Follow the money: who benefits from Conspiracy Theories?

Spot the Conspiracy theorist
Spot the Conspiracy theorist

Americans, Italians and the Middle East love conspiracy theories and Conspiracy Theory is an interesting phenomenon in its own right. There are some simple tests for evaluating individual conspiracy theories but I have not seen any evaluation of the phenomenon itself. One way to look at it is who benefits and how.

Who benefits

A powerful test of a conspiracy theory is “who benefits” remembering that the benefit may not be money. Suspects include

  1. Those who make a living promoting conspiracy theories

  2. The state

  3. Banks and big corporations

  4. The shadowy groups alleged to be behind the puppet governments of the world

  5. Organised religion.

A few people make money from promoting conspiracy theories. Most, perhaps all, do it out of conviction not for money. As large scale contributors to the phenomenon those making money seem to be minor players.

The state

The Evil Overlord Handbook has the overlord saying “ Every few years I will pay some mentally retarded youth to stand up in a market place and say they are the true heir to the kingdom. Then when the real one turns up no one will believe him”. In one of her novels Mercedes Lackey describes the ruler of a city as permitting and welcoming the existence of groups dedicated to overthrowing him, and ruminating that if there were no such groups he would have to set one up in order to identify the malcontents in his city. The state therefore benefits from Conspiracy Theories since real conspiracies by government or their cronies can be denied more easily. Just as the best place to hide a book is a library a real conspiracy could be exposed and ignored: thus the state could leak evidence of its won conspiracies and have it ignored or disbelieved.

Big Business and Finance

Like the state the banks and big corporations can hide their real underhand actions in a bodyguard of nonsensical conspiracy theories. John Perkins in “Confessions of an Economic Hitman” describes a conspiratorial effort to bring the third world under US domination, and his book seems plausible ( though I am still evaluating it) so like the state the Finance Industry and the big Multinationals benefit from promoting such theories. In fact I am surprised the 2010 Gulf of Mexico oil spill has not been attributed to a conspiracy to keep oil prices up.

The Illuminati and their grey reptilian masters

The Shadowy groups alleged to be the rules of the world, including the grey shapeshifting reptilian aliens (who have presumably infiltrated the Illuminati via the Rosicrucians and Masons) benefit from such a smokescreen and can use this to find the people who endanger their plan. It is very easy at this point to start falling into a Conspiracy Theory mindset so I will not pursue this line as I am fairly sure there are no such groups. But if there were.......


Organised Religion

Organised religion is another beneficiary. It seems to me the majority of Conspiracy Theorists are also dedicated religionists, for example only in the Middle East do many people think the “Protocols of the Elders of Zion” to be genuine, and many of the American Religious right believe there is a satanic conspiracy to teach evolution, and last but not least there is the nonsense of the 1987 Satanic Ritual Abuse Panic, resurrecting slurs against Jews and recasting them as fantasies about Satanists. These theories serve to bond congregations and increase the power of religious leaders. Of course if there were any REAL Satanists they would be clever enough to realise the best cover would be a fanatical Christian sect.

Full Circle

And of course all these groups benefit because Conspiracy Theories tend to act as social safety valves. Real conspiracies like Watergate and Iran Contra are not seized on by the public and used to leverage change but quietly forgotten as too complex – although they are less complex than many conspiracy theories. And all the powers that be need to do is declare another “war” on something and the sheep step back into line.

It is amusing however that asking who benefits from Conspiracy theories has generated another such theory. I do not expect to benefit from it.

More by this Author


Comments 10 comments

AlexK2009 profile image

AlexK2009 3 years ago from Edinburgh, Scotland Author

thanks Gcrhoads64

I try to ba skeptical of the standard explanation and of conspiracy theories


Gcrhoads64 profile image

Gcrhoads64 3 years ago from North Dakota

Love this! Going to link to my conspiracy theory hub.


AlexK2009 profile image

AlexK2009 6 years ago from Edinburgh, Scotland Author

Good point Marshall, and I will think about it. Most "conspiracy theories" seem to me to be little more than the equivalent of speculative gossip: Like talking about which house the milkman goes into after their delivery round is finished.


Marshall Hammond profile image

Marshall Hammond 6 years ago from Portland, Oregon

Perhaps you could define what a conspiracy theory actually is. In my opinion, "conspiracy theory" is loaded term - an emotional charged label that is used to discredit any information being presented which might counteract a "politically expedient" version of events, which might often be reported by a a corporate owned media outlet with economic conflicts of interest. The existence of "conflicts of interest" can often be easily demonstrated, but as soon as the "conspiracy theory" label is attached, people succumb to the pavlovian response of ignoring the information, as a result of their mass media indoctrination training.


Hello, hello, profile image

Hello, hello, 6 years ago from London, UK

Very interesting and a good point. Thank you for a great hub.


GreenMathDr profile image

GreenMathDr 6 years ago

Actually, if there actually were a conspiracy, then the perpetrators of that conspiracy would benefit from a plethora of conspiracy theories. With so many, no one would believe that there actually was a conspiracy.


msorensson profile image

msorensson 6 years ago

Oh, please forgive me. How quickly we forget. In the 1980s there was in fact a series called V. The invaders were reptilian aliens and it was all about human resistance to the invasion, and I enjoyed it. It was a hit series!!

They are reviving this series, as I recall.


msorensson profile image

msorensson 6 years ago

Awesome..and kind of funny..reptillian aliens? lol...


AlexK2009 profile image

AlexK2009 6 years ago from Edinburgh, Scotland Author

Exactly my point.


Dave Barnett profile image

Dave Barnett 6 years ago from Central Oregon Coast

Who profits from conspiracy theories? Why people who write books about conspiracy theories. Some kind of conspiracy goin' on. WHAT?

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working