Best Arguments In Baseball History

The Most Memorable Sports Arguments
The Most Memorable Sports Arguments

I Respectfully Disagree

Every sport has rules and those rules are enforced by objective referees, umpires and judges. During every game and match, someone disagrees with a call made by these objective observers. Sometimes these arguments become legendary. The following is a short list of the best arguments in Sports History.

Upon Hearing That His Home Run Was Taken Back George Brett Respectfully Voiced His Objection
Upon Hearing That His Home Run Was Taken Back George Brett Respectfully Voiced His Objection

The George Brett Pine Tar Incident

On July 24, 1983, The New York Yankees were playing the Kansas City Royals at Yankee Stadium. The Yankees were leading 4-3 in the ninth inning with the future Hall of Fame Reliever Goose Gossage on the mound. There was a runner on base with two outs and Royal Third Baseman George Brett at the plate. George Brett hit a home run out to right field and gave the Royals the lead.

However, Yankee manager Billy Martin had other ideas. Martin went up the Umpire, Tim McClelland, and argued that Brett's baseball bat had an illegal amount of Pine Tar on it. Pine Tar is used by players to get a good grip on the bat. McClelland measured the amount of pine tar on the bat and agreed that there was too much Pine Tar.

McClelland then turned towards the Royals dugout and signaled that George Brett was out and the home run was scratched from the books. Brett ran out of the dugout shouting and screaming at McClelland like a mad man. The other umpires had to hold him back.

Brett was of course kicked out of the game. Four days later the American League decided that the game should not be decided by such an obscure rule. The Yankees protested and even took the matter to Court, but eventually the home run was allowed and the game was finished on August 18. The Royals finally won the game 25 days after it began.

Phillip Wellman Would Not Take The Umpire's Call Standing Up
Phillip Wellman Would Not Take The Umpire's Call Standing Up

Fire In The Hole

On June 1, 2007, the Mississippi Braves were playing the Chattanooga Lookouts in a minor league baseball game. In the middle of the game, the Braves' pitcher was ejected from the game for using what the umpire believed was a foreign substance. Braves' manager, Phillip Wellman expressed his disagreement with the call.

Wellman used a different style of arguing style to make his point. After his pitcher was ejected, Wellman stormed the field shouting at the umpire. He then covered home plate with dirt, yanked third base out of the ground and tossed it off the field. Not done, Wellman then crawled, military style, over to the pitcher's mound where he began throwing a mock grenade, in this case a rosin bag, at the umpires hitting one in the foot. Wellman finally left the field blowing kisses to the crown and taking a bow.

Wellman served a short suspension for his tantrum but remained manager of the Braves.

Earl Weaver Was Never Afraid To Share His Opinion
Earl Weaver Was Never Afraid To Share His Opinion

No Reading Material Please

Earl Weaver was the undisputed King of managerial run ins with Umpires.  Weaver was kicked out of more games than any other American League Manager.  The most famous of his run ins was when after being ejected from a game Weaver told the umpire he was going to check the rule book.  The umpire offered his copy of the rule book Weaver answered that the Umpire's rulebook was no good because Weaver "can't read Braille." 

Sweet Lou May Act Crazy But There Is A Method To His Madness
Sweet Lou May Act Crazy But There Is A Method To His Madness

Sweet Lou

Lou Piniella has been a Manager in the major leagues for decades and is best known for his antics getting thrown out of games. During his time, Piniella has thrown bases all over the field, kicked his hat across the field and kicked dirt on numerous umpires.

Yet, Piniella is not just some crazed lunatic. Sometimes, there is a method to his madness. Piniella was hired as the Cubs manager before the 2007 season. The Cubs did not get off to a great start. On June 2, 2007, the Cubs were nine games under 500 and playing the Atlanta Braves. Angel Pagen was called out at third trying to advance on a wild pitch. Piniella came out to argue the call, threw down his cap, kicked dirt on the third base umpire, and kicked his cap around the field. The crowd cheered and chanted "Lou "Lou."

What is amazing is that Piniella after the game admitted the umpire got the call right. During that press conference, Piniella hinted that he got himself kicked out on purpose to fire up his team. The Cubs after this went on a roll and ended up winning the National League Central Division.

More by this Author

  • Famous Mistakes In Baseball History
    46

    Baseball has a long and rich history. From Babe Ruth, Mickey Mantle, Pete Rose through today, Baseball is rich in tradition and nostalgia. With this long history comes a rich tradition of horrible mistakes that have...

  • The NBA Slam Dunk Contest
    22

    The NBA Slam Dunk Contest is an annual competition held during NBA All Star Weekend where the best dunkers in the league are chosen to show off their talents. The contest did not start in the NBA however, as it...

  • The Story Of Tellico Dam And The Snail Darter
    20

    The Snail Darter is a tiny little fish that is native to the waters of Tennessee. In 1975, the Snail Darter was placed on the newly created Endangered Species List. In 1984, its status was lowered to threatened. Even...


Comments 6 comments

James A Watkins profile image

James A Watkins 7 years ago from Chicago

Good stuff, man. I am always up for a good read about baseball and you have a good angle here. I am a Cub fan so I have gotten to know Lou pretty well and I love him.


bgpappa profile image

bgpappa 7 years ago from Sacramento, California Author

Thanks James.

Lou is classic and a good manager. Only if his players would start hitting this year.


James A Watkins profile image

James A Watkins 7 years ago from Chicago

A couple of them are over .250!


bgpappa profile image

bgpappa 7 years ago from Sacramento, California Author

That is a start.


twinkiesfan3 profile image

twinkiesfan3 7 years ago from Texas

Nice Hub. I really like #2 with the minor league manager. That was hilarious. I have some sports hubs also. You schould check them out!


bgpappa profile image

bgpappa 7 years ago from Sacramento, California Author

Thanks for reading

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working