recently saw video on you tube where sam harris said that moses,abhraham,jesus ,muhammad knew next to nothing and dumb people...what are your views on this?
What else youd expect from the dumb?
If he understood anything at all he would know not to call them dumb...or as a matter of fact noone
Harris was describing a lack of knowledge or education, which has nothing to do with being dumb.
Here is what Harris actually said:
"All of our scriptures were written by people who, by virtue of their placement in history, had less access to scientific knowledge and what is now basic common sense than any person in this room. In fact, there is not a person in this room who has ever met a person whose worldview is as narrow as the worldview of Abraham or Moses, or Jesus or Muhammad. These people knew nothing -- next to nothing -- of the facts that are now relevant to us, in the 21st century. They knew nothing about the origins of life, or the relationship between mind and brain. They didn't know that mental illness was even a category of human suffering. They knew nothing about DNA or viruses, or computation or electricity. None of this is in scripture. They had no idea why people got sick and died. Unless you saw someone stabbed with a spear, you had no idea why they died."
Here is a link to the YouTube video so that you can watch it for yourself:
I trust you mean, Sam Harris the author of "End of faith"
Moses was raised in the house of Pharoah. He knew how to read and write, and many other things which the Egyptians of his day knew. I wouldn't say he was dumb...although he did have a speech impediment. Jesus was raised by a carpenter, which suggests a level of education equal to that profession in that day and age. Indications are that he could also read and write, though no real evidence can be shown....just logically speaking. Abraham? For his day and in that world, he may have been sharp as a tack. His neighborhood is the home turf of the oldest strain of domestic wheat on the planet, and a few hours away is the mysteriously hidden lost complex of Gobekli Tepe.
I don't know if I agree with that. It depends on how you define dumb. Abraham was ancient, even in ancient terms. He probably couldn't count higher than the digits on his hands....but by the standards of the time he was probably as educated as the next guy.
Moses was raised in the royal house of Egypt. So he was probably well educated. Now, you could argue he lost IQ points when he saw the burning bush....but we can't know that for sure. He was obviously goood at organizing. He led a people out of Egypt and around the desert for forty years. So, I'd say Sam is wrong on that count
Jesus, as the son of a common laborer obviously didn't have a formal education. But a lack of education doesn't make someone dumb. He was obviously insightful enough to impress others with his words.
Mohamed...I don't know a lot about him, but you can't accomplish the things in life he did without a savvy brain.
I think Sam Harris might be an arrogant elitist. A lack of formal education doesn't make people dumb.
Any person living thousands of years ago would be dumb by our standards today.
We will be considered irredeemably stupid by our descendants, too.
That last sentence actually just motivated me to do my homework. I don't want my future kids to think I'm dumb! But maybe it's a lost cause already...
Your kids won't, but your great-great-....-great-grandchildren?
I'm sure I'll be considered a knuckle-dragger by my distant descendants, and I kind of hope I will be. If they haven't made any progress since my generation, that'll be a bad thing.
by Religulous6 years ago
I was just reading that the Koran refers to Abraham as being the first Muslim. Is that correct?
by paarsurrey6 years ago
Hi friendsJesus and Moses are to be believed and respected only as an academic value.The original text of the Bible OT and NT having been lost in the original language; their true meanings also lost in the translations....
by Ron Hooft6 years ago
1. God told Moses to sacrifice the first born of humans and animals to him. 1The Lord said to Moses:2Consecrate to me all the firstborn; whatever is the first to open the womb among the Israelites, of human beings and...
by Ahmad Usman3 years ago
===> Saint Barnabas & the Bible:Among the disciples of Jesus, Barnabas was a dynamic evangelist. He was a Jew from the tribe of Levite and was one of the earliest Christian disciples and convert to Christianity...
by davidkaluge5 years ago
I want to know the tribe of Muhammed. A senior friend said he is a Jew. He also told me about a book written by a Germany, Fredrick N. which explained the history of Egypt Pharaohs and Moses. If Muhammed is a Jew why is...
by Amani Placide7 years ago
Biblically and theologically, what can be said about the black church can also be said about the vision of its religious leadership. The black community’s most effective leaders have been nurtured in the...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.