jump to last post 1-12 of 12 discussions (39 posts)

Does the Quran condemn violence and bloodletting?

  1. andrew savage profile image60
    andrew savageposted 3 years ago

    Can someone who has studied Islamic literature/scripture explain that killing people for having different religious view is not okay in the Quran?

    1. Marisa Wright profile image94
      Marisa Wrightposted 3 years ago in reply to this

      Surely the point is that the Old Testament of the bible is just as bloodthirsty.  God telling his people to commit genocide is fairly clear, IMO.  Pot calling the kettle black if you ask me.

  2. Monisa Ahmed profile image78
    Monisa Ahmedposted 3 years ago

    m.youtube.com/watch?v=kxaOvvXCdwo
    I hope this vedio answers your question. May God bless you.

  3. Monisa Ahmed profile image78
    Monisa Ahmedposted 3 years ago

    m.youtube.com/watch?v=D7gRIPj6rYs

    1. Mathew James profile image78
      Mathew Jamesposted 3 years ago in reply to this

      There are three basic battles that are recorded in the Glorious Qur'an.  They are similar in purpose to the ones recorded in the Torah.  The purpose of these battles whose to test the men of faith that were fighting in the cause of the Book, which is from the One and Only One.  He is our only Protector, Provider, Sustainer.  The battles that are recorded in the Book, (Torah, Gospel, Qur'an) ended when the Book was finished.  The Qur'an clearly states that we are to wait until the end and then the One and Only One shall show us our differences and why.

  4. amer786 profile image80
    amer786posted 3 years ago

    In the second chapter of The Holy Quran (Al-Baqara) verse 256 is one of the most well known and oft quoted which directly answers your question. Here is the verse . . .

    "There is no compulsion in religion. Verily, the right path has become distinct from the wrong path. Whoever disbelieves in transgression and believes in God, then he has grasped the most trustworthy handle that will never break. And God is All-Knowing, All-Hearing."

    Now it is important to note that some so-called Muslim scholars hold that certain verses of The Quran have abrogated earlier ones and they will post one that is in apparent contradiction. They also present The Sunnah (a body of work that encapsulates the practices of Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him) where he apparently (God forbid) put apostates and put infidels to death.

    We at The Ahmadiyya Movement in Islam (followers of The Messiah and Mahdi prophesized by Prophet Muhammad, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian) completely reject any Hadith (traditions and sayings of Prophet Muhammad peace be on him) or Sunnah that violates any injunction of The Quran. We also reject the concept of abrogation and believe that all verses of The Quran are held as Heavenly Law for all time to come in this world. God in the Quran in Chapter 15 verse 9 reveals that “Surely it is We who have revealed The Exposition (Quran), and surely it is We who are its guardians”. Any other body of work be it Hadith or Sunnah does not enjoy this divine protection.

    Therefore, the verse 2:256, in our belief is the tell-all and end-all regarding this matter. The verses of The Quran calling for battle and confrontation have their own context. A practical proof of this is the document that prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) delivered to the monks of St. Catherine’s monastery at Mt. Sinai known as ‘The Charter of Privileges’. In it, the Holy Prophet (peace be on him) forbids all Muslims till the Day of Judgment to attack any Church or Christian on the basis of their religion. I suggest you seek this document on internet and read it. This document is proof of the truth that Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) never violated any laws or injunctions in the verses of The Quran. If contradictions have followed in Hadith and Sunnah or scholars have made theories of abrogation, these must be rejected as innovations.

    God Bless

    1. A Troubled Man profile image61
      A Troubled Manposted 3 years ago in reply to this

      Sunnah or not, you should read about the Muslim Conquests in which Muslims spread Islam by the sword, murdering millions over centuries of conquering the known world.

      1. Mathew James profile image78
        Mathew Jamesposted 3 years ago in reply to this

        In alot of ways your comment "Sunnah or not" is at the root of this issue.   There are several sects of Islam that follow the Sunnah and Hadith as if the documents are Divine Guidence.  The sects that follow these documents are following the stories of what their forefathers have told them and many Muslims are being led astary into violent behaviors.   If people just read the Holy Qur'an without any outside influence, and then contemplate on what it says, that is the best.   The Qur'an is a clear message to all who drink from it freely.

        1. A Troubled Man profile image61
          A Troubled Manposted 3 years ago in reply to this

          Exactly, and it is a book of myths and superstitions for the Arab culture, filled with deceit and lies.

          1. Uninvited Writer profile image81
            Uninvited Writerposted 3 years ago in reply to this

            So, it's the same as the Bible smile

            1. A Troubled Man profile image61
              A Troubled Manposted 3 years ago in reply to this

              Only the names and places have been changed to protect the innocent... or was it the guilty?

