Josephus & The Baker's Dozen
In debates over the historicity of Jesus, one name that invariably appears is that of Flavius Josephus, a Jewish historian who made references to him in his writing (decades after Jesus supposedly died). What is NOT commonly known is that Josephus also mentions thirteen OTHER people named “Jesus” throughout his major works -- “War Of The Jews” (WOJ) and “Antiquities Of The Jews” (AOJ).
So who are these other men named “Jesus?” Most were high Jewish priests. The others included a ruler, a general, a thief, a 'prophet' and the leader of a robber gang. Two even led mobs against each other. Separating them all into mutually exclusive identities – either by date or by association with other distinct individuals – is somewhat problematic. In Josephus' narrative, independently verifiable information is often sparse.
Complicating things further is the commonality among the names associated with the different Jesuses, making them harder to distinguish (as in the cases of Jesus numbers 9 and 10, who fathers share the same name). Even worse – as anyone who's researched ancient manuscripts knows – the same historical name is often spelled quite differently depending upon the historian (making corroborating external sources difficult).
I've listed Josephus' “Jesuses” in chronological order by year, or by order of appearance (in his narrative) if more than one appears in any given year:
Jesus #1 was the first high priest of the Jews after they began returning from their Babylonian captivity (539 BCE). He was the son of Josadek, who was high priest when the Jews first entered captivity seventy years earlier (AOJ, Book 20, Chapter 10).
Jesus #2 was the brother of John (Johanan), who ascended to the high priesthood (410 BCE) instead of Jesus – who had been promised the job by his friend Bagoses, one of King Artaxerxes' generals. The two brothers quarreled in the temple, and John killed Jesus, for which Bagoses ostensibly punished the Jews for seven years (AOJ, Book 11, Chapter 7).
Jesus #3 was in line for the priesthood when his brother Onias, the current priest, died. However, due to a quarrel with the king Antiochus IV, he was denied the position in favor of his younger brother (also named Onias). Jesus (later “Jason”) raised a rebellion against the new priest and, having more popular support, sent Onias packing until the king returned (167 BCE) and restored Onias (later “Menelaus”) (AOJ, Book 12, Chapter 5).
Jesus #4 was in line for the high priesthood on the death of his father, Phabet (24 BCE). Unfortunately, King Herod wanted to marry Mariamne, the daughter of Simon who, though a priest in Alexandria, was still much farther down the social ladder. So, he raised Simon to the high priesthood in Jerusalem, enhancing his social status and making the marriage more politically feasible (AOJ, Book 15, Chapter 9).
Jesus #5, the son of Sie, was another high priest, who ascended to his rank after King (Herod) Archelaus sacked Eleazar, the current priest (3 BCE) (AOJ, Book 17, Chapter 13).
In between the fifth and sixth Jesuses comes Jesus of Nazareth. There are a couple of references to him in “Antiquities Of The Jews (Book 18, Chapter 3 and Book 20, Chapter 9, though the former is commonly believed by scholars to be a complete or partial interpolation (inserted later into the text by Catholic transcribers)).
Jesus #6 was the son of Damneus. He was made high priest by King Agrippa (63 CE) after his predecessor, Ananus, abused his authority by convening a Sanhedrin to condemn and stone James (brother of Jesus of Nazareth) (AOJ, Book 20, Chapter 9).
Jesus #7 was the son of Gamaliel. He succeeded Jesus #6 (above) in 64 CE, by order of Agrippa. A “sedition” broke out between the two competing Jesuses, approaching the point where their mobs were throwing stones at each other. Agrippa eventually removed this second Jesus, repacing him with Matthais (AOJ, Book 20, Chapter 9).
Jesus #8 was the son of the Jewish high priest Sapphias. He was one of the generals chosen in Jerusalem by the Jews in their revolt against the Romans during the reign of Cestius Gallus (66 CE) (WOJ, Book 2, Chapter 20).
Jesus #9 was the son of another Sapphias, governor of Tiberius (the city, not the emperor) in Galilee. Together with John of Gischala, he agitated crowds (67 CE) against Josephus (then one of the Jewish generals in the revolt against Rome). He became ruler of Tiberius until the city was taken by Josephus' forces (WOJ, Book 2, Chapter 21).
Jesus #10 was the son of Shaphat, leader of a gang of robbers in Sennabris. Jesus led a band of horsemen who attacked a cavalry detachment of Vespasian's army (68 CE). He was later driven out of Taricheae by Titus (WOJ, Book 3, Chapters 9-10).
Jesus #11 was the son of Gamalas. He was a high priest who tried to pursuade the people of Jerusalem against the “zealots” who took over city and prompted its siege (and eventual capture) by Titus (70 CE). Initially escaping to the Roman camp, Titus sent him back to the tower to try to negotiate with the citizens (WOJ, Book 4, Chapters 3-5 / Book 6, chapter 2).
Jesus #12 was the son of Ananus, a “plebian” and a “husbandman.” He supposedly 'prophesied' for 7 1/2 years the coming destruction of the Jewish temple (70 CE), and was beaten and killed by a rock thrown at him from the crowd (WOJ, Book 6, Chapter 5).
Jesus #13 was the son of Thebuthus. He defected to the Romans beseiging Jerusalem under Titus (70 CE), bringing sacred items from the temple as a condition for safe passage (WOJ, Book 6, Chapter 8).
I've created this hub to serve as a resource for believers and skeptics alike. Of course, it doesn't settle the question of Jesus' historicity, nor is it intended to. But, hopefully, it will make the issue easier to navigate, and provide a broader illumination of Josephus' relevant work.
More Biblical resources from Paladin:
More by this Author
For Christian believers, the Old Testament book of Isaiah is a treasure-trove of Jesus prophecies, and chapter 53 (including the last three verses of chapter 52) is perhaps the most popular of all. At first glance, the...
When it comes to defending the Bible, nothing is more appealing to believers than prophecies, and one of the most widely quoted is Isaiah chapter 7, verse 14: "...Behold, a virgin shall conceive, and bear a son,...
Just as there is no way to definitively prove that God exists, there is no way to prove that he doesn't.* Interpretations of the available physical evidence will always be subject to personal bias. Critical examination...