Reply to a Heartbroken Sister by Merwin

Excerpted from FB.

”Merwin, if he redeemed mankind from his murderous paths, how do you explain things like the Crusades and church excommunications and believers separating themselves from family members only because they don't believe?”

2 EDK and all… Thank you for any patience you may have been forced to generate while waiting on me to compose this reply. I will respectfully respond as though the question were genuine and sincere. I apologize for the complexity of the answer, I will attempt to keep it as direct as I can, with little or no segues onto rabbit trails.

I see this as a two part question dealing with 1) “Things like the Crusades”. AND, 2) “Things like Excommunications…” / Shunning / Dis-fellowshipping.

Because I do see this basically as a two part question, I will take the liberty of answering it on two levels for each part… a simplistic opinion, then a more in depth opinion if requested.

1) Crusades et al. Rather than answer just about the Crusades, I will give my simplified opinion regarding all Christian atrocities, Crusades, Spanish Inquisition, Anglican counterpart to the Spanish Inquisition (persecution of Catholics in early protestant England, and more recently the Serbian (Christian) genocide in the former Yugoslavian region. Etc. These are the products of mankind… not God.

Mankind will take whatever opportunity he may, to exert murderous control over his fellow man. He will use whatever vehicle presents its self to further himself along this path. Mankind does this with all faiths, or lack of faiths. He does this with any political platform that is accessible to him religious/political, or atheistic/political, and anything in between, in any variations.

Any departure from this heinous behavior is due to the person(s) having been redeemed from that nature, and that redemption may take many moralistic forms… religious, anti-religious, political, or just plain personal faith (religious or otherwise) that this should be done.

But… In my opinion, there have been more examples of consistently kind, peaceful, generous lives coming from redeemed faith, not just Christian, than from the various militant cultures that can found among unbelievers.

2) Excommunications et al. The examples of “cut off” in the Old Testament, for unbelief and many other things, usually meant the death of the offender. And because this does not appear to be what you were referring to, I will stick to the New Testament for the reply.

The first example that springs to my mind, can be found in first and second Corinthians, with the believer who bragged about sleeping with his own Mother and was disfellowshipped, and later, (2 Cor) he was heartbroken and despondent, so Paul encouraged the Church to allow his return.

I know there are circumstances mentioned elsewhere in the Bible that instruct us to “not have fellowship with one such as…” then names the conditions. My opinion are that all these are more along the lines of a cold shoulder treatment as opposed to disfellowshipping as in the previous paragraph. Not as severe as your portrayal I think.

It does little good to ridicule me for “interpreting” the Bible, as you asked for my explanation.

Conclusion of the simplistic response… It is mankind that is fallen. It is mankind that corrupts. There can be no code of conduct to be found anywhere in existence, that teaches righteous and peaceful coexistence as good as the Law and the Prophets, and they can be found personified perfectly in Jesus.

And, yes mankind constantly attempts to take God’s message and corrupt it for his own purposes. Similar to Stalin and Chairman Mao with the Communist Manifesto, Marx and Engels probably had no idea the hundreds of millions that would be murdered at the hands of atheistic communists… or did they..?

(Again, I can provide a more definitive answer if requested)

Comments 3 comments

Roger Crigger profile image

Roger Crigger 5 years ago from Northern Idaho

The HEART of ALL mankind is desperately wicked! The ONLY good that will ever come from Mankind will come from, through and by God Himself....often THROUGH individuals, as HE chooses, but the atrocites, some of which you mentioned above are totally VOID of God. WE...MAN...Are solely responsible and are such because God has planned to "give us choice", (That's why we're here, although I do not have a fraction of the space and time to accurately expound upon that statement here. Suffice to say, when we remove God from the equation, (which we have and are doing to greater and greater degrees), we stand hopeless, and completely void of the ability, as a race, (people)to repel, squelch or stop man from doing what man does... Exalt himself and BECOME GOD! Great Hub Merwin.... and finally, for what it's worth... I personally doubt that Marx or Engels would have cared at all... we are all accountable to ourselves ONLY...when WE are God!


Roger Crigger profile image

Roger Crigger 5 years ago from Northern Idaho

I tried to edit and ad one more statement to the above comment but was unable so I will do so here. Having come to the end of my first comment prompts many, (including myself in the past) to offer up the question, "What kind of God would allow...( state strocite here)", to which I have come to understand and would reply, "The same kind of God that 'allowed' us to disobey Him in the first place!"


CoauthorU profile image

CoauthorU 5 years ago from Inland Northwest, USA Author

AMEN AND AMEN... Thanks Roger.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working