I have a challenge... there are a few rules to the challenge.
1 - For each point made, please explain whether it is an example of good or poor leadership.
2 - If a point is an example of poor leadership, please explain why.
3 - Do not bring up any other subject than the points described here. In other words, stay on topic.
Point A - Education
In 2003, Massachusetts was ranked by the NAEP(NCES) as follows:
4th Grade Math: 6th
4th Grade Science: 6th
4th Grade Reading: 3rd
In 2007, Massachusetts was ranked as follows:
4th Grade Math: 1st
4th Grade Science: 1st
4th Grade Reading: 1st
A similar story is found across subjects and grades, but these are the only three subjects with full data for their grade level available. All of this, even while cutting spending on education from $7.8 million in 2003 to $7.4 million in 2007.
Point B - Budget
In 2003, Massachusetts had a budget deficit of $650 million for the current year. Romney retroactively balanced that budget.
For the 2003-2006 budgets, Romney balanced every budget. For the 2006 budget, Romney had to line-item veto about 250 expenditures, and the legislature overturned all of his vetoes. He then used his executive emergency power to cut that spending anyway, as MA law requires a balanced budget. Romney fought against a legislature that was breaking state law.
In 2003, Massachusetts' 'Rainy-Day Fund' had a balance of $641 million. In 2007, it had a balance of $2.3 billion.
Point C - Unemployment/Job Creation
In early 2003, state unemployment was at 6%. In 2007, unemployment was at 4.6%.
In 2003, Massachussets was ranked 50th in job creation. In 2007, it was 28th.
I'm going to ignore rule three because you're narrowing the debate to a restricted data set and applying it to vague 'leadership'. Hitler and Stalin sure had great leadership too.There's one thing agreeing about something, but we have to establish whether the question is relevant or not.
A - Impressive, and proof that lowering spending does not equal poorer results (which should be helpful on another thread). However, Romney is not proposing any significant cuts to the education budget, has said very little about giving parents more choice, and is definitely not considering repealing compulsory schooling. From what we've seen so far it looks like you guys are going to keep the bureaucratic mess of Department of Education for a long time, and continue the agenda of mass indoctrination.
B - it might be signs of good leadership, but since there is no law requiring a balanced Federal budget, there is nothing to stop him continuing the policy of over-spending and over-borrowing, which he looks set to do.
C - Again, impressive, but the whole country is another ball-park altogether. Where is the evidence in his campaign that he's actually going to achieve this on a country-wide scale? He's as much a Keynesian as Obama is, loves the false hopes of bail-outs and stimulus packages, loves corporate subsidies and loves regulation to the point where I think he may be a Marxist in a Republican's clothes. The only lasting way to reduce unemployment is to provide a balanced budget, relieve the market from draconian legislation and get rid of that blasted Federal Reserve before it bleeds us dry. Where is the evidence?
by screaming4 years ago
With track records like these, do you really think Romney can create jobs? As Gov, Romney had Massachusetts ranked 47th in job creations. And in New Jersey, Gov Christie has his state ranked 48th in job creations. Yeah...
by Susan Reid5 years ago
Well duh!No wonder Romney's focusing so much on his Bain experience!His job creation record as governor of Massachusetts is not exactly impressive.47th out of 50 states on his watch.Wow.And we want this man as our...
by Grace Marguerite Williams5 years ago
To those who are going to vote for Mitt Romney, what are the pressing issues which draw you to him? Why do you believe that Mr. Romney is going to make a better president than our current President Barack...
by Xenonlit4 years ago
He is clearly a pathological and habitual liar. He has poor control over his explosive temper. He giggles when confronted about disturbing behavior he has done in the past. Who is stupid enough to vote for a man who has...
by Grace Marguerite Williams3 years ago
they saw President Barack Obama as the president of promise and reformation? During President Obama's administration, unemployment and national debt is the HIGHEST it has been. More and more civil...
by John Coviello5 years ago
Mitt Romney Has a 20 Point Lead in South Carolina. Is the GOPNomination Over? I thought that Romney would take New Hampshire, then lose some southern states, and leave the door open for someone else to come...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.