Kebennett1 profile image 93

Why is it that our children can't read a Bible in school, but they can in prison?

Prison may just be a little too late!!!

asked by Kebennett1 3 months ago

flag

dabeaner profile image

dabeaner says

Children shouldn't be exposed to such rubbish. But it's too late for those in prison, so what the hey.

 |  (+6 / -5)
questiongirl profile image

questiongirl says

Are children not allowed to carry a Bible at school and read it on their own accord? Or is it just that the school cannot encourage the reading of the Bible?

I am unclear on what the actual situation is, but it seems to me that if children are not permitted to be in possession of a Bible while on school grounds (as if it were a weapon or illegal substance), then their religious freedoms are being impeded. If a kid has a great desire to memorize Proverbs over lunch, why shouldn’t he be allowed to?

However, a public school, as a government-funded institution, must acknowledge the religious freedom of all of its students. Therefore, it would be inappropriate to incorporate Bible-reading into the curriculum, just as it would be to incorporate the reading of the texts of other religions.

In my opinion, schools should allow religious clubs if the students desire to charter them, but they should fund themselves. I believe school libraries should have religious texts of all sorts available in equal numbers for any student to check out at his or her own will—after all, these texts are all important cultural documents that give great insight into the history, traditions, social norms and conventional wisdom of the diverse groups that lend their collective flavors to the delicious melting pot that is our great country.

But these are just one girl’s opinions….

 |  (+5)
Kebennett1 profile image

Kebennett1 says

Joanne Lowe, deputy general counsel for the California Department of Education, said Students are allowed to meet in Bible clubs or other religious groups on campus, but the clubs must be run by students without an adviser (Adult of any particular religion). Therefore, on further research I must conclude that they are indeed allowed to have bibles on campus and the information I was given was in err. I am happy to hear that bibles are allowed in both places. Thank you for your responses.

 |  (+2)
EdG. profile image

EdG. says

This is a common misconception that even educators sometimes misconstrue. Praying in school with a bible is perfectly acceptable under the constitution, children simply can't be mandated to do so. In fact, I am fairly certain that the public high school in my town has an after school bible club. I believe there's even a room set aside for muslim students should they need to pray during school hours. If the principal were forcing all students to pray, it would be a different story, but praying is certainly allowed in school on a voluntary individual or group basis. That being said, your point about prison seems null.

That and unless your "child" commits a very severe crime he/she will not be sent to prison anyway. While some criminals may seem like children on account of their intellect, they are in fact adults.

 |  (+3)
topgunjager profile image

topgunjager says

Because people in prison do not have lives of their own, they would need to imagine a lot of things to ease the pain.

 |  (+2)
H P Roychoudhury profile image

H P Roychoudhury says

Reading of Bible is a sacred teaching for every body. It is immaterial where the teaching of Bible is carried out. It may be in school, Church or in prison. But for the sake of convenience teachings of Bible is rested with Churches while teachings of fundamentals are kept in schools. Jails are the places where an accused is required to be taught both in fundamentals and the ethics and morals of bible. As the division of departments increases the administrative efficiency, similarly divisions of teachings in Schools, Churches and Jails increases the academic efficiency.

 |  (+1)
svencill profile image

svencill says

Well when I was in school they had no problem with reading a bible there. As a matter of fact they had christian clubs at my school.

 |  (+3 / -1)
sarovai profile image

sarovai says

May be there is not much activities in prison. so, they like to read bible.

 |  (+4 / -3)
RomerianReptile profile image

RomerianReptile says

This is completely silly! When I was in grade school and was still of a religious persuasion, I was NEVER stopped at any point from reading the Bible during free time.

This is one of those silly claims that people throw out there so they can cry religious persecution.

 |  (+2 / -1)
pageantgirl31413 profile image

pageantgirl31413 says

This has been a problem for years. A Bible teaches morals and for those in prison, they are hoping they will change and sometimes the best way to do it is reading the Bible. Separation of Church and State is what causes the issues at school. I was almost suspended in middle school for praying with a friend at lunch. For the remainder of the year, I could only lower my head and close my eyes. I could not fold my hands nor pray with another student. This eventually cause my praying problems that I have today.

Too bad people don't really know where the whole 'separation of church and state' came from and how it was taken out of context at the original trial.

 |  (+3 / -4)

You can vote each answer up or down to show your support or disapproval. You cannot flag an answer, but if an answer receives enough down votes compared to up votes, then it will become hidden.

Ask A Question

working