Henry M. Littlefield was an was an American educator, author and historian who is best none for his analysis of "The Wizard of Oz". He breaks down the movie and connects characters, themes, etc. to Populism. Some agree, some disagree. Either way I thought this was interesting. Where do you stand?
I don't see it. Maybe in the character of the old woman trying to take away Toto. She was an influencial citizen over the farmer. The Emerald City was a happy place, nothing about the populace being discontent or the elitism of the great and powerful Oz.
NO, the Wizard of Oz was an argument to have a bi-metallic standard for money. Believe it or not, the book was designed to argue AGAINST having a central bank and fiat money (basically, what I have been arguing for since coming to hubpages)
"Follow the yellow brick road" - the gold road. They kept following the path of gold.
Dorothy's slippers were ACTUALLY SILVER - in the original story, her shoes were silver. The movie industry changed them to ruby to show off technicolor.
The charactersThe tinman represented the industrial north who would be more flexible with silver. The Scarecrow represented the farmer who was a bit too dumb to realize what silver would do for them.
And the Lion represented William Jennings Bryant who didn't have the courage to do stand for metal currency, however, he had spoken in support of it regularly.
The Wizard of Oz was the President
Each of the wizards represented a different economic player as well.
Here is Mark Thornton's take on it (he's an economist)
The Emerald (green) City is Washington and the Wizard of Oz (ounce of gold) is the president, who manipulates the population on behalf of the big-city banks. The Tin Man, Scarecrow, and Munchkins represent different groups of people while the Cowardly Lion represents William Jennings Bryan [an opponent of the gold standard] and Dorothy stands for “everyman,” the average, good natured citizen, who does not have a clue about the underlying causes of the problems of society. The Yellow Brick Road is the gold standard…Baum’s story parallels the American banking system where the government and big banks controlled the economy in support of the industrial and financial interests in the East to the detriment of farmers, labor, and rural America, especially in the South and West.
Baum’s book was written after only three decades of nationalized banking; the creation of the Fed in 1913 produced a system even more centralized than the one the Lincoln administration had recreated.
An important thing to note is Gresham's Law. If you want a silver and a gold standard, then the two metals' values can not be directly linked to each other, or else hoarding ensues.
If you make $25 worth 1 ounce of gold (yes, this is what gold used to cost), then that is what a dollar costs! 1 oz. = $25.
However, if you then make $5 worth 1 oz of silver, then you suddenly will find massive shortages of metal.
This is because of Gresham's Law. It basically states that you can only define a fiat currency off of one commodity because the relative values between commodities is ever-changing. Thus, one day the ratio will be correct, the next day silver will be worth more than $5, and the next day gold will be worth more than 5 oz. of silver... etc.
The only correct way to have a bi-metallic fiat currency is to define the currency as one quantity of one metal ($25 = 1 oz Gold), and then let the money ALSO be redeemed at a bank for the MARKET PRICE of silver (whatever that may be).
YOU WEREN'T EXPECTING AN AUSTRIAN ECONOMICS LESSON, WERE YOU?!
That's totally ludicrous. Why would anyone try to analyse a fictional child's bedtime story?
That analysis has been refuted by most serious historians but it is a great devices to get students engaged in the politics of the 1890's
No. It's about a little girl and her dog that, in a dream, are transported to another land via a tornado and they meeat a good witch and a wicked witch and a scarecrow and a tin man and a lion and a wizard and she gets home and wakes up and everybody smiles and they run the credits. That's pretty much it. I always thought it was about nuclear disarmament but turns out I was wrong. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar as they say.
From url http://www.usagold.com/gildedopinion/oz.html
"A key plank in the Populist platform was a demand for "free silver" -- that is, the "free and unlimited coinage of silver and gold" at a fixed ratio of sixteen to one."
From url http://www.turnmeondeadman.com/index.ph … sard-of-oz
"The Farmers' Alliances wanted greater government regulation of railroads, tax reform and the free coinage of silver to increase the money supply."
Hugh Rockoff writes that "The land of Oz is the East [in which] the gold standard reigns supreme and where an ounce (Oz) of gold has almost mystical significance" . . .. Rockoff goes on to identify the Wicked Witch of the East with Grover Cleveland, the gold Democrat who, as president, "led the [successful] repeal of the Sherman Silver Purchase Act of [sic, should be "in"] 1893" . . ..
Maybe it's me, but I really think that's quite a stretch. This thread, however, got me thinking - which led to putting my own thoughts on the meaning of the story into a Hub (so thanks - not that the thread was created to give me an idea for a Hub, of course - but I wanted to acknowledge where the idea came from and say "thanks" anyway .
by Gary Anderson7 years ago
Our meltdown can also be understood. This is must see. All hubbers need to take the time to watch this video:http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid … 0256183936
by rhamson3 years ago
What if we reinstated the gold standard to evaluate the dollar in its' current distribution. Since the debt standard has been blown apart in recent years could a real precious metal you can touch make a comeback?
by Gary Anderson4 years ago
You mentioned in our discussion on another site that Alan Greenspan sold out. But really, he sold out by not regulating bubbles. You say he sold out by not having a gold standard. But a gold standard would cause credit...
by rhamson5 years ago
In 1941, most countries adopted the Bretton-Woods system, which set the exchange value for all currencies in terms of gold. It obligated member countries to convert foreign official holdings of their currencies into...
by Evan G Rogers5 years ago
Main stream economists are finally discussing what every Austrian economist has already known (and has already been advocating) since... before they were called "Austrian Economists". That we need the gold...
by Charles James4 years ago
I am not an American, but American politics can affect us Europeans so it makes sense to follow American politics to se what might be coming down the line.Ron Paul generates an intellectual and political excitement I...
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.