jump to last post 1-6 of 6 discussions (15 posts)

Converting Public Schools to Charter Schools is a Bad Idea

  1. Ralph Deeds profile image69
    Ralph Deedsposted 5 years ago

    Charter schools are being oversold as a way of solving public education problems. "Waiting for Superman" is a prime example of the propaganda efforts promoting charter schools.

    http://www.thenation.com/article/154986 … g-superman

  2. Evan G Rogers profile image84
    Evan G Rogersposted 5 years ago

    Most public schools adamantly refuse to work at all in any shape way or form with Charter schools.

    They are now opening their doors to the idea, thanks to a Private Charity that is helping government open its sticky doors

    http://www.dispatch.com/live/content/ed … tners.html
    http://www.kipp.org/news/the-columbus-d … r-schools-

    And on top of this, as a teacher-to-be, I'm seeing first hand the reality of how schools are run. I won't comment further because it might cost me a job in the future, or the jobs of current teachers.

    1. talisa2699 profile image79
      talisa2699posted 5 years ago in reply to this

      Interesting response.  I am really shocked by how many public school teachers and officials have been called to the carpet for items posted on social networking sites.

  3. livewithrichard profile image87
    livewithrichardposted 5 years ago

    Charter schools are not the problem.  The problem is Federal interference by "dumbing down" our children so that all children are on the same playing field.  The so called "culturally disadvantaged" and illegal immigrants need to feel good and our Government sold us out for what is called Outcome Based Education.

    I wonder how many culturally disadvantaged and illegal immigrants are in the Finnish education system which is cited so heavily in Waiting for Superman.  The Finnish system is touted as the best in the world.

    When I was in school we were taught reading, writing, math, history. and even geography and we were taught how to apply the aggregate of the knowledge in real world situations. 

    Schools don't teach that way anymore, they only touch on the very basics in the name of "equality" "fairness" "inclusiveness" and "self-esteem."  And, as a means of evading responsibility, they invade the privacy of families by encouraging students to report their parents attitudes and behaviors, and by encouraging teachers who are often unqualified and unprepared in amateur psychology which is why so many children have been placed on mind and mood altering drugs. 

    The problem with our schools is not in just one area, its systematic and will remain that way as long as the Federal Government keeps interfering.

    1. Jim Hunter profile image61
      Jim Hunterposted 5 years ago in reply to this


      Wow, I didn't expect to see this.


    2. Shadesbreath profile image88
      Shadesbreathposted 5 years ago in reply to this

      Yep. Totally agree.

      And because nobody is willing to say out loud that the real problem is and hold parents accountable for their children failing, it doesn't get better.  It takes effort on the part of parents to get kids to do well in school. You can't just sit on your ass all school year playing X-box, getting stoned or watching TV and then go in at the end and yell at the principal that the school has failed your kid.

      The education system and curriculum issues you describe are the crippling results of political correctness. Until someone is willing to stand up and say, "Your kid is failing because YOU are failing your kid," then we are stuck with this stupid, reactive idiocy.

      1. 69
        logic,commonsenseposted 5 years ago in reply to this

        Used to be the 3 R's.  Now it's all about PC!

        1. Daniel Carter profile image89
          Daniel Carterposted 5 years ago in reply to this

          Yes, and there's so much overwhelming evidence that Americans know reading, riting and rithmatic rill good.


    3. Evan G Rogers profile image84
      Evan G Rogersposted 5 years ago in reply to this

      Whatever your argument is, please don't blame teachers (I know you didn't, but I just want this to be clear)

      I'd say more, but once again, I use my real name on these forums, and it might cost me a job.

      1. Misha profile image75
        Mishaposted 5 years ago in reply to this

        Relax Evan, no American school principal in his right mind will hire you based on your other posts here, so this one is not going to make any difference smile

        1. Evan G Rogers profile image84
          Evan G Rogersposted 5 years ago in reply to this


    4. talisa2699 profile image79
      talisa2699posted 5 years ago in reply to this

      Can I ask you, in your opinion, who should interfere?  What ideas do you have for solutions.  One of the reasons why I fear having children is because kids are so different now and I feel that  it is partly due to the fact that the school systems are so different from when I was a child.

  4. Daniel Carter profile image89
    Daniel Carterposted 5 years ago

    New charter schools are not taken very seriously by universities and colleges. Without a strong track record, (and because they are generally very new they don't have a history or track record) they are looked at as experiments at best, and a haven for disgruntled, problem students and their parents.

    I taught Jr high school for one year over 20 years ago. The worst part about it was the administration and parents. As a result, I fled out of the public school system, and have never wanted to return. When administrators threatened me for leaving, by saying I wouldn't "teach in this state again," I told them to make it effective so I couldn't teach in all 50 states. Ever.

    However, for the record, I've continued to be an educator for adults and kids of all ages in private practice and in many other education forums.

    To me, American public schools are in about the same condition as the government, being over run by people with serious entitlement issues.

    Apparently, entitlement issues are a way of life for most Americans, and so these problems probably won't go away any time soon.

  5. livewithrichard profile image87
    livewithrichardposted 5 years ago

    My number one solutions is to get the federal government out of the business of education.  We need to tell those jackasses in Washington that for the very reason they have screwed up our nation, our economy, and our world stature, they need to step away and not screw up our children any longer.

    There is no right to an education enumerated in the US Constitution.  Individual States may include that right in their constitutions but it is not a Federal Mandate. So, why have we allowed the Federal Government to go where it has no business being? 

    I know how they got their foot in the door.  Through the commerce clause. Since the states receive federal tax dollars for education the Govt. has the right to come in and monitor how it is spent.  Also, since schools purchase items from all over the country, Interstate commerce takes affect.

    The way it should be is that the states grant local school districts the authority to create a curriculum and local school districts elect school boards to establish the curriculum and school policies. They then hire a superintendent to oversee all school operations.

    Most states are different. They each have their pros and cons for living there.  One of the biggest factors for someone with children electing to move to another state was the quality of the school district they were going to move to. 

    Now that the feds have implemented No Child Left Behind, the students in rural Mississippi have to be taught at the same level as students being taught in Barrington, Illinois (an extremely wealthy town)  But are they really?  I seriously doubt it. You see the school district with financial means only needs to loosen the curriculum (dumb down) so that they are closer to those districts with tighter funding. Why would they domb down? So their school gets a higher rating, of course which means in the new system of merit pay the teachers in the wealthier district will get paid better for doing less work (than teachers in poorer districts)

    Kids are being dumbed down for politics amd political correctness. Don't believe me? See how well your high school child does while watching "Are you Smarter than a 5th Grader" then come back and answer.

  6. jaydennia04 profile image60
    jaydennia04posted 5 years ago