I think this is based on David Hume, but I can't be sure if he would agree with the entire argument because I am not completely familiar with all of his writings.
1. All knowledge of the natural world is either directly based on sense experience, or derived from technology that can be understood through these sense experiences.
2. Sense experiences are subjective to the individual having them.
3. Therefore, all knowledge of the natural world is subjective.
This is a purely intellectual exercise. I don't really believe this argument, but I am wondering about thoughts on it.
What is this 'knowledge'? Is it about sensing what is outside of us? In that case we do not know ourselves even, for what we think of as our body is an illusion created by our brain called body image, which can be fooled.
But does the things outside of us, exist because we perceive it, or have they got independent existence? They should, for we are just a collection of matter that can disintegrate in front of us, while the matter is there. That is, we are perishable while matter is eternal and should exist independent of us.
I do not know whether I am clear, for I can't get the proper words.
by Sooner283 years ago
Bishop Berkeley makes this argument (simplified) to argue against the existence of an external material world.1. "Material objects" are simply collections of "sensible qualities" (sensory...
by emrldphx4 years ago
For those who are interested, I am putting together a primer on the difference between subjectivity and objectivity. Much of the disagreement in this forum is due to confusion between the two. We'll start with a...
by BakerRambles2 years ago
Materialism, a notion based upon the acquiring of various goods to achieve ones goals. What is materialism however, and how much does the notion impact your life? Would you say it was more positive or...
by Jane Ramona Rynkiewicz Frieman21 months ago
This quote is philosophical. In my personal experience, acquiring knowledge was not just handed over, it was a goal to be worked towards by way of learning life's lessons, reasoning out what's right and last but not...
by Sooner283 years ago
I don't know if anyone else has ever made this argument. If so, I apologize for not affording the proper citation. I thought of it recently and thought I would share. I want to lay out a disclaimer...
by Cecilia5 years ago
The hilarious pattern of people in the forums is not realizing they are in the wrong genre.There is a scientific discussion and then the churchgoers who know nothing about science pipes in.Then the churchgoers want to...
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.