Recently I wrote a hub and a request on basic rights or privileges concerning health care in America. Today one of my many news feeds had health care and this very idea on the front page.
Check the article out and I hope some opinions and suggestions will come out.
As a twenty-something citizen of the United States, this very issue is my fore runner of the big 4. If it is deemed a privilege, what's to be done for the millions that will be classified as unworthy?
The link goes to an article about the issue of some doctors and pharmacists wanting to refuse to provide contraceptives. Is that the issue you meant to address here?
As far as health care in general is concerned, something has to happen. Otherwise the system will just collapse pretty soon. It's unsustainable as it is now.
From the article, "Though freedom of conscience is a basic American principle, most people recognize that no right is absolute. The questions is: How far do providers' rights extend, and how are they balanced with the rights of patients?"
Yes the article is about the moral issue dilimena of "making doctors perform procedures" that goes against their moral high ground. But I didn't want this to become a "God" vs man topic.
Sorry, I should've made that clearer. My bad.
But I will say this, in this article you will find that the dividing lines are being drawn here. It is no longer becoming a grey issue, its more defined now to blue or red. When a doctor takes the oath to save lives, he didn't take an oath to pick and choose. At least that is my opinion.
Well, it seems to me, even defining what "life" is, when it begins and ends, is part of the current lack of ability to come together to make decisions for everyone's benefit.
So, until a consensus on "life" can be found, decisions may not be forthcoming. Or, maybe simple logistics of doctor accessibility within a clinic/hospital can be accomplished. Always have on duty a "provider" from both positions to meet the need of the patient.
Roe vs. Wade did decide that issue thirty years ago.
No, a law was put forth, it decided nothing based on the votes of the citizens as individuals of the nation. A law can not define and prescribe one's conscience beliefs, should not try...and that is one of the reasons why Roe V Wade was bad case law (or so I have heard from lawyers). It should be decided at the state level, so that the citizens can be represented.
The voice of the law that governs the US is the Supreme Court. They are part of the checks and balance system. They did determine and decide that issue 30 years ago. I wasn't even born. Yet, I still know my girlfriend or any woman has the RIGHT to get an abortion in the USA if she wants too. They did decide- whether you like it or not. America often does not take populace votes to determine law. That is why we have elected officials. Do you live in America? Do you fully understand America's form of Democracy?
This is silly relativistic crap. You don't need to equivocate nor should the rest of us have to suffer equivocation. If you're seeking that kind of balance, you ought to know that most doctors and nurses are fully aware of their job's responsibilities and are willing to carry out procedures. There simply aren't enough who don't for your solution. Also, what sort of service can a provider who refuses to do their duty provide? If you don't want to provide services that are routine, find a new job. If you're uncomfortable with having said services provided to you, go elsewhere. There's no need to conflate this issue with larger issues of consensus.
I once had a dentist whose assistant, while cleaning my teeth, told me I had major cavities in my molars, and the dentist wasn't telling me because he wanted them to get so bad, that they would have to be pulled. He didn't pull molars. It was just the operating principle that the molars should be pulled. I went to another dentist, had the cavities repaired, and still have the molars 30 years later.
That basically defines the simple solution to this topic.
by daskittlez694 years ago
Based on your own family's experience, what do you think we should do to improve health care in America?
by Judy Specht4 months ago
I have been listening to how the government has a billion dollars for getting people to sign up for the Affordable Healthcare Act. Would that money have been better spent training more doctors and building new...
by Silver Rose7 years ago
I don't normally get involved in political debates, but had to wade into this one. Some foolish American magazine has made the following comment:"The controlling of medical costs in countries such as Britain...
by Susie Lehto7 months ago
HEALTHCARE REFORM TO MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAINSince March of 2010, the American people have had to suffer under the incredible economic burden of the Affordable Care Act—Obamacare. This legislation, passed by...
by Alexander A. Villarasa2 years ago
What does one expect of a piece of legislation that was voted on, and passed both by the Senate and Congress, signed into law by Pres. Obama, and certified by the Supreme Court as being constitutional? High...
by Doug Hughes6 years ago
Last year there were 1.4 million personal bankruptcies in the US. According to a study by the American Journal of Medicine in 2008, 62% of bankruptcies are linked to medical costs. An astounding 80% of those people HAD...
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.