            2. Taalib Pugh1 profile image79
              Taalib Pugh1posted 3 years ago in reply to this

              The Qur'an is not the same as the Bible it's the Last Revelations not the Gospels of Essa well known as Jesus.

        2. amer786 profile image80
          amer786posted 3 years ago in reply to this

          Matthew, you are spot-on. In verse 25:30 of The Glorious Quran is a great prophecy exactly regarding this . . .

          "O my Lord, my people indeed treated this Quran as a thing abandoned."

      2. Taalib Pugh1 profile image79
        Taalib Pugh1posted 3 years ago in reply to this

        Give us the proof of these conquest at least name one and give the proof of this conquest and the clear details explaining it being an Islamic conquest. Also give the source of proof.

        1. A Troubled Man profile image61
          A Troubled Manposted 3 years ago in reply to this

          How about an example that came to light only recently when Pope Francis canonized 800 Italians who were beheaded because they refused to convert to Islam, captured during a raid on Otranto in Puglia in southern Italy. Their skulls still line the walls of Otranto cathedral.

  5. Monisa Ahmed profile image78
    Monisa Ahmedposted 3 years ago

    Tel me Mathew, from your explanation it doesn't seem to me that you hate Islam. What do you think of believing in God?...

    1. Mathew James profile image78
      Mathew Jamesposted 3 years ago in reply to this

      Peace to you Monisa, my love is for all the Prophets, none above the other, Enoch, Noah, Abraham, Lot, Mosses, David, Solomon, Jesus, Muhammad.  There were many Prophets and Muhammad was the last Prophet.   The One and Only One, the Almighty Creator of ALL  has sent His message to every nation and the message is even written in our night sky.  Yes, the constellations repeat the same message as the Book.  However, most Muslims are taught to be afraid of the stars and never have the opportunity to learn the message written in the constellations.

      1. Taalib Pugh1 profile image79
        Taalib Pugh1posted 3 years ago in reply to this

        We don't need the constellations. He didn't send the constellations as revelation. ALLAAH sent The Qur'an. It is sufficient for mankind. This The Word of ALLAAH, Al Furqan (criterion for mankind) The Last Revelation.

        1. Mathew James profile image78
          Mathew Jamesposted 3 years ago in reply to this

          Read the Qur'an and seek the truth Taalib.  The Qur'an has many statements about the stars and the constellations.  Allah created the stars and gave the stars their names for a reason.  Very few people have spent the time to understand the message wriiten in the night sky, but the upright are commanded to watch the stars again and again.  I am amazed that Muslims do not know anything about the stars and yet if they learned the truth of what the constellations say, they would ponder the heavens many many times greater.  The signs in the night sky are for the upright to know and the constellations hold the Original Prophecy.

          1. Taalib Pugh1 profile image79
            Taalib Pugh1posted 3 years ago in reply to this

            Look Mathew this is not what the Prophet Muhammad taught that studying the stars was the way you can obtain the Prophecy (being revelation). The Qur'an is perfect it needs no assistance.

            1. Mathew James profile image78
              Mathew Jamesposted 3 years ago in reply to this

              yes the Qur'an needs no assistance it is a clear message from Allah,

              1. 0
                riddle666posted 3 years ago in reply to this

                Who told you?

            2. A Troubled Man profile image61
              A Troubled Manposted 3 years ago in reply to this

              No, it is not perfect, the table still wobbles. wink

  6. Monisa Ahmed profile image78
    Monisa Ahmedposted 3 years ago

    Are you a Muslim James?

  7. Monisa Ahmed profile image78
    Monisa Ahmedposted 3 years ago

    Are you a Muslim James?

    1. Mathew James profile image78
      Mathew Jamesposted 3 years ago in reply to this

      Yes, Islam is the right path.  There is One God and One God Alone and Muhammad was His Last Messeneger.

      1. Zelkiiro profile image84
        Zelkiiroposted 3 years ago in reply to this

        Just like the Christians believe Jesus to be the last prophet, and just like the Jews believe Isaiah(?) to be the last prophet.

        And just like the Sumerians believed rivers were made up of Enki's urine and that we were created by slave-driving aliens.

        1. Taalib Pugh1 profile image79
          Taalib Pugh1posted 3 years ago in reply to this

          Isaiah never said he was the last prophet, neither did Jesus, he said that a comforter (being another prophet) will come. But the prophet Muhammad may the peace and blessing be upon him stated Himself besides the people believing in him as the Last Messenger and Prophet of ALLAAH.

  8. Monisa Ahmed profile image78
    Monisa Ahmedposted 3 years ago

    Yes, I agree with you. I always wanted people to understand about Islam, It does not have any misconceptions as people say. It is a religion of greater understanding with reason and logic..why we have been given a task to accomplish and that we are not left alone in freedom. Allah knows all and hears everything. It is a religion of truth and total obedience and submission to Allah, most High and the most Compassionate.

