jump to last post 1-7 of 7 discussions (22 posts)

Do liberals support Illegal immigration because they are lazy ?

  1. ahorseback profile image46
    ahorsebackposted 4 months ago

    Why else support illegals who are merely working the bottom  of the food chain of employment ?

    1. wilderness profile image95
      wildernessposted 4 months ago in reply to this

      It produces seemingly cheap products, including food.  That the real cost is far, far greater is something not to be discussed or allowed to be mentioned at all.

      1. ahorseback profile image46
        ahorsebackposted 4 months ago in reply to this

        THAT is exactly why corporate America fights against  stopping illegal immigration .

        1. wilderness profile image95
          wildernessposted 4 months ago in reply to this

          Actually, I don't think that is particularly true.  When all the competition is also paying substandard wages to illegals it doesn't do much for the profit margin.  No, it is the greed of the consumer, the consumer swallowing the tale that illegals pay their way, that is the problem.

          1. ahorseback profile image46
            ahorsebackposted 4 months ago in reply to this

            Unchecked immigration is a government subsidy .

            1. wilderness profile image95
              wildernessposted 4 months ago in reply to this

              Well, a subsidy for the consumer, anyway.  Again, when all the businesses get the same "cut" in costs it doesn't help the bottom line a great deal.  They may get to keep a small portion, but not much if they want to compete and stay in business.

              Had a farmer tell me once that yes, he hired illegals and did it knowingly.  But that if he didn't he wouldn't be in business - it makes one think about just how much of that low wage is staying with the company.

              1. ahorseback profile image46
                ahorsebackposted 4 months ago in reply to this

                Yes ,  I have seen those employers and their illegal employees and families  in old run down house trailers without air conditioning or storm doors  out behind the tobacco fields ,    Poor -poor  tobacco growers , poor- poor  rich people who can't afford to pay a legal American  house cleaner ?

  2. psycheskinner profile image81
    psycheskinnerposted 4 months ago

    They often *are* the food chain, working with harvest and livestock husbandry which are skilled positions.  It isn't the basis for my feelings about undocumented immigrants.  It is however a fact of the economy that most people in affluent countries want cheap food but not to do the physical labor required to create it.

    1. ahorseback profile image46
      ahorsebackposted 4 months ago in reply to this

      What it is -is a Government Guaranteed Minimum Wage System .   

      Perhaps anyone here can explain why an entire  ethnic class of people  should be  relegated to a poor working  class  lifestyle in the most advanced nation in the west , supported mostly by the same liberals who want the borders left open ? these people live in a world of exploitation , crime , drugs , sex trafficking , extreme poverty , indentured servitude .?

      1. psycheskinner profile image81
        psycheskinnerposted 4 months ago in reply to this

        The jobs are there for anyone to do them, but affluent people won't because they have better options.

        Making all work $15 and hour plus benefits would be fine with me, great in fact.  The same people would do laboring jobs for the most part, and the same people wouldn't.

        I think the too issues are less connected than you seem to think, or at least not in the way you think.  If US laboring work paid better, even more people would come over here to do it.  Affluent folks will still prefer flipping burgers or shuffling papers to picking fruit or turning down beds.  They don't do laboring jobs because they don't want to and they don't have to.

        1. wilderness profile image95
          wildernessposted 4 months ago in reply to this

          Would you really go to a heart surgeon that charged $15 per hour?  An attorney defending your life?  Even an auto mechanic that you depend on for your children's lives?

          I wouldn't.  I'd go to Canada, or even Mexico first.

  3. psycheskinner profile image81
    psycheskinnerposted 4 months ago

    And to reiterate, this has nothing to do with my support of sanctuary cities and tolerating undocumented workers. My support is partly compassionate, partly recognising a shared heritage, and partly pro-pan-American free trade zone.

    1. ahorseback profile image46
      ahorsebackposted 4 months ago in reply to this

      Yeaaa....  I hear there are lot of great benefit packages in certain undocumented trades like say , prostitution , lawn mowing ,  child sex trafficking , drug running , yes  even apple picking , ......I wonder what they do when they fall off a picking ladder  and break their ankle .....call Workmans Comp ?
      What do they do when a drug trafficker  stiffs them out of a paycheck ?  Ask for $15.00  bucks an hour ?

      Say there are 20,000  undocumented people here  and  20 %  of them are working parents ;      How many of those are being exploited  in one way or another ,do you suppose ?

      1. psycheskinner profile image81
        psycheskinnerposted 4 months ago in reply to this

        Citizens are 5 times more likely to commit serious crimes than undocumented immigrants.  So if you want to reduce crime, try putting a curfew on citizens.

        The answer to undocumented immigrants being victimized is sanctuary cities. If police don't deport victims, victims come forward and get help.

  4. Will Apse profile image87
    Will Apseposted 4 months ago

    Economic migrants to Europe have headed to the UK over the last couple of decades, for the same reason Latin American migrants head to the US.

    Rightwing countries are fine with poorly paying jobs. Investors make good money and that is what matters in those counties.

    Countries like France and Germany do not want low wage/low skill jobs on the basis they do not offer anyone a good life.

    If you really want to cut immigration to the US, make it harder to create jobs that local people do not want and will only be taken up by the desperate.

    1. wilderness profile image95
      wildernessposted 4 months ago in reply to this

      How do they get their low skill tasks done if they don't want such jobs?  Require a college education to work a shovel?

      1. Will Apse profile image87
        Will Apseposted 4 months ago in reply to this

        Warning, cutting comment ahead, lol.

        I realise that the French must seem very clever to the average American but they ain't all Jean Paul Satre.

  5. ahorseback profile image46
    ahorsebackposted 4 months ago

    Time  for educating  ,  as long as there are more diverse people born there will be diverse jobs for them to do .     Some people are born  to pick up  grass clippings , some are born to be professional  college students , or  truck drivers or  waitress'...................?

  6. Kathleen Cochran profile image84
    Kathleen Cochranposted 4 months ago

    This question meets the "When did you stop beating your wife?" test.  Better worded:  What are some reasons Americans might have concerns about illegal immigration?

    1. ahorseback profile image46
      ahorsebackposted 4 months ago in reply to this

      That would be your choice of threads ?  Geee ,  ........next time I'll consider how you would word MY question ........................?

    2. Kathleen Cochran profile image84
      Kathleen Cochranposted 4 months ago in reply to this

      .next time I'll consider how you would word MY question ...

      There is always room for improvement - for all of us.

  7. profile image60
    Soft Maestroposted 4 months ago

    for shame all of you!  opining about something you will never control nor seek to control, nor will have the power to control... what a waste of time.

 
working