If Mary believes in reincarnation and Jane believes you just turn into dust after dying because she is an existentialist, what happens to each after they die?
a. Does Mary get reincarnated into the appropriate form and Jane turn into dust forevermore?
b. If reincarnation is really what happens, does Jane get to say, when she is surprised to realize at some point in her new life that she did not turn into dust, that she really just wants out, she doesn't believe in reincarnation- "Just turn me into dust!"
c. If, on the other hand. everyone just turns into dust after you die, what happens to Mary? She is dust, she cannot say, "Hey, this isn't what I believe in, reincarnate me!"
d. Does it matter how firm they are in their beliefs?
e. What if neither happens?
that is the advantage of knowing what you believe. There is persuasive evidence for resurrection and reincarnation falls apart at the seams when diagnosed. Reincarnation has its evil side and says the world will continue forever and ever with regurgitated souls in abundance, whereas resurrection is all good.
Yknow when we are born on this planet we have no idea of life in the womb, or that first six months. Everything is new to us and this is the state of resurrection, we are born new into a plane of existence we had not previously imagined, so there will not be any talk around the water cooler of our past life or longing to see dear ol cousin ed, our wives memories gone. But what we have in front of us is amazing and new
Sorry, that is false and we all know it is false, no need to lie about that.
Give evidence of falseness please. Back up your statement and then i will tell you that you ignore the power of God. Resurrection is of God seeing as God lives forever, suns exist for billions of years.. you believe in radio carbon dating so you know there is a very very very long time of possibilities. Ahh but you don't see it do you? Imagine walking your dog along a forest path and all of a sudden he rushes into the bushes and comes back with a dead bird in his mouth.. you had no idea the bird was there, but the dog did. You didn't see the bird did you? Your senses failed to acknowledge the dead bird. And so do my friend your senses fail you to see God.
have a nice day.
You don't give evidence of validity--just a claim that you a somehow wiser (i.e. the fallacy called "argument from authority").
You provide no evidence for resurrections. Everything we know does not support your claim at all. Even George Romero knows only to well the zombies in his movies are paid actors.
What power? The only power I see is the power of indoctrination.
Did the dog find God in the bush, too?
Points well taken, brotheryochanan and A Troubled Mind. It certainly is to one's advantage to being intimately aware of what you believe and to be able to consider all the ramifications, not just those surrounding the above scenario, to see if it is truly wise to continue following that line of thought.
I pose the question just to get people to think about what they believe. Sometimes, I think, it needs to be somewhat glaringly, maybe we could say, "odd?" to get a person to do so. I do not mean to be offensive in any way.
Questions are questions and deserve better response than a snipers shot while quickly driving by. There are so many differences between believers and non believers its like a and z. Often their arguments are weak and unsupported and unthoughtful and their best defense is God doesn't exist which is like saying to a mathematician quantum pi is fictional. So the debate goes on and on in this area and that.
Its all good to those with good intentions, but certain ones have crept in unawares.
The natural world is how it is, regardless of what a person believes.
True, I do not give evidence of validity. Many people do not have evidence of validity for what they believe, yet will live out their lives holding to such, and sometimes vehemently. So, given this in relationship to varying beliefs about what happens after death, my basic questions underlying the scenario set forth still remain: a. Is one's personal belief about life after death valid, b. can significantly divergent beliefs be simultaneously valid, and c. what happens to each individual after they die if beliefs are not simultaneously valid?
I believe it is important to get this sorted out sooner rather than later, thus I pose the question.
a. no way of knowing
b. no. One or none of the differing beliefs are correct. A belief does not change reality.
c. That will depend on which belief system is correct.
What a person believes about what happens after death is of no consequence. Whether there is life after death or not is unknown and unknowable; it will be whatever it will be regardless of how we believe.
I have my own thoughts on the matter, but, as I said, they are only conjecture from what I understand of the universe. Only time will tell what it really is.
I believe what you say is true about it not mattering what any individual believes, what really happens is what's going to happen. Some research, though, into the medical field even, will give you some clues about whether something happens after you die, or if it's just "The End." Maybe some day you'll think it's worth a little more research?
Those who are loving and caring will be resurrected to life eternal. Those who are selfish and evil cannot be used by the creator in the next life, as selfishness and evil are destructive to themselves and to the order of the universe. Their soul will die on judgment day (second death).
I might be wrong, but that's what Jesus said. I'd rather stick with Jesus than with any other man who's ever walked this earth. Never been much impressed with anyone else.
You want to know who is right without reference to evidence.
That pretty much leaves it to a) personal preference or b) whoever shouts the loudest.
by Author Nicole Canfield5 years ago
Do you believe in the Summerland or something similar such as Tir Na Nog or Heaven, etc.? Do you also believe in reincarnation or a recycling of energy? What do you, as a Pagan, believe in as far as life after death?...
by The Reluctant Revivalist4 months ago
Do you think there is life after death? Or do you think that once you die, that is the end of your existance?
by JonTutor7 years ago
IMO three theories....1) Christian/Moslem.... one life.... either Heaven granted by Jesus/Allah or condemned to hell.2) Budhist/Hindu.... reincarnation.... multiple lives before liberation.3) Atheists..... usually no...
by ArockDaNinja12 months ago
I've read about many different theories about death and what happens. It is the main question that is in the back of everyone's mind. It's very difficult to picture it or to question the point of existence. The fact...
by PhenomWriter5 years ago
Is this the only life we have been given? Or there is a soul that survives this body and goes elsewhere to any God? This is the small question I am having with my fellow human beings who are few in numbers...Image:...
by Grace Marguerite Williams3 months ago
Do you contend that the afterlife is actual or a fantastical idea propagated by religion in order to assuage people that there is something....better? To those who believe in the afterlife, do you strongly...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.