Recently, here in Kentucky, a pastor of the Hagar Hill Freewill Baptist, spoke out to his congregassion to vote President Obama out of office. He is now being called on the carpet for making this public statement and according to the government, he has broken a federal law. Do you think this law is justified? Should a Pastor be able to give his opinion to the people of the church?
Just like the military an individual can have "personal" opinions and express them in private conversation without restriction. However, when in uniform or on military details such expression of personal opinion on a political issue can get a military member a general court martial which can end in jail and total loss of career and benefits [or an agreement to "retire" like General Stanley Mac Chrystal who was the best spec ops general around].
Churches are the same: Remember "Separation of Church and State". the Minister can have his "personal Private Opinion" and express it in personal and private conversations; expressing In Church to a Multitude of people that opinion becomes "political commentary" and violates the Federal Law Which Creates the "Exclusion from Taxation" and which defines the "Separation of Church and State":
the minister was dead wrong and just too lazy to speak to each of his members privately so he made his "personal opinion" a "Political Statement" violating the separation doctrine and endangering his entire church hierarchy's tax exclusion. They did not censure him for speaking the opinion, they censured him for endangering their tax exclusion; and rightly so.
Even though I do not believe freedom of speech means one can say whatever they like I still caution that it is easy for people to fall into a dictatorial atmosphere when they are in charge.
In the United States the government is supposed to be working for the people it should not be the other way around.
If politician are corrupted, stealing from the people, exempting themselves from laws etc. should the people remain quiet regarding these crimes?
If freedom of speech is based on taxation then corporations that pays their lawyers to keep them from paying taxes must also remain silent.
I never knew this law existed! However, if the majority of the congregassion feels the same about the issue at hand, then should they not be able to voice this in their own church? In reality the law makes sense, however, many of the issue effect people to their very core and in spiritual ways. I do not think you can always draw a clean line between church and state. It makes me ponder!
Total abuse of the power of the pulpit.
I hope the feds prosecute him.
And it wouldn't matter to me which candidate the pastor was telling his congregation to vote for (or against).
That is inappropriate in the extreme.
by Susan Reid2 years ago
Since when is America a "Christian" country? I challenge anyone to find a single mention of Jesus Christ in any of our founding documents."God" does not equal "Christ." I swear to God, yes....
by Mick Menous2 years ago
As far as this whole Separation of Church and State thing in the United States is concerned, I personally believe that it is necessary. For example, the words “Separation of Church and State” are not...
by Ben Bush8 years ago
There are many who say that, not only is the separation of Church & State not a truly legal concept, but it was never intended by God to be the true state of affairs in the United States.So, what is the separation...
by Rad Man4 years ago
The USA is supposed to be a secular society, but the religion or faith of their politicians seems to be of upmost importance. Canada for example, is also a secular society, but their citizens don't care what faith their...
by ElSeductor2 years ago
Why must religious people impose their beliefs on others? Why can't religious people keep religion out of politics? Why must Muslims kill others over their beliefs? Why can't Christians keep their...
by SparklingJewel7 years ago
Where does the expression, “Separation of Church and State” really come from?1. The U.S. Constitution? No.2. First Amendment to the Constitution No.3. Declaration of...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.