Both are very good but it would have to be Wayne Rooney with out a doubt, so I think Alex Ferguson's decision to not sign Tevez might not have been great but it certainly was not wrong, time will show that Rooney will be a far greater player in the future
Both are top quality players though Rooney is undoubtedly better in skill and finishing, but tends to lose his temper...but after watching Tevez score the penalty against United even after taunts from his old teammates, I feel Ferguson made a really big mistake by selling him.
They are different players. Rooney is the better player I agree, but you cannot disagree that Tevez is the more tenacious and perhaps skillful of the two. Rooney's recent heading form shows he can easily add more strings to his bow though.
Please check out my weekly review of English football. Review of the top 4 divisions, surprising stats and features such as player/goal/save of the week. Features this week include man city v chelsea, carling cup final and Aaron Ramsey's unfortunate injury. http://hubpages.com/hub/Stans-Statistic … land-Vol-6