If this below is really true, and it is from the Library of Congress on Congressional By-laws and operations. Than how did any bill proposed that affects the Public generaly. sucH as Cap and Trade, Health reform, get to be declared Private.
Did Pelosi break her own Congressional law? I think so..?
Your comments or thoughts please, if you care to.
From the Library of Congress;
A bill is the form used for most legislation, whether permanent or temporary, general or special, public or private.
The form of a House bill is as follows:
For the establishment, etc. [as the title may be].
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, That, etc.
The enacting clause was prescribed by law in 1871 and is identical in all bills, whether they originate in the House of Representatives or in the Senate.
Bills may originate in either the House of Representatives or the Senate with one notable exception. Article I, Section 7, of the Constitution provides that all bills for raising revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives but that the Senate may propose, or concur with, amendments. By tradition, general appropriation bills also originate in the House of Representatives.
There are two types of bills-public and private. A public bill is one that affects the public generally. A bill that affects a specified individual or a private entity rather than the population at large is called a private bill. A typical private bill is used for relief in matters such as immigration and naturalization and claims against the United States.
A bill originating in the House of Representatives is designated by ''H.R.'' followed by a number that it retains throughout all its parliamentary stages. The letters signify ''House of Representatives'' and not, as is sometimes incorrectly assumed, ''House resolution.'' A Senate bill is designated by ''S.'' followed by its number. The term ''companion bill'' is used to describe a bill introduced in one House of Congress that is similar or identical to a bill introduced in the other House of Congress.
A bill that has been agreed to in identical form by both bodies becomes the law of the land only after-
Presidential approval; or
failure by the President to return it with objections to the House in which it originated within 10 days (Sundays excepted) while Congress is in session; or
the overriding of a presidential veto by a two-thirds vote in each House.
Such a bill does not become law without the President's signature if Congress by their final adjournment prevent its return with objections. This is known as a ''pocket veto.'' For a discussion of presidential action on legislation, see Part XVIII.
It would help if you let us in on what 'private' bill you are talking about...
any bill labeled private, like the Health care bill for example, or the Cap and Trade Bill, they are in and went through closed door committees- those type of bills, which we are told we cannot know about them, until passed?
Why? If they affect the public and they do, then why?
according to above that's not allowed?.
I stated which two bills, as an example in the first part of the post, I thought.
Closed-door committees are not new or unique to either party - or absent from any administration. What major legislation has not seen closed-door committees? It's not unusual for negotiation to be done off-camera - the final vote is public.
Er, according to the quote from the Library of Congress that you put in the Original Post, there is no functional difference between the way a public bill and a private bill are passed.
"There are two types of bills-public and private. A public bill is one that affects the public generally. A bill that affects a specified individual or a private entity rather than the population at large is called a private bill. A typical private bill is used for relief in matters such as immigration and naturalization and claims against the United States."
The difference is in what they are used for, but both must go through the same process.
Is there another clause in the rule set that describes some process by which a "private bill" becomes law that is different from the process by which a "public bill" becomes law? If not, then there's no issue.
If so, then there may be an issue, if the proper processes have not been followed, and/or the bill in question has been mis-classified.
I see the point Jeff, I am wrong then to say she did.
I see it.
Makes sense to me. Thanks for the explanation, learned a lot on this one.
The woman was asked about the Constitutionality of the health care bill. Her response "Are you serious?"
If she is that unconcerned about the Constitution, then I highly doubt she's any more concerned about the law of the land
by bahersadek5 years ago
Fighting back against Republican calls for greater spending cuts, President Obama said Friday that the government doesn’t need to make major changes to get its budget back on track and called for that solution to...
by Mike Russo4 years ago
I'm curious to know what have been the Republican congress accomplishments since Obama has been in office? It seems to me all they have done is criticsize everything that he has done and say no to any bill or...
by My Esoteric11 days ago
For eight years the Right has been fantacizing about how ACA came about in secret with nobody reading the massive bill. FALSE, but that is what the GOP is doing this week.The facts are that In considering the...
by ptosis4 years ago
"illegal immigrants under 30 who entered the U.S. as children and meet certain other residency and education requirements for the next two years. They also would be eligible to apply for work permits," -...
by IslandBites3 years ago
What now? House republicans said they will do their own reform. But, there is division about the issue, specially after some republicans voted to passed it in the Senate. Do you think the bill will not pass? Do you...
by Petra Vlah4 years ago
According to a new report in The Washington Post, the median net worth of the current Congress rose 5% during the recession while it fell 39% for the average American. The wealthiest one-third of lawmakers saw their net...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.