Definition, Etymology and Effectiveness of the Haymaker Punch

The stereotype of the Haymaker Punch is that it is used by country folk in the American backwoods in down-and-dirty brawls. It's not considered a sophisticated technique but, depending on who you talk to, it is sometimes considered effective. By some, it's considered ineffective, for various logical and very sound reasons. I suppose the jury is out, because the punch is still used in various forms, on the street, maybe at the barn and even in professional competitions (more on this later).

What is the Haymaker Punch, where does the term come from and is it effective? Let's find out.


What Is It?

A Haymaker Punch is a wide-swinging blow that generates tremendous power because of the travel and, therefore, momentum that it possesses. Being a wide swing, it can be easily detected by the perceptive, well-trained and experienced opponent. The power of the punch is derived from the shoulder muscles and body weight; it is a torque technique. Because it has tremendous power, if it connects it almost always assures a knockout; or, at least, significant damage and "destabilization". The opponent is certain to be at least stunned by this punch.

Because the blow packs so much power, some people use it to end a fight as quickly as possible. In spite of its lack of finesse and efficiency, if it lands it could very well end a fight on the spot.

Comparison of the sickle and the scythe.
Comparison of the sickle and the scythe. | Source

Origin of the Term

It is generally accepted that the origin of the term is derived from the wide sweeping motion made with a tool called a scythe for chopping down hay and other crops on a farm. The Scythe is a long curved blade attached to a handle, similar to a sickle but larger.

This etymology makes sense because of the general notion that the punch is used by tough farm boys in the country; also, the movement of using the scythe to chop down hay is very similar to the punch. I suppose country folk get a lot of practice with that motion and it's burned into their muscles.

There is another theory, not at all well-substantiated, that the term comes from a rather desperate boxer known as Gene "Lights Out" Hamaker. He supposedly was a Swedish immigrant who was in dire straits, in early 20th Century America, and took to prize fighting to support himself. The story goes that he knocked an opponent out and the referee, mispronuncing his name, shouted out "Haymaker!" as the winner of the bout. There is not much to support this claim or that the fighter even existed. It is interesting to note there have been a few boxers with the nickname "Lights Out", so this lends even more validity to the claim that this origin story is fictitious. Kind of sounds like to me that someone pieced together a few facts to make up a fake story about the origin of the Haymaker.

Depiction of the use of the scythe to cut down hay.
Depiction of the use of the scythe to cut down hay. | Source

Do you think the Haymaker is an effective punch?

See results without voting

Is It Effective?

The Haymaker can be effective for one main obvious reason: It's powerful. It's a knockout punch if it lands on the temple or jaw. Somewhat of a form of it has been used by professional fighter, UFC and MMA competitor, Chuck Liddell. Chuck is famous for knocking out opponents with wide hooks and looping overhand punches. But it should be said that he does not come out of the corner with wild swinging punches. He sets up the heavy shot and uses obscure, hard to detect angles. Chuck is a smart fighter but he knows power is necessary to score a win. He often goes for the power punches to end fights quickly.

While a very skilled fighter can pull off a wide swinging punch and knock out an opponent with it, it is a dangerous punch to use. You leave yourself wide open for a counter and you are telegraphing your movement. Telegraphing means the opponent sees the attack coming. Generally, in the striking arts, students are taught to use economical motion, meaning you only move enough to get the job done and still in a way that your technique is effective. This means you do not use unnecessary, and big, motion but still use proper angle and use enough travel to have power behind the attack. Essentially, the Haymaker goes against the rules of good, effective and efficient fighting. You are partly relying on luck if you use it. Very skilled fighters will see it coming and you're liable to find yourself at the bad end of the deal.

Liddell Teaching His Overhand Right

It's important to understand that fighters like Liddell who use some wide swinging punches, have exceptional timing and use many other weapons in their arsenal. Chuck uses a swinging overhand punch but places it effectively, at an obscure angle, at the right time, set up by other moves.

Generally it is still true that you don't want to use what might be effective. You want to use something that protects you and is most efficient and hard to see coming. This is why fighters in striking arts are usually taught to cover themselves, not to leave themselves open and to make their punches and strikes undetectable and efficient in terms of movement. However, everyone knows that power is important; and this is why some people will use the Haymaker. It is all about power.

Liddell on Making his Power Punches a Bit "Long"

More by this Author

  • Martial Arts Mathematics

    Here we explore the use of math in martial arts: Geometry and use of angles and shapes such as circles and triangles for movement and footwork, and physics for movement, power and energy.

  • US Presidents Who Practiced Martial Arts

    I think it goes without saying that our Founding Fathers were all for fighting for your rights and standing up to bullies. After all, they went up against an empire to secure their own rights and the rights of...

  • Why Do I Keep Dropping Things?

    It might be that you find yourself dropping things without, seemingly, any reason. The objects you are dropping might not even be heavy or in any way difficult to handle: You pull a fork out of the drawer and it...


NateB11 profile image

NateB11 2 years ago from California, United States of America Author

That is definitely very funny, tirelesstraveler. I'm glad you liked the article and glad you stopped by. Thanks!

tirelesstraveler profile image

tirelesstraveler 2 years ago from California

Hope you are ready for a laugh; I thought this was a recipe from the title. Moonshine of some sort?

.Very glad the title drew me into the story. Worthwhile read. History of anything is worth reading.

NateB11 profile image

NateB11 2 years ago from California, United States of America Author

No problem, Rachael. I think the origin of words is a fascinating subject. Glad you stopped by.

RachaelOhalloran profile image

RachaelOhalloran 2 years ago from United States

It is interesting how some things get their names. Thanks for the interesting lesson.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.

    Click to Rate This Article