Is the United States justified to declare war on governments that blatantly supress their citizens' want for freedom and kills large amounts of the population?
There needs to be a very good cause for any war. Civil Wars are internal problems of individual countries.
This is one of the hardest questions to answer. Any free nation has a moral obligation to protect the rights of people no matter where they are.
However, the United States first has an obligation to protect its own citizens. Thus by engaging in a war with a belligerent country, the United States may be exposing itself to retaliation by that country or other countries.
The short answer is yes, our country is justify in helping to protect basic human rights.
The difficult answer is that it is not always possible. The abuse of human rights is so widespread in this world, the United States does not have the resources to be everywhere, all the time.
So the realistic answer is yes, if we have the means an capability of doing something without endangering the health and safety of our own country and stand little if any risk of retaliation.
That sounds like a political answer and I apologize for that. But we live in a political world, where it is not always possible to do the things we want to do. Also, if there is an established government in that country, you face other challenges under international law.
I hope someone has a better answer, but this is the best I can do.
I agree with Larry about we can't be everywhere. But, the only things that frustrates me is when people claim because of that we should help no one. That's why I think you're right to include your "political" reason. I think its logical to think that way.
I think your question is too generalized to be answerd with any specifics.
There are no absolutes. But in general, if one anaylizes the motiation for wars, it's usually for economic reasons.
Tells us which wars and which governments you are concerned about and maybe we can give a more specific answer.
Fair enough peoplepower73. In my head I was thinking about Iran primarily and Iraq.
In my opinion, the Iraq war was totally unjustified. There were two reasons for that war. Saddam Hussien posed a threat to Israel and we wanted control of the oil. It was done under the guise of converting an entire Muslim country to democracy, which was and is totally unsucessful.
The conflct in Iran is for the same basic reason which is to protect Israel. Iran does not have weapon system to reach this country, so therefore, they are not a threat to us...of course, this is all in my humble opinion.
I would ask if the US was justified in declaring wars on countries whose governments don't agree with the US.
Murray Rothbard argued that there are only a few "just" wars.
Those of self-defense, and those of retrieving freedom from tyranny.
The second type is only to retrieve your own freedom, or to voluntarily help others with your own property.
by AdsenseStrategies7 years ago
Even though there is a perception that the United States gives large amounts of aid to Africa, the fact is that the Chinese and the Arabs are licking their lips at all of that mineral resource wealth that Africa holds,...
by StripedCrunchy5 years ago
Cubaâ��s totalitarian regime controls all aspects of life through the Communist Party (CP) and its affiliated mass organizations, the government bureaucracy and the Department of State Security. The latter is...
by Rajab Nsubuga6 years ago
When the Jews rebelled against the Roman Empire in AD 70, Titus the emperor destroyed Jerusalem. From then the Jews stood apart from other peoples in two important aspects. One was that in general they did not...
by ryankett6 years ago
Firstly, let me point out that I am a full supporter of the continued efforts in Afghanistan. Whilst I am still slightly cynical of the possible underlying motives, there can be no doubt that the country under Taliban...
by Comrade Joe3 years ago
The State Council Information Office of the People's Republic of China has published a report titled "Human Rights Record of the United States in 2013".In this a host of human rights abuses are highlighted,...
by Josak4 years ago
One of the greatest criticisms leveled at socialist and perceived socialist nations is their high taxes, usually reinforced with the example of France and it's high tax rates under a newly elected socialist...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.