Why the Boston Red Sox Will Not Win the AL East in 2011

Major free agent pickups will not be enough

The Red Sox were one of the biggest players in the offseason battle over star free agents. They looked especially victorious considering how little their rival Yankees managed to do, which is the first time in a decade the Yankees haven't made any major free agent signings in an offseason. Let's take a look at who the Red Sox picked up and how it will help them improve on their third place finish from last season:

Adrian Gonzalez - The Red Sox signed him away from the Padres, where Gonzalez averaged about 35 home runs and 100 RBI a season while also earning Gold Gloves at first base. This was especially impressive considering how massive the Padres home park is and how hard it is to hit home runs there. Gonzalez's wins above replacement for the past two seasons was 7.0 and 6.3, which is MVP territory. The general consensus is that he'll do even better in Boston, as Fenway Park is more favorable to him and he'll have a better lineup around him, including Jacoby Ellsbury, Carl Crawford, and Kevin Youkilis hitting in front of him and David Ortiz hitting after him. That should provide a lot of RBI opportunities.

Carl Crawford - Crawford is a multi-tool player. Last season he had a career best 19 home runs and led the American League with 13 triples. Expect him to hit more triples thanks to Fenway's quirky dimensions. Crawford also won a Gold Glove last season. One of the overlooked benefits of the Crawford signing is that the Red Sox will no longer have to face him. He has destroyed the Red Sox on the basepaths, stealing 26 bases against them just in games at Fenway Park. In fact, Crawford has only been caught stealing once in his career at Fenway!

What the Red Sox lost

The Red Sox did not re-sign third baseman Adrian Beltre. This was expected, as the Gonzalez signing moves Kevin Youkilis over to third base and there was no longer room to play Beltre, but his bat will be missed in the Red Sox lineup. People may not have recognized it, but he was one of the top 5 most valuable players in the American League last season. He hit .321 with 28 home runs and 49 doubles, and he was an above average fielder.

If Adrian Gonzalez has the huge season people are expecting of him, he'll just manage to cover the loss of Adrian Beltre.  

Why Carl Crawford is Overrated

Carl Crawford is one of those guys who people think is great because he appears to be good at all facets of the game. The truth is, he's got some major faults. For one, he doesn't get on base nearly enough. His career on base percentage of .337 is terrible for anyone who doesn't hit 45 home runs a year. His best skill is his speed, but he's got to get on base to use it. He's a great player, but he isn't worth what the Red Sox are paying him. 

Red Sox pitching - a bunch of has-beens?

The Red Sox starting rotation includes Jon Lester, the ace. He's solid, and I expect big things from him this year.

#2 is John Lackey. He's overrated. He used to be an ace, but only on teams that didn't have a real ace. He's never been a great pitcher, despite the hype.

#3 is Clay Buchholz. He's good enough to be an ace on some teams.

#4 is Josh Beckett. He was a great pitcher... about 7 years ago. He's been inconsistent and battle injuries in recent years. Don't expect him to do much better than .500 pitching this season.

Dice-K was dominant for a season or two, and since then he's been consistently inconsistent. Remind you of anyone? Oh right, every single Japanese starting pitcher who has ever played in the major leagues. I guess hitters just get used to the wacky windups after a while.

Daniel Bard is the best guy we've got in the bullpen and he's entering the prime of his career. 

Jonathan Papelbon was better than Mariano Rivera for about a 4 year stretch. That's saying a lot. Unfortunately, he started to really flake out last season. I wouldn't be surprised if he isn't the Red Sox closer by the end of this season.  

Who will win the AL East?

I hate to say it, but the Yankees are going to win the division this year. They are looking more and more like that rag tag bunch that dominated in the late-1990's. The back end of their pitching rotation is suspect, but they make up for it with good fielding (with the exception of Derek Jeter, who has zero range) and a lineup that is an excellent mix of speed and power.  

More by this Author


Comments 6 comments

wavegirl22 profile image

wavegirl22 5 years ago from New York, NY

I know your love for NY teams is not any love at all, but at least you never (did I say never?) let your emotions cloud your take of the games. Jeter may not have the "range" but he sure is hot..definite eye candy for females to keep the interest alive.

As for me, any Hub with a title announcing how Boston will fall gets thumbs up from me :)


luckycraig profile image

luckycraig 5 years ago from Washington

The way they looked this opening series, you may be right!


ballfan92 profile image

ballfan92 5 years ago

And especially because they've started terribly this year I just wrote a hub myself on their struggles. Great hub.


Jon Hunt profile image

Jon Hunt 5 years ago

Well, I am just glad that you're wrong about Gonzo and Paps!


I am DB Cooper profile image

I am DB Cooper 5 years ago from Whereabouts unknown at this time Author

It's good to see the Red Sox doing better than my expectations. Pedroia and Ellsbury have really stepped up this year, and Gonzalez has actually played up to expectations. The fact that they've played so well the past 2 months with a pitching rotation that seems to feature a random AAA pitcher every other day is remarkable. If they can get their full pitching rotation healthy and playing well, this is the team to beat.


Billrrrr profile image

Billrrrr 5 years ago from Cape Cod

All things considered, this was a pretty good analysis of the Sox team. Nice job.

The game is all about timing. The Red Sox won 90 games in the regular season...the same number as the Cardinals.

At season's end the Cards were hot, the sox were not. Final result. Sox - zip Cards - World Champs

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working