ngureco profile image 98

How Should Parents Discipline Their Children? Is Corporal Punishment A Form Of Child Abuse?

asked by ngureco 4 months ago

flag

63

HOW TO DISCIPLINE THE CHILDRENS IN THEIR OWN WAY

Childrens , we knew  the replica of parents. But we expect from them more than a adult. As such childrens know their world. Even we think they should know the adults world. so we straight away go for... keep reading →

 |  (+2)
 |  0 comments
no image

benitosuave says

Proverbs 23:13 Do not withhold discipline from a child;

if you strike him with a rod, he will not die.

14 If you strike him with the rod,

you will save his soul from Sheol [Hell].

 |  (+3)
Cathi Sutton profile image

Cathi Sutton says

I believe corporal punishment can be taken to the extream and become abuse. But corporal punishment used in a loving way to direct the mental and emotionl growth of a wayward child toward the right direction, is absolutely not abuse. As Will Rogers said, (to paraphrase), you can tell the child not to touch the coffee pot, but touch it he will, untill after he experiences the pain from the hot coffee pot. There are "coffee pots" all through a child's formative years, and beyond, into the teenage years, and on into early adulthood. If we simply let our children stumble there way through life, how can we expect them to be good, concerned, productive, kind people? There are consequences to the choices we make, and the actions we take. As surely as when it rains the ground gets wet. Children must be taught the concept of consequences. If they do not learn this, it is to their own peril, and to socity's. So spat a hand before it reaches the scalding coffee pot. And show the child that you love him too much to let him burn himself badly!

 |  (+5 / -2)
anisetta profile image

anisetta says

Yes, I believe that parents have the obligation and moral responsibity to discipline their children and to ensure that they provide appropriate guidance so that their children become a valuable asset to our society.

However, I do not believe that corporal punishment is the answer to unrully children. I believe that love,understanding, lots of attention, friendship, and the modeling of good values and high standard principles are the key to successfully bring up children that will be the future generation of responsible adults and outstanding parents.

I think that corporal punishment is one form of child abuse. There is also verbal abuse and putting the children down with sarcastic remarks, using bad language, yeling, and demonstrating frustration to children when they are unable to differentiate from the parent's right to be upset and the parent's lack of patience.

For me the keys to bringing a child into a responsible, polite, and well mannered adult are lots of love, lots of understanding, lots of friendship, and some serious and firm talk about following society's rules, which after all start at home and end at home.

 |  (+4)
Miss D profile image

Miss D says

Adults in today's society are more afraid of children than the other way around. This is because children have learnt that there are no real punishments when their behaviour extends beyond the boundaries permitted by society. As young children we learn right from wrong. Unfortunately it is now the case that children believe they can grow up disrespecting others as this is seen as the norm and they are so often not taught otherwise.

 |  (+4 / -1)
Phobe01 profile image

Phobe01 says

Look at our children now vs. children from past years. I believe we need more corporal punishment back in our schools. The teachers can't teach for fear of students who abuse the authority of their parents, and now their grades are suffering, there are fewer good teachers left with a passion to teach, and the drop out rate for students are higher. The respect factor for adults is lower, thus we have more crime and so on and so on. When I was growing up they would send a note home at the beginning of every year in grade school asking for parents to check the box (yes or no) in reference to kids getting paddled for misbehavior. Usually the parents checked yes, and the teacher and principle in witnessing the paddeling. Needless to say our teachers had very few problems with us back then and we were taught what we needed to learn in school. Very few bullies existed and life seem to work better than it does today. I think there is a age limit in which this type of punishment because trying to inforce this with a teenager does not work. You have to take something important away from a older child to seem to get your point across. But let none of us be fooled. Children don't do very well raising themselves, you have to take a stand and jump in their life now, while you can still make a difference.

 |  (+4 / -2)
Barry Davidson profile image

Barry Davidson says

To answer the question, corporal punishment is not child abuse unless it's taken to extremes. It's one thing to leave a red behind, but quite another to leave bruises which last for weeks.

When I was growing up, I always told myself that I'd never spank my kids. Now that I'm older I see what I put my parents through. The unfortunate part is that if one actually does discipline their children with corporal punishment, someone will eventually call the police or Child Protective Services. Trust me when I say that even grabbing your child's hand a little rough is public is an invitation to having someone follow you home and call the police.

 |  (+3 / -2)
66

The issue about corporal punishment

corporal punishment, child abuse, discipline keep reading →

 |  (+1)
 |  0 comments
janiek13 profile image

janiek13 says

If used correctly, corporal punishment is not a form of child abuse, but the inherent danger is in losing control. I believe it should be used as a last resort when nothing else has worked. It should always be an option because children often will push to the limit unless they have a fear of the consequences. Sometimes the unknown is more frightening than the known.

 |  (+2 / -3)
liuwenhua profile image

liuwenhua says

Spear the rod and spoilt the children. But having said that, corporal punishment must be used sparingly. I had never use (yet) on my child and they are still doing fine. We got to start teaching them right and the wrong from young

Where as in my kids days, my mum do canned me very often. After a while I started to be immune to the pain and threats, so after that nothing can stop me from going astray anymore.

 |  (+2 / -3)

You can vote each answer up or down to show your support or disapproval. You cannot flag an answer, but if an answer receives enough down votes compared to up votes, then it will become hidden.

Ask A Question

working