    1. Mathew James profile image78
      Mathew Jamesposted 3 years ago in reply to this

      Allah is the Greatest !!!

      1. A Troubled Man profile image61
        A Troubled Manposted 3 years ago in reply to this

        The greatest what?

        We are told often enough from believers that it is inconceivable to compare us puny humans to Allah. Yet, you are doing that right now, by calling him "the Greatest!!!" because obviously, he can only be greater then us. smile

  9. Monisa Ahmed profile image78
    Monisa Ahmedposted 3 years ago

    It's only a test to pass to enter the Eternity...

  10. Monisa Ahmed profile image78
    Monisa Ahmedposted 3 years ago

    James, I recommend you to enrol in the Islamiconlineuniversity.com by Dr.Bilal Philips. InshAAllah , I see that you are a true believer. There are free courses to study and exams are given online. May Allah shower Blessings upon you. JazakAllah khairan!

    1. Mathew James profile image78
      Mathew Jamesposted 3 years ago in reply to this

      thanks Monisa, i will check it out.

  11. Monisa Ahmed profile image78
    Monisa Ahmedposted 3 years ago

    Amer786, what you say is correct , but I have a question here . We should never say that the Ahadith is totally a fabrication, we have the Sahih Ahadith related to Sahih al Bukhari and the Muslim that is totally authentic due to the commentaries in the Holy Quran. The Tawheed, which defines the uniqueness of the Almighty Allah and that it does says to be away from "the Shirk", that Allah alone is the Creator and the Sustainer and we do not give names and attributes of uniqueness, in lordship and in worship to anything besides Allah. Then we speak about peace , behavior, and total submission ( it is as if the soul of our body given to the Almighty), speaking refuge from the evil within yourself and so we bow to Allah in Repentance...No man is away from false, so it is a clear guidance to mankind.

    1. amer786 profile image80
      amer786posted 3 years ago in reply to this

      Monisa Ahmed, I am in total agreement. I never said Hadith is total fabrications. I only said that any Haidth or Sunnah that contradicts the Quran and cannot be reconciled in any acceptable form, only then it should be rejected as innovation or fabrication. What is important to note is that throughout history religion has been unduly leveraged to back someone’s politics. This happens a lot today especially in the Islamic world. And there is a strong possibility that many such Hadith were doctored or misinterpreted for political power and even to craft divisions and sectarianism in Islam.

      I am in fact a big student of Hadith. There are many that agree with and even expand on the teachings of The Holy Quran. The wide body of Islamic Eschatology which we see materialize before our eyes is in fact contained in the Hadith. Also, like you mention the Sahih Muslim, Sahih Bukhari and Saha Sitha (the Six authentic works) are good systems for Hadith validation. But please remember, these are still human endeavors and cannot be held in divine authority. The Holy Quran is the final word, true and divine. Allah Almighty has accorded us an inestimable favor by securing its text which remains unaltered down the letter for over 1,400 years. In return, we should never do, say, or accept anything from outside it that compromises its teachings and the great ‘Seal of the Prophets’ Muhammad (peace be upon him) who was the medium for its dispensation to humanity.

      Peace be with you and God Almighty Guide you.

      1. A Troubled Man profile image61
        A Troubled Manposted 3 years ago in reply to this

        That is what many consider the Quran, a fabrication of Muhammad, hence it is rejected.



        No, it is the words of Muhammad and nothing more.

  12. Monisa Ahmed profile image78
    Monisa Ahmedposted 3 years ago

    Amer786, I Agree with all your words...MashaAllah, you have a lot of knowledge about Islam. You are right if you say that we have to leave the Ahadith if it contradicts with the Al Quran. Do you have a Degree in Islamic Teachings Amer?

    1. amer786 profile image80
      amer786posted 3 years ago in reply to this

      Monisa, thank you for the kind words, I am not deserving. I am certainly no scholar, perhaps an aspiring seeker of Truth. Much of my knowledge comes for an intense two-year study conducted before joining The Ahmadiyya Muslim Community—since this was a big step and in fact against the advice of most Muslim scholars. Generally, I am weary of scholarship in religion. I think a lot of corruption in religion occurs at the hands of scholars. It is so-called scholars who lead ignorant Muslims into acts of terror and ungodly horror. Still, I am sure there are good scholars and saints too. In a famous Hadith the Prophet Muhammd (pbuh) called the so-called Muslim scholars of the latter-days as ‘the worst of creatures under the firmament ’. When we hear of these so-called Imams who exploit a young and tender mind with promises of Paradise and then ask them to go and kill indiscriminately in the cause of God and religion, has this prophecy not come true in our time? I believe so.

 
working