Which part do christians believe go to hell/heaven? The soul or spirit? Or bit of both? There seems to be disagreement about definition of soul and spirit. Definition of soul sounds same as neurological output (feelings/cognition/personality etc)
Some christians define the soul as being the same as character/morals.
Some say the soul departs. Some say the soul dies with the body (so wasn't really separate entity?)
If only the spirit endures, but not the soul then how does one feel emotions (eg like pain in hell or euphoria in heaven)
Finally, is there any evidence that a soul and spirit exists? We have already had the subjective experiences of near-death-experiences presented. Anything else more concrete?
The problem is that believers have not really defined the "soul" so they have no idea what they're actually talking about. If they define it as feelings/cognition/personality, then we can easily offer the case of the one who has lost those characteristics as a result of brain damage. What then?
how does brain damage obliterate the soul? Its still in there just the husk is not working..
So people in wheelchairs as quadriplegics have no soul?
Who said anything about quadriplegics? Funny how believers either have reading comprehension problems or love to put words in other peoples mouths.
"Just the husk is not working"
LMAO! Very funny stuff!
k how does one lose feelings/cognition/personality.
according to what you wrote. Do they have brain damage and appear normal. Are you talking about alzheimerz?
The problem is you don't really know what you are talking about and when i try to decipher your vague quasi-sentence, you switch streams just to keep your argumentative flair goin on and become insulting with some barbaric generalization about all believers which has just about the same amount of common sense as your ridiculous posts that you blindly say make sense.
Very funny stuff, indeed.
You failed so miserably on the disney and starving scenario and yet you try again with another vague sentence. What prompted you to use the einstein icon? Irony maybe? ego? pride? certainly not accuracy.
So sorry that you're having reading comprehension issues.
Of course, that is what all believers believe, as their god continues to ignore the starving and sends kids to Disneyland. Why should the believers care about the starving when their prayers for trips to Disneyland are answered?
Ah yes, the typical offering of personal insults in light of forming an intelligent argument.
You've already done a topic on this
why start another one with virtually the same query?
Forget the soul let's move to the feet.
Are feet just our imagination walking around our soul?
No, I want to know more about the distinction they make with spirit (and define it better).
Speaking of feet - amputating limbs doesn't mean anything has changed about the "soul" - it's not like a bit of soul dies with the detached body part? Or do some think otherwise - is that why some bury the placenta?
I'm working on a hub about death - hence the many questions
'working on a hub about death'??
remind me to invite you to a party!
What about if the soul is in your leg and that leg is amputated
wouldn't that 'defeet' the objective?
joez badtoez more like bad breath,and quit flipin' them skevies,boy changum at least onced a week,puuuweee,joe good god amighty,straigten up an fly right badtoe head else i'll have 2 put a prune over yer eye not a bad idea anyhoo quit aggravaton that girl.
well billy beer i'll see ifen i ken help ya out now like my ol' granpappy used 2 say( let me sifer this fer ya )as god iz tri uin so iz we theirz the father,the son,and the holy ghost(spirit)we ain't quite the same as god,the creature will near be the same as the creator,anyhoo you got yer flesh an blood vehicale the spirit rides around in, savy?the soul comunicates betwix the 2 don't ya see,now don.t listen 2 ol sour faced bettlejuice r beelzebub r his bunk buddy alternater pot cauze 1za chowder head senic and the tutherz a devil,when the body gives up the spirit(or the ghost)the spirit goez into itz reward(heaven we hope)the body and soul go back to the clay whooweee.the spirit of the lord waz wif me taday.hope that helped little fuller.ol goober
Actually, all three!
you failed to include the body.
There is a thing called the resurrection of the dead.
The dead "in Christ" have a body like His, post-resurrection, and the "others" will be cast into the Laker of Fire.
Just a "minor" technicality.
I believe that the soul is the character, personnality, emotions, will, memories, in fact everthing that you are and it resides in the brain. When you die, your brain dies, so does your soul.
Your spirit does not exist. It's a mythical pagan idea adopted by the Catholic church and perpetuated in order to keep the fear of hell burning.
All people good and bad who died I suspect are still in their graves and will remain so until a resurection.
auh shudup an disarear head u are so far off u dumb hill billy i thank ur already brain dead u stink.
that's what I'm starting to make of it too disappearinghead
"God is a spirit, and those who worship him must do so in spirit and in truth." If the spirit doesn't exist, then God doesn't exist. Didn't God say in the beginning, "let us make man in our image?" The truth is, the spirit does exist, and is at war with the flesh, if you're a believing Christian. The flesh wars against the spirit, and the spirit wars against the flesh.
Being made in God's image does not mean we are also spirit. A photo of a person is an image but that photo is not flesh and blood is it. We are made of flesh and that alone and we will die.
If we had an intelligent immortal spirit then why do people often suffer personnality changes resulting from brain damage? Why are people unconcious when in a coma? Why arn't those with neurological conditions not Einsteins? In short why does this spirit not take over our cogniative functions? Amswer. It does not exist and we live in the brain.
The spirit of a man in scripture is a metaphorical term used when attempting to discuss that part of our minds tuned into God.
The bible explains nothing. It only makes up stuff. Get real.
that post explains nothing, It only just made something up.
Still no rebuttal, huh? Sadly, absurd.
Why don't you use your bible to rebuke my statement?
Oh, I forgot, the bible was written by primitive charlatans from long ago, who knew very little compared to the scientific minds of today.
When you argue for nonsense, you just look absurd.
by ptosis16 months ago
The soul, by definition, is meta-physical and is thought that the soul would be connected to the brain, not within the brain.It used to be thought that the soul resided in your heart - but getting a heart transplant...
by cooldad5 years ago
I'm an atheist, but I've always thought that the Bible adamantly condemns homosexuality. Do homosexuals have any chance of getting into heaven? This has always confused me. In God's eyes, is being homosexual any more...
by Emma5 years ago
I would really like to know if Muslims and Budhist people go to heaven because since Christianity says that one can't go to Heaven unless they believe in Jesus. I have a Muslim and a Budhist friend and these guys are...
by awesome775 years ago
I have observed how we humans are consumed by our desire to go to heaven when we die! No wonder we have feel good preachers and political leaches who prey on peoples ignorance!How can you believe a theory that has never...
by Link101032 years ago
Do you agree with this? It seems to me that some of the holier than thou christians on this site legitimately believe with all their heart that those who do not believe in their god will have special front row tickets...
by glendoncaba7 years ago
Just posting these three summary doctrines here for those who wish to know the historicist view on the above-mentioned topic. This is placed here especially for community participants who have repeatedly assumed...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.