I don't get this notion of everyone has rights. There are several problems with this philosophy. One -- If you have "the right", then you must be right and thus doesn't need to be accountable to noone, including society. Two -- everyone will try to make a law that suits them regardless what others think. Soon, you have many different laws for many different situations. Making laws to please everyone doesn't work.
Privileges means you deserve to be in that situation because you are accountable and you earn it. However, if you abuse it, you lose it.
Privileges are a fairer way to look at life and the law should be based on it, not rights.
Privileges are granted by someone else. You want someone else to tell you what you can and cannot do?
Come to think of it, you are right. The Bill of Rights is already the Bill of Privileges.
A bit of confusion here! A right and being right are two totally unconnected states, having a right does not always mean that you are right and being right does not always give you the right.
That beside I do have a certain amount of sympathy with the OPs opinion.
Too many people get rights and privileges mixed up, how often have you heard people say "it's my right to drive down this road"?
Driving isn't a right, it's a privilege.
How many more privileges do people claim as rights?
The point is that we have the duty to treat other people with a basic level of respect no matter how much of an idiot they are. "Rights" is just a way to encode *our* duty to treat others humanely--and to indicate that this duty *is not* conditional or optional for a civilized person.
If feel that unless you are ready to pay the consequences for your actions, you can't be consider a citizen. Of course, if you do right and respects the law and others, you should be rewarded.
Civilizations failed because their "citizens" do not respect the laws that govern their behavior that would be consider to be acceptable.
That would fall under the heading of innocent until proven guilty. You have the right to all privileges the law can afford the citizen, until such time as you are found guilty of breaking the law. Your rights begin to change at that moment.
You may have a little more faith in the good will of governments. I would prefer to err on the side of caution when considering what liberties to remove.
I doubt it would be much easier to control us all if we had to pass a test in order to secure what we know consider inalienable rights. The criminals would still be the criminals. You and I would simply be less free, because I can assure you; if you give government free reign to tinker they'll take all of your freedoms away.
People in prison lose some of their rights. Convicted felons have to wait 8 years after being released to petition for their right to vote. But to remove all rights for naughty people, illegal aliens,, and whatever other groups you might want to see added to the list would fundamentally corrupt the most noble of American characteristics: the rule of law.
Good Point. Privileges you can lose, but rights seem to be fautless way of saying i can never lose. Sometime to do with power, maybe?
It sounds like pretty much like people are close to the target regarding Rights and Privileges however I think I want to align myself with these 3, paradigmsearch, John Holden, Emile R
As someone here already stated a privilege can be taken away from you but having the Right- I Have The Right To Say You Can't Come Into My House Without A Warrant ( Not Supose To ), I have the Right To walk down the street without being stop or held against my will for doing nothing. I have the Right to a phone call. If these were privileges then other decide if they'll allow it.
by Cagsil7 years ago
What's your take?Feel free.
by repstrydiefly7 years ago
There are two bills that are in progress in the Senate to pass a law banning all private internet usage!!They claim that it will help eliminate spamming for military and government purposes.We need to do something about...
by cjhunsinger7 years ago
The American Bill of Rights is a restriction of government to interfer with the inherent rights of Man. The Bill of Rights is essentially the Freedom to Achieve. Human Rights are those rights granted by the United...
by Stump Parrish6 years ago
This is a comment I posted in one of my hubs and I was wondering what other's opinions on where our rights come from, are.If you believe our rights are basic human rights then you believe that all humans have the same...
by Flightkeeper6 years ago
Radical leftist James Lee became a militant environmentalist after seeing Al Gore's movie, An Inconvenient Truth, and has held three people hostage when he stormed the lobby of the building where Discovery Channel has...
by Texasbeta5 years ago
Yesterday, the celebrations began...NY has approved gay marriage. The latest polls tend to show the most Americans support the right...what about on here?
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.