She Messed Up Her Relationship. How To Fix It? Is It Too Late?
I am impressed by the advice you've given and wish that I stumbled on it earlier. I was in a similar situation as Marla recently. We are in early 30's and broke up about a 1 1/2 yr ago because he thought we weren't compatible long term but realized he was wrong. After about 7 months of being apart, we eventually got back together with the first 9 months being fantastic until I began pressuring (he had not thought about engagement when I brought it up but we'd talked about future, kids, met parents, etc, him not thinking about it made me freak out). Btw, he moves very slowly, he kept telling me he wanted to be with me and for me to be patient. We began arguing over stupid things, etc. A t the time, I also lost my job and didn't realize how much that put my focus on him. He had been unhappy and he ended it 2 weeks ago. When we broke up he said I'm not happy and I don't love you (even though two days earlier he said he loved me). I've realized that it's been my fault and I was putting my needs and focus on him, etc, when other parts of my life was not where I wanted it to be. I also realized that I had 'baggage' from the last breakup and that I was testing him to see if he was going to change his mind after we started talking about engagement. This time around before I began pressuring he had been committed and there wasn't any reason why I should have doubted him (except for my baggage from the other time around). I recently sent him an email explaining all of this and apologizing because I think I should have treated him better and he didn't understand why I was acting the way I did. It's been such a painful lesson because we are perfect in so many ways and I do think we both thought we were each other's one. I am completely devastated--mostly because I realized what huge mistakes I made. I've come into a lot of clarity in the last couple weeks and grown up quite a bit. He has not responded to my email at all (it's been 3 days). Is there anything to do once the pressure is out there and I think he ended it in part because of that. I really want to make amends and there are so many things I want to do differently now if we are together again. I would be grateful for any advice you may have. Thanks in advance.
Thanks so much for reading me, and for trusting me with your specific situation.
I must say, I'm truly impressed by how clear you are. And how you've really stepped up and owned it all. Seems like your Rites of Passage brought a lot of focus and clear thinking for you, which is wonderful.
Pressuring someone into marriage commitments often turns out the way your relationship did. Taking a step that huge that should involve the entire rest of your life is a tremendous decision. It's not just about love, it's about self awareness, security. It's about how a person feels regarding the path they are on, and every branch of that from wanting or not wanting kids, to loving or hating your job. It puts all of your dreams on the line, and magnifies all of your insecurities. The decision to marry can't be forced. And pushing someone into making a decision they are not ready or not able to make can only ruin your relationship with that person. They don't see you as a partner, and why would they. They see you as demanding, unsympathetic, needy and controlling. They see your disregard for their feelings. They see your behavior as the shadow of things to come with you. Most likely, they imagined a life partner who'd be a friend and companion as well as a lover. You aren't any of those things when you are demonstrating intolerance.
What you're doing
I've often said throughout many hubs, that actions speak louder than words when it comes to the men. It is very common that they can't articulate what they feel, fear and want. And it is also common that even if they can, they just don't. So it's always important to watch what they do.
For example, if he's saying he doesn't want to talk about marriage yet, but he's opened a joint savings account with you to put some cash aside for the wedding or a house, then that's a very major indicator that he IS planning his future with you, even if he's not ready to talk about it.
Consequently, if he's saying, "Oh yeah, I'm gonna marry you, babe. Someday." And he continues to party away all extra cash, doesn't tell his family or friends about you, doesn't share any responsibilities with you like rent or a bank account... he's telling you with his actions that he is not planning any future with you as of this moment.
Amanda, you have to put this logic in reverse. Since for most guys actions speak louder than words, you have to realize that what they see you do speaks much louder to them than what you are saying.
Your words of remorse and insight are beautiful, and admirable. I was blown away by your email. However, for him, it's not going to have that impact. He's going to cycle that into what he's "heard" before. He still sees you in his mind's eye through the behaviors and fights he's remembering.
Writing him these emails, leaving messages, trying to "talk" is all a woman's way. But it is not his way. And it's not going to get you anywhere. All you're doing with these emails is confirming for him that you're obsessed with him and this relationship, that you aren't a whole person, that you're dependent and needy.
Your ex went through his Rites of Passage/Saturn Return which has brought him clarity, too. You're not the only one seeing things clearly now. He clearly ended all ties with you stating he does not love you. He could not have been clearer. I realize you want to temper that with what he's said before. But you have to see what he did there. He made a clean break. He left you with no hope. After doing so, he gets this long email from you. It doesn't matter what it said. All it "says" to him is that you don't listen. You're the same unhappy person, pushing him to do something he is clearly telling you he doesn't want to do.
Amanda, this must stop.
What you should be doing
It is my opinion that when you're needy and obsessed you repel the partner you seek.
You aren't needy and obsessed. So make a conscious effort not to act like you are. You said you weren't happy with other aspects of your life. You lost your job, you have some personal stuff going on there. Focus on that. I'm serious. Take a couple classes, take yoga, apply to some different part time jobs so you can get a mix of different things while you're seeking your dream job. Read. Dance. Make plans with your girlfriends. Reconnect with some high school or college buddies. Go to Happy Hour, go to a poetry reading. Sing Karaoke. Break old habits and enjoy new things. You think I'm kidding, but I am dead serious. Your new found clarity has to manifest into your physical life before it makes a difference.
Do this for you.
You have to love yourself and like yourself before anyone else is going to love or like you. You have to become a whole person again. You have to let this heal, and close. And end. You have to move forward.
And I will let you in on a little secret. Months and months from now, maybe even a year or two from now, you could bump into him. Word could be getting back to him. And when he SEES that you have grown and that you're this independent vivacious strong fun-loving woman, he will see you with different eyes.
There is a possibility you two can reconvene. But I guarantee you it will not be because you continued beating the past to death. If it happens it will only be because you let go and moved on, and he saw you for the whole, insightful and beautiful person you really are.
Got a question?
Want my opinion on your relationship dilemma? Ask me, like Amanda did. Send me an email through my profile. I'll do my best to help.
More by this Author
When you first began dating him, you were new. You had mystery. He didn't know where you were going Saturday night. He had to ask you if he wanted to see you. He didn't know all your friends, he didn't know every detail...
I’ve been reading your hubs since the beginning and although I have a feeling of where you’ll be headed with your response to my questions, I think I want to hear it. I think I’m ready to hear it. Then...
Some things are clear. Opening his mail is a felony. Going through his dirty laundry if you’re the one doing the laundry, well then that has to be acceptable. But what about everything that falls in between? If...