a whole lot of it. Thanks for your thoughts on it. Excellent as always.


Gerg profile image

Gerg 7 years ago from California Author

Emotionally hung over - I like that! I've been spending a lot of attention on focusing on the present and letting the past and future take care of themselves. My ego struggles against this, but I think it's a worthwhile effort.

Thanks again for your kind comments, Pam!


Gerg profile image

Gerg 6 years ago from California Author

Note on September 11, 2010: This is my post from last year, the eighth anniversary of 9-11. It seems appropriate to draw attention again to this entry.

G


phdast7 profile image

phdast7 4 years ago from Atlanta, Georgia

Gerg - You have written an excellent and important clarion call to all of us, a plea for restraint, morality, decency, understanding, community, and rational, as opposed to emotional and fear driven, behavior.

We must resist divisions and hatred and the us versus them mentality. Those are not solutions; they only increase the likelihood of increased conflict, cruelty, and loss.

What a marvelous quote by Frankl. I use Man's Search for Meaning in my Holocaust course. Do we read all the same books? :)

"Between stimulus and response there is a space. In that space is our power to choose our response. In our response lies our growth and our freedom."

Such a salient and trenchant observation. Many people believe there is no space between the two, that we cannot "stop" ourselves, that conflict is our permanent condition.

But Frankl was right and they are wrong, and as moral beings and to preserve a future for our children, we must learn to behave rationally and humanely. Excellent essay. Sharing with followers.


Gerg profile image

Gerg 4 years ago from California Author

Amen, phdast! And thank you for your words of encouragement. This is also one of my favorite hubs of my own!

Best,

G


suzettenaples profile image

suzettenaples 4 years ago from Taos, NM

Wonderful article. I can't agree with your more. Old Chinese proverb: He who seeks revenge digs two graves. We in the U.S. have a very contentious society and all we are doing is destroying ourselves. I don't know what the answer is. Those that want peace are believed to be weak. Those that act peaceful are believed to be weak. As you can see, those that advocated peaceful answers to conflict, MLK, Ghandi etc. were violently assassinated. So what is the answer? I don't know.


Gerg profile image

Gerg 4 years ago from California Author

We're on the same page, suzettenaples. You're right. Those who seek peace are the truly strong and sensible, because too many people, in my view, are addicted to extremes. Having an opinion - even one un-researched and borrowed from an extremist - evidently makes many people feel powerful, when in reality it is the opposite.

I wish more people were comfortable in the reality of the middle. Life isn't absolutes. We're supposed to exercise discretion and intellectual discernment. Not as sexy, but real.

I appreciate your support.

G


sen.sush23 profile image

sen.sush23 4 years ago from Kolkata, India

Gerg, this is a brilliant piece of writing. You have raised a question and with restraint, stopped yourself from suggesting any cliche solution. Will be waiting for more such Hubs from you. Voting up and sharing.


Gerg profile image

Gerg 4 years ago from California Author

Restraint - good word. And you're right. It is hard not to want to sum up with some contrived "side" to make us feel stronger and smarter. Very astute observation, sen.sush23. Thank you for your encouragement and support!

Greg

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working