Nice story, but I don't see how God needed a sacrifice.
It is a long story. The short version is this. God loves you so much that He gave the best to die for your sins. The wages of sin is death. Jesus took your punishment upon His back so that you might live.
Why is the wage of sin death? Perhaps God likes us to sacrifice things to show him we love him like a seriously sadistic old man, but we or he made no sacrifice because he is still there. No one in your story lost anything. A sacrifice is when we give up something for someone else. That was not done, nothing was given up.
God created man to live forever, (in His image and likeness). Adam had one commandment. Do not eat of the fruit of the tree of knowledge of good and evil. God told him in the day that you do it, you will surely die. This is the first time death is mentioned in the Bible.
Man had the ability to go anywhere and do anything. Nothing harmed him nor did he have any boundaries, except that one commandment. As soon as Adam ate that fruit, death was pronounced upon all mankind. The stench of sin would be with men at all times. For this reason, Jesus took the wages that are due us for our sins, which is death.
The man could have saved his beloved and precious son. He chose not to even knowing that those on the train had no clue as to what was going on.
My punishment? What did I ever do to deserve punishment such that someone else had to die? Obviously, there is some great mistake here.
You do know that one day you will die.? Jesus took the, (your), punishment of death so that you might have life.
Not according to the Christian mythology; all that dies is the shell temporarily housing us. The real "us" continues on for eternity, either burning or in heaven.
Revelation mentions the second death.
Rev_2:11 He that hath an ear, let him hear what the Spirit saith unto the churches; He that overcometh shall not be hurt of the second death.
But does not indicate what is meant by the term; certainly it has no meaning in English unless there are two entities involved.
It is written what is meant by it.
Rev_21:8 But the fearful, and unbelieving, and the abominable, and murderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all liars, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone: which is the second death.
It (the second death) is a rather scary concept. Can some souls become so bad, say Hitler… that they slip out of existence even on a spiritual level (somehow) permanently????
An omnipotent god does not need a sacrifice (or anything but a figurative snap of it's fingers) to accomplish it's goals. Either the Christian god has lied to mankind or it's all a made up story.
I'll give you that it was an artful depiction of that analogy. Unfortunately I have always disliked it because it paints such a different picture than the gospel. A train full of innocents being spared from a mistake by a switch-master who allowed his son to be placed in peril, quite by accident and a son wanting to save them, but only exchanging his life for theirs because he slipped...those are but a few of the problems. The closer you look the more the analogy falls apart, giving a false picture of the gospel message. We agree on most things but I must part with you on this one.
Let's stick with this, as here we can agree:
You God needs something to die. Like Sir Dent you are not getting it. You are clearly closer, I'll give you that but you still seem to think God made a sacrifice for us.
You are reading more into it than I did. The father had the option to save his son or save those on the train. God could have at any time saved Jesus from the cross but He didn't because it would have meant that no man would be saved.
It's no big deal to disagree on things at times. We all do it.
Had the passengers been informed that they had a choice: Be saved/no... many would have opted to live...
Faith is the one thing that stands in the way.
I wonder why God made faith the key. He knows that most of us want to see before we believe... He is not even saying things we "like" as flesh. So many more would believe if he proved himself first. It really makes me ponder what he is thinking behind what i already know, "You must first believe that he is, and will reward you when you seek him."
by frantisek782 years ago
We are often told that we will meet our dead friends and family in Heaven and we'll all be happy. Will we also meet our old enemies in Heaven as well, or do they go somewhere else like into their own Heaven with their...
by haj33965 years ago
NO!!!!!!!!! Revelation 20:14And death and hell were cast into the lake of fire. This is the second death. done let religion make you run from God. God is real and the devil is real. All of these wrong at that you see...
by Slarty O'Brian5 years ago
Is it moral to profit from the murder of an innocent man? If you accept that the person is murdered to give you everlasting life aren’t you just as guilty of the crime? If a man said to his son, let them murder...
by Jeromeo6 years ago
No not everyone goes to heaven when he or she dies.Jn 18:36 Jesus said, "My kingdom is not of this world . . . this realm" Jn V3 I will come and receive you that where I am YOU may be also Its your home and...
by Matthew Kirk3 years ago
This is a genuine question;I would like to know the mechanics of how a man being killed by a group of Romans washes away sins?I don't want to be preached to, I would like a 'rational' answer / explanation if one can be...
by garrettdixon4 years ago
Can anyone tell me a reason not to believe in capital punishment?
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.