wandererh profile image 85

If God is all knowing, and he knows the choices we will make, do we really have free will?


If God knows everything, and he knows all the choices that we are going to make before we are even confronted with the choice, how can it be that we have free will? The only way for us to have free will is for God not to know the choices that we are going to make, effectively making God not all-knowing.

sort by best latest

SidKemp profile image93

Sid Kemp (SidKemp) says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
krillco profile image95

William E Krill Jr (krillco) says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • wandererh profile image

    David Lim (wandererh) 4 years ago

    If God already knows everything down to the most minute of details, how can that be compatible with free will? I just can't see how the concept of an all-knowing God and free will can coexist.


  • See all 3 comments
iantoPF profile image86

Peter Freeman (iantoPF) says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
ptosis profile image80

ptosis says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
BrianMI6 profile image61

BrianMI6 says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • vector7 profile image

    vector7 4 years ago

    I'm speechless. As in, the question is answered in full much more understandably than I have answered it previously. Looks like my sentiments on paper. [or screen rather]

    Double that statement above. I'd quote it if asked.


  • See all 3 comments
Sheepsquatch profile image75

Sheepsquatch says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
yoginijoy profile image80

yoginijoy says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
lone77star profile image91

Rod Martin Jr (lone77star) says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • wandererh profile image

    David Lim (wandererh) 4 years ago

    The intent of the question has never been to "knock God off his pedestal", but to highlight that it appears that an all-knowing God (knowing all of the past, present and future) and the freewill of humans, cannot both be true at the same time.


  • See all 3 comments
ackman1465 profile image61

ackman1465 says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
JimMiles profile image82

Jim Miles (JimMiles) says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
CynthiAnn profile image59

CynthiAnn says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
If God is All-Knowing or Omniscient, Do We Really Have Free Will?85

If God is All-Knowing or Omniscient, Do We Really Have Free Will?

4 years ago
 |  Comment
 |  12 comments
wingedcentaur profile image84

William Thomas (wingedcentaur) says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • wandererh profile image

    David Lim (wandererh) 4 years ago

    Hi wingedcentaur, I think you are confusing predictive ability with control. The fact that I or God can predict an outcome does not mean that we control the outcome.

mintinfo profile image82

mintinfo says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • wandererh profile image

    David Lim (wandererh) 4 years ago

    Are you saying that God knows all the different possible futures that can come to pass, but we get to choose which future will actually come to pass? Hmmm, an all-knowing God and free will.


  • See all 4 comments
d.william profile image85

d.william says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • IDONO profile image

    IDONO 4 years ago

    So, why would anyone do anything good for another person? Is life real or just an extreme imaginary entity that will drive me nuts. If you think there is no God, you'd better be right!


  • See all 3 comments
josh3418 profile image68

Joshua Zerbini (josh3418) says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
Civil War Bob profile image61

Civil War Bob says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • vector7 profile image

    vector7 4 years ago

    What a title CWB! lol. Caught my interest, will check it out.

60

Xemini says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
0

Larry Wall says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
  • backporchstories profile image

    backporchstories 4 years ago

    I whole heartedly agree!


  • See all 3 comments
0

VeronicaInspires says

4 years ago
 |  Comment
working