Rep. Catherine Brown, (R) has submitted a bill that would declare that abortions of a fetus that is the result of "criminal penetration" (rape) or incest would be considered "tampering with evidence" and be a crime punishable by up to 3 years.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/2 … ref=topbar
http://www.nmlegis.gov/Sessions/13%20Re … HB0206.pdf
"UPDATE: 12:25 p.m. -- Brown said in a statement Thursday that she introduced the bill with the goal of punishing the person who commits incest or rape and then procures or facilitates an abortion to destroy the evidence of the crime.
New Mexico needs to strengthen its laws to deter sex offenders, said Brown. By adding this law in New Mexico, we can help to protect women across our state."
This is going to help and protect women??!! Is there a single person in the state of New Mexico that actually believes that crap? This is nothing but another attempt to make an end run around Roe vs Wade and ban abortions - it can be viewed as nothing else.
How do such people ever get elected to office? People that are both willing and eager to run roughshod over everyone not accepting their particular brand of theology? Who votes for anyone with such utter disregard for the people that put them in office? Are there that many idiots and morons in New Mexico?
Or is it just another public event to buy votes? With both houses controlled by Democrats it will never pass - is she just placating a handful of voters? No wonder our politicians can't accomplish anything worthwhile - their time is taken up with nonsense like this!
That "woman" is totally amiss. She needs to resign from Congress and to return to college to take some courses in logic and critical thinking. Obviously, she is lacking in these skills.
It was because of idiotic questions like this one that I never took debate back in high school. Inevitably I would get stuck having to argue the PRO side! Little wonder so many trial attorneys are warped, leave law and go to Congress.
Warped? This woman makes a pretzel look straight!
Well, you know, wilderness....that pregnancy is the only 'evidence' that a rape has been committed. The other physical damage that a woman endures certainly isn't. Bruising, lacerations, that's nothing. Rape kits are pretty useless, right?! I mean they only provide semen (containing an offender's DNA). What possible use could that be? The medical examination that proves that sexual intercourse was forced upon an unwilling recipient....well, doctors don't know anything these days.
What a bunch of bullshit! Please assure me that you recognize the sarcasm in my words above.
*Edit - Oh, and let's add on to the psychological and physical trauma that this woman is enduring by treating her like a criminal. After all - she was asking for it, wasn't she?
She must have been asking for it; we all know from other politicians that you can't get pregnant from a rape. The female body "shuts down" or something and refuses to become pregnant. I assume the same reasoning applies to incest as well - the uterus knows the male is closely related and refuses any pregnancy.
I'm so glad we elect only intelligent, caring politicians to lead us!
Yeah, Motown, the sarcasm does tend to show through just a bit.
If men have to turn in their "man cards" for doing something less than masculine she should have to return her "woman card" for proposing something so asinine.
It is a shame that some politicians in this country are actually concocting these radical ideas, maybe they need a hobby or something since they obviously have too much free time on their hands.
Oh, it's not a radical idea at all - at the root is "ban abortions" - it's been around for decades. It's just pathetic that it's reached the point that such reasoning is the only thing left to the proponents and that they are stupid enough to actually use that reasoning and try to convince we the people that it makes sense.
Nor does it matter who says these things. Man, woman, child - heck the monkey swinging from the tree branch - can see right through the lies inherent in it. Only those desperate enough to stoop to anything at all to exert control control over others would have any hope at all that listeners would be sucked in.
I know that there has been a push to ban all abortions but this is the most radical way I have seen it. I guess she should get credit for thinking up the biggest whopper of a way that I have heard of so far.
The woman is foolish.
But wow .......I thought maybe liberals would love that law! After all, it de-personalizes the fetus into just a "thing", just like abortion does.
I'm appalled that the rights of the unborn are subjected to both unconscienable views.
Oh, I don't know, Brenda. The child, after being born, is the "thing" - just evidence to be used to convict the rapist.
Of course, anything a child has to offer (DNA) is just as available from an aborted fetus, but of course that isn't the point of the law. It's to make abortions illegal. ALL abortions, starting with those brought about by rape and/or incest.
Another nail in the GOP's coffin. They just don't get it.
that's bad...the senator must think everyone is stupid....errrr....or maybe she's just stooopid....more white noise...however it is only a bill being submitted, not passed....sheesh i wonder how much time and money goes into various bills that are submitted by stoooopid people. Stupid people scare me btw!
As a rape and incest survivor I am going to take an odd stance on this. I somewhat understand the point of having the pregnancy as evidence. In cases of long term sexual abuse a rape kit does nothing unless the victim just happens to finally tell right after an abusive moment. On top of that situations involving children/teens being raped by a family member there is always a possibility of the child just being angry and claiming something happened that didn't.
However there is testing that could be preformed after aborting to determine the DNA.
I understand what they are trying to do. By making it illegal it will make it easier to catch cases like incest. I just think there are other ways of fixing this problem.
I see where you're coming from, peeples. My problem with it is that it will result in treating a woman who has already been traumatized as a criminal - threatening her with punishment of up to three years in prison. I HATE that! A woman who is put in a position (after rape or incest) where she has to consider abortion is already suffering such emotional turmoil that I think the absolute last thing on her mind should be legal repercussions.
by Amber Musselman7 years ago
OKAY... SO I WROTE A HUB ON ABORTION AND TIMOTHY LEFT A COMMENT (BELOW)AFTER THAT COMMENT IS MY RESPONSE----- TELL ME WHAT YOU THINK AND WHO DO YOU AGREE WITH!! timothy Carpenter says:I...
by Scott Bateman6 months ago
The abortion debate is dominated by two extremes. On the one side, "pro life" extremists insist that abortion is murder. On the other side, "pro choice" extremists insist that abortion is a personal...
by Credence24 years ago
Do you think that the ‘pledge" taken by GOP presidential candidates Santorum and Gingrich to support a constitutional amendment prohibiting all abortions even in cases of rape and incest is a sell out...
by LailaK5 years ago
The 2012 presidential election is approaching! Do you think that the new presidential candidates should support or ban abortion for women of all ages? Why?
by Grace Marguerite Williams3 years ago
According to Huffington Post and Reuters, the Kansas House of Representatives passed a bill on Friday, April 5, 2013 on a 90/30 vote declaring that "life" now begins at fertilization. This is after the...
by Jackie Lynnley2 months ago
I read this was true and I just have to know if it is, please! Please provide links to prove what you say. Surely we are not going to be aborting babies ready to come into the world fully developed and healthy?
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.