No Gay Boys for the Boy Scouts of America

Cub Scouts
Cub Scouts
Boy Scouts
Boy Scouts

A long time ago, I was in the Cub Scouts. Our Cub master was a guy in the Navy and the leader of our troop of boys of about 12. He was very nice, had a flat top haircut, but, a little too nice with us. Nothing happened and he was very knowledgeable with knots, which was a requirement for a Wolf badge. Even at that young age of seven, I sensed he was different. Not sure what it was, maybe he was a bit too touchy and nice, plus, his voice was not deep. Then, during a camping trip, one of the older boys said he was "queer", another said, "homo". That was the first time I had heard those words. I had to ask my older brother what they meant. Even after he explained it, I didn't really understand. Our cub scout leader was eventually replaced.

Today, things remain the same in the Boy Scouts, an organization that helps develops morally correct young men. The organization, after a two year study, remains anti-gay and excludes any gay boys. The main reason cited is that this is what the parents wanted to organization to do. Their decision is fully supported by the U.S. Supreme Court because it is a private organization. The gay organizations indicated that the Boy Scouts teach division and intolerance of others. The Girl Scouts of America has taken the opposite position- they accept gay girls.

How do you feel?

Should a private organization have the right to exclude a group on sexual orientation? Do gay scout leaders push their own "gay" issues on impressionable young kids? Are they able to actually present an unbiased approach? Does allowing gay kids into scouting open the door for intolerance from others? Could gay scout leaders also be pedophiles in hiding? Is intolerance always a bad thing?

There are million issues and reasons both sides could claim to this issue. Most are legitimate concerns from both groups. Parents have their own rights to raise their kids under their beliefs. The Boy Scouts of America have theirs as well.

Maybe it would be easier just to have a Gay Scout organization. They already have Gay communities and retirement homes. Each to their own. One does not have to accept every lifestyle on the planet. A private organization should have a right to exclude whomever they want. Those who are excluded have a right to call them racists or whatever.

Do you think gay boys should be in the Boy Scouts?

See results without voting

More by this Author


Comments 6 comments

Attikos profile image

Attikos 4 years ago from East Cackalacky

There's no legitimate question they have a right to do it. They do. The rest is politics.

There's also no reason to doubt their explanation of the decision. Most parents would pull their boys out of the organization were it officially to accept gays either as leaders or members. Some people won't want to accept that as fact, but the Scouts are in the best position to know, and that's what they have concluded. It shouldn't come as a surprise. Social mores haven't changed to the extent some wish. Denying it is just another exercise in politics, with a strong admixture of ideological projection.


perrya profile image

perrya 4 years ago Author

I agree. They do have the right.


Jade0215 4 years ago

I honestly don't think they should have the right to exclude anyone unless something happens that would require action to be taken. They're still people, that doesn't change anything. People shouldn't be segregated because they're gay, what their race is, how old they are, etc... This is just another form of racism. I'm sure if someone was kicked out because they were African American, people would be throwing a huge fit about it. There's no difference, gay people exist and everyone needs to get over it, they're going to be that way no matter how much some of us disapprove.


Attikos profile image

Attikos 4 years ago from East Cackalacky

There is no right of free association among people in private life? Are you sure about that?


perrya profile image

perrya 4 years ago Author

I tend to agree with Attikos, most parents, even if tolerant, would be apprehensive about their kids being led by a gay person. In the back of their mind gay = pedophile. Sandusky certainly made it much worse. People do have a right to protect their kids.


Ralph Deeds profile image

Ralph Deeds 3 years ago

Like the Army, gays have been in the Boy Scouts from the beginning. Soon they may have an opportunity to join the Scouts without hiding the fact that they are gay.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working