What is the Difference Between the United States of America and the united States of America? [149*7]
A SIMPLE QUESTION
I PUT A QUESTION, which Hubpages probably wished was a forum, out a little while ago that asked - "Do Conservatives believe in a United States or a united States of America?"
One part of the comment thread was a series of back-and-forths between Mitch Allen and myself which I post here. I do so because I think it highlights, with a very bright line yet in very simple terms, the unique difference in perspective between conservatives in America and all other political stripes. It is a "bright line" because it boils down to a very fundamental assumption that lies at the core of our nation.
Except for a comment about Libertarianism at the bottom of the thread, I will leave it at that and let the fray begin, if it does.
Mitch Alan says
As a Constitution Conservative/Libertarian I believe in a small, Amendment X federal government...the word States is capitalized for a reason. Each State was meant to be a sovereign Republic with a Federation...A government closest to the people is the most efficient and responsible to it's people.
- .My Esoteric 11 hours ago
Yes, that was assumed in my question, but do conservatives think the 'u' in united States of the Declaration of Independence remain uncapitalized, which signifies one thing, or capitalized as in the Constitution, which means something different?
Mitch Alan 10 hours ago
The capitalization of the S in States is far more important...the Constitution was set up to limit the federal government that the States were granting certain limit powers to. We were meant to be a federation of States united...
My Esoteric 78 minutes ago
Disagree. There was a reason the creators of the Constitution, who were extremely careful with nuance, chose to use a "U", rather than a "u"; for it changes the meaning entirely as your comments clearly point out. I get the feeling you want a 'u'.
Mitch Alan 41 minutes ago
Yes, one of the main reasons for the Constitution and the bill of rights was to limit the federal government in both size and scope... and as a supporter of the Constitution and one who sees the value and reasons behind that idea...I am a "u" and "S"
My Esoteric 1 second ago
OK, now we are getting somewhere. The group of founders who wrote the Constitution were a 'U' and 'S' set of founders. The ones who wrote the Articles of Confederation were a 'u' and 'S' set. The 'U' and 'S' group won the ratification battle.
Mitch Alan 17 minutes ago
Yes, the Constitution more clearly DEFINES the federal government then did the Articles of Confederation, but it is still a LIMITING document. The "U" was used to show a unitary, but n ot a totalitar
My Esoteric 1 second ago
Yes,that is one way of looking at it, I prefer a more common meaning of "all together".
A Matter of Labels
Libertarians vs. Conservatives: From what I have learned, there is a distinct difference between the two. While they do share the same fiscal and governmental values, they do not share the same social values; in the main, there is quite a bit of difference there. Conservatism, as practiced by people like Edmund Burke and Russell Kirk is all about social order and laws based on tradition. One consequence of "social order" for a true conservative is a belief in a class or hierarchical structure of society, e.g., aristocrats vs commoner. This idea is antithetical to a Libertarian who believes in egocentrism and an extreme form of individual liberty.
Thomas Jefferson might be considered a Libertarian today but not a conservative, James Madison the same, at least until he became President, then the conservatives would have probably booted him out. Patrick Henry and George Mason were true conservatives.
WHAT DO YOU BELIEVE?
Should The 'U' in United States in the U.S. Constitution Be Capitalized or Not?See results without voting
DEMOGRAPHIC POLL #1
Do you consider yourself more closely aligned with the -See results without voting
DEMOGRAPHIC POLL #2
Are youSee results without voting
- Meyers-Briggs (Personality) Type Inventory (MBTI) - ...
The MBTI has always fascinated me because it is 1) pretty accurate and 2) very informative about who we think we are and how those perceptions of ourselves interact with others and their perceptions.
- American History IV: Do You Know Who You Really Are?...
- An Analysis of the Right-Wing Authoritarian Follower...
Are you a Right-wing Authoritarian (RWA) follower? I have talked about this personality characteristic vis-a-vis our political arena in several of the articles I have written because I believe it plays such a major role in today's political debate. T
- On Principle and Pragmatism II - Ratification of the...
Most Americans, including most Conservatives and Tea Party types, as well as Democrats, are not aware how close we came to not having an America at all. Roughly 50% of colonialists wanted something more like the what the European Union is today, exce
- The American Dream: Why is the American Middle Class...
America is rapidly approaching the inequality between the haves and have nots that existed in late 18th century France; right before the French Revolution. What is worse, we are doing it on purpose.
AMAZON ON FOUNDING DOCUMENTS
© 2012 My Esoteric
More by this Author
- 7Where Did Today's Conservative, Republican, and Democratic Political Parties Come From -- No, it Wasn't a Stork. 
How American political parties came to be the way they are always fascinated me. So, I decided to write a history about it. This will be a developing project that will probably take a year; please come back often.
Because research into the 2016 Presidential voting totals indicated the distinct possibility of a rigged election, Jill Stein of The Green Party has initiated recounts in three states; WI, MI, and PA
When I say "Freeloading", that is of course, sarcasm: only a small percentage of those drawing welfare are actually freeloading although Conservatives would have you believe it is 100